Site icon Thomas J. Daley

Continuous Substance Abuse Supports Termination Best-Interest Evidence | In re K.H. (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

In the Interest of K.H., a Child, 02-26-00330-CV, November 12, 2026.

On appeal from 97th District Court, Clay County, Texas

Synopsis

The Second Court of Appeals held that legally and factually sufficient evidence supported the trial court’s clear-and-convincing finding that terminating both parents’ rights was in the child’s best interest under Texas Family Code Section 161.001(b)(2). The court emphasized the parents’ longstanding substance-abuse histories, prior child-protection involvement, repeated treatment followed by relapse, and inconsistent testimony, and it affirmed the termination judgment.

Relevance to Family Law

Although In re K.H. is a termination case, its treatment of substance-abuse evidence has broader significance in divorce and SAPCR litigation. Evidence of recurrent drug use, unsuccessful treatment, relapse, prior CPS involvement, and a parent’s lack of candor may affect conservatorship, possession restrictions, supervised visitation, injunctions, and drug-testing orders under the best-interest framework applicable to custody disputes.

The opinion also illustrates the importance of presenting a parent’s history as a longitudinal pattern rather than as a collection of isolated incidents. In a custody modification or contested divorce, the same evidence may support findings concerning parental stability, endangerment, material and substantial change, or the need for safeguards protecting the child. The decision does not establish a property-division rule, but substance abuse can still affect property litigation when it relates to waste, reimbursement, dissipation of community assets, credibility, or the feasibility of a proposed parenting arrangement.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Mother and Father were in a relationship beginning around 2018, and their daughter, Katie, was born in June 2022. Both parents had histories of substance abuse and prior involvement with child-protection agencies concerning their older children.

Father testified that he had used drugs intermittently since he was approximately eighteen years old. His history included marijuana, methamphetamine, opioids or pain medication, alcohol abuse, criminal proceedings, probation, inpatient treatment, halfway-house placement, twelve-step programming, and child-protection proceedings in multiple states. Some of Father’s older children had entered foster care or otherwise been removed from his care. He had been required to complete treatment and recovery services before children were returned to him.

The court identified significant inconsistencies in Father’s account of his history. His testimony concerning where he lived, when he used particular substances, when his children were returned, and when he met Mother did not fit into a coherent chronology. His testimony also indicated that he resumed marijuana and methamphetamine use after completing services and regaining custody of older children. Although Father had attended twelve-step meetings, he had progressed only to an early step and had not obtained a sponsor.

Mother likewise had a history of drug use and prior Department involvement. The Department had become involved with her older son in approximately 2018 or 2019 after marijuana was brought into the home. Mother acknowledged that she was responsible for bringing it there and participated in outpatient drug classes.

The Department contacted the family within days after Katie’s birth because of reported drug use in the home, including allegations that Father was using methamphetamine. Father’s urinalysis results in 2022 were positive for marijuana, and he admitted that he was smoking marijuana daily at the time. The evidence concerning his methamphetamine use was conflicting, but portions of his testimony indicated use during the period in which he was responsible for children.

Mother’s statements about her own methamphetamine history were also inconsistent. During a psychosocial assessment, she reported using methamphetamine before learning that she was pregnant and stopping approximately six weeks into the pregnancy. At trial, however, she testified that it had been at least fifteen years since she had used methamphetamine.

After a three-day trial conducted over multiple months, the trial court terminated both parents’ rights. Mother and Father appealed, but their sole appellate issue challenged the legal and factual sufficiency of the evidence supporting the best-interest finding.

Issues Decided

Because the parents’ sole appellate issue concerned best interest, the court did not revisit other components of the termination judgment that were not presented for review.

Rules Applied

Texas Family Code Section 161.001(b) requires proof by clear and convincing evidence of both a statutory predicate ground for termination and that termination is in the child’s best interest. Section 161.001(b)(2) supplies the best-interest requirement.

“Clear and convincing evidence” is the degree of proof that produces in the factfinder’s mind a firm belief or conviction regarding the truth of the allegations. See Tex. Fam. Code § 101.007.

For legal sufficiency review, an appellate court considers the evidence in the light most favorable to the finding, assumes that the factfinder resolved disputed facts in favor of the finding when it reasonably could have done so, and disregards evidence a reasonable factfinder could have disbelieved. The question is whether the evidence could permit a reasonable factfinder to form a firm belief or conviction that termination was in the child’s best interest. See In re J.F.C., 96 S.W.3d 256 (Tex. 2002).

For factual sufficiency review, the court considers the entire record, including evidence contrary to the finding. The court determines whether the disputed evidence is so significant that a reasonable factfinder could not have formed a firm belief or conviction in favor of the finding. See In re C.H., 89 S.W.3d 17 (Tex. 2002).

Best interest is evaluated under the nonexclusive considerations identified in Holley v. Adams, including:

See Holley v. Adams, 544 S.W.2d 367 (Tex. 1976). The Department need not prove every Holley factor, and undisputed evidence concerning one factor may be sufficient in a particular case. Evidence supporting a statutory predicate ground may also be probative of best interest.

Application

The court considered the evidence as a continuing pattern rather than treating each positive test, relapse, prior CPS case, or inconsistency as an isolated event. Father’s history extended over many years and included drug use, criminal proceedings, structured treatment, twelve-step participation, child-protection intervention, and the removal or displacement of older children. Of particular importance, treatment and the restoration of children to his care had not produced sustained sobriety. His testimony indicated that he returned to marijuana and methamphetamine use after completing services.

Father’s conflicting chronology also mattered. The trial court, as factfinder, was entitled to evaluate whether his inconsistent accounts reflected confusion, minimization, or a lack of candor about the scope and timing of his substance use. Those credibility determinations bore directly on whether Father recognized the danger, had achieved lasting behavioral change, and could provide a stable home.

The court likewise viewed Mother’s circumstances in the context of prior Department involvement, drug-related services, and inconsistent statements about methamphetamine use. Her trial testimony did not fully align with the history she supplied during her psychosocial assessment. The factfinder could consider that inconsistency when deciding whether Mother had accurately acknowledged her substance-abuse history and whether her claimed progress was reliable.

The parents’ history was especially relevant to the child’s present and future safety. The record showed that child-protection intervention and treatment had occurred before, yet substance abuse returned. The trial court could therefore infer that the risk was not confined to a remote period and that promises of future sobriety had to be evaluated against demonstrated relapse.

On legal sufficiency, the appellate court deferred to the trial court’s reasonable credibility choices and considered the evidence in the light favorable to the finding. On factual sufficiency, it examined the entire record, including contrary evidence and the parents’ explanations. The contrary evidence was not so significant that the trial court could not reasonably have formed a firm belief or conviction that termination served Katie’s best interest.

Holding

The Second Court of Appeals held that legally sufficient evidence supported the finding that termination of Mother’s and Father’s parental rights was in the child’s best interest. The evidence permitted a reasonable factfinder to form a firm belief or conviction under Section 161.001(b)(2).

The court separately held that the evidence was factually sufficient. After considering the entire record, the court concluded that the disputed and contrary evidence did not prevent a reasonable factfinder from reaching the best-interest finding under the clear-and-convincing standard.

Accordingly, the court overruled the parents’ sole issue and affirmed the termination judgment.

Practical Application

In re K.H. demonstrates that a best-interest case involving substance abuse should be built around chronology, recurrence, and parental insight. Proof of a single positive drug test may have limited force standing alone. Its significance increases when counsel connects it to earlier treatment, prior CPS proceedings, relapse after reunification, daily use, inconsistent disclosures, or drug use while children were in the parent’s care.

For the party seeking termination, restrictive conservatorship, or supervised possession, the presentation should explain why completed services did not eliminate the future risk. Treatment certificates and attendance records are not dispositive if later conduct shows relapse. Counsel should compare what the parent learned in treatment with what the parent did afterward.

For the responding parent, simply establishing participation in services is insufficient. The stronger defensive record will demonstrate sustained sobriety through objective testing, meaningful recovery work, stable housing and employment, credible relapse-prevention planning, and consistent testimony. Counsel should reconcile assessment statements, deposition testimony, discovery responses, criminal records, medical records, and trial testimony before the client takes the stand.

In ordinary custody litigation, the case supports careful development of evidence concerning how substance use affects parenting—not merely whether use occurred. Relevant proof may include impaired supervision, unsafe caregivers, unexplained absences, failure to exercise possession, instability in housing, use of community funds to purchase drugs, driving with a child after using substances, or repeated noncompliance with testing orders.

The opinion also reinforces the appellate importance of preserving distinct sufficiency complaints. Termination appeals implicate heightened review, but appellate courts continue to defer to reasonable credibility determinations. A party challenging best interest should identify the evidence contrary to each material inference and explain why it is sufficiently significant under the factual-sufficiency standard, rather than merely rearguing credibility.

Checklists

Building a Best-Interest Record

Preparing a Parent With a Substance-Abuse History

Litigating Drug Evidence in a Divorce or SAPCR

Preserving a Best-Interest Sufficiency Challenge

Citation

In re K.H., No. 02-26-00330-CV (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Nov. 12, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion

~~19931625-0241-4172-8c0a-af4a931b1094~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version