Ex parte Mitchell Wasek, 03-26-00036-CR, November 20, 2026.
On appeal from 167th District Court of Travis County
Synopsis
The Third Court of Appeals held that the 2015 version of Texas Penal Code § 21.15(b) survives First Amendment strict scrutiny because it is narrowly tailored to protect individuals from nonconsensual, sexually invasive recording. The statute is not facially overbroad, and an as-applied takings challenge was not cognizable through pretrial habeas corpus.
Relevance to Family Law
Family-law litigators should not treat ownership, possession, or control of the marital residence as authorization to make hidden recordings of a spouse, paramour, child, guest, or other occupant in a bathroom, changing area, bedroom, or other private setting. Even when a recording could produce relevant evidence concerning adultery, conservatorship, reimbursement, waste, or credibility, the method of obtaining it may expose the client to criminal liability under Section 21.15 and potentially implicate other criminal and civil privacy laws. The opinion also limits a constitutional attack that might otherwise be used to justify covert visual surveillance: the First Amendment does not invalidate a narrowly drawn prohibition against intentionally capturing intimate images without consent under circumstances involving a reasonable expectation of privacy.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
The State charged Mitchell Wasek with multiple violations of the 2015 version of Texas Penal Code § 21.15(b). That version made it an offense, without the other person’s consent and with intent to invade the person’s privacy, to record or transmit a visual image of an intimate area when the person had a reasonable expectation that the area was not subject to public view. It separately prohibited nonconsensual, privacy-invasive visual recording in a bathroom or changing room.
According to the probable-cause affidavit, hidden cameras were used to record thirteen men and women in multiple rooms—including bathrooms—at two properties owned by or rented to Wasek or his parents. Officers recovered sixty-eight audiovisual recordings that allegedly depicted individuals using the restroom, changing clothes, or engaging in sexual activity. The alleged victims were unaware of the cameras and had not consented to being recorded.
At least one camera was motion-activated and disguised as an electronic-device charger. Investigators also identified purchases of equipment described as spy cameras or hidden cameras, together with camera mounts, gaffer tape, tripods, high-capacity memory cards, and hard drives.
Wasek filed two pretrial applications for writ of habeas corpus. His facial challenge asserted that Section 21.15(b) was an unconstitutional content-based restriction on speech and was substantially overbroad. His as-applied challenge asserted that the statute effected an unconstitutional taking by limiting a property owner’s authority within the owner’s property. The trial court denied both applications, and the Third Court of Appeals affirmed.
Issues Decided
-
Whether the 2015 version of Texas Penal Code § 21.15(b) imposed a content-based restriction on protected visual expression that failed First Amendment strict scrutiny.
-
Whether Section 21.15(b) was facially overbroad because it prohibited a substantial amount of constitutionally protected expression in relation to its legitimate applications.
-
Whether an as-applied takings challenge to the statute was cognizable in a pretrial application for writ of habeas corpus.
-
Whether Wasek adequately presented an independent basis for construing the Texas Constitution more broadly than the First Amendment.
The court did not decide a vagueness challenge because Wasek abandoned that issue on appeal. It also did not reach the merits of the as-applied takings theory because that claim was not cognizable through the selected pretrial procedure.
Rules Applied
Texas Penal Code § 21.15(b), as applicable to the charged conduct, required both lack of consent and an intent to invade another person’s privacy. Subsection (b)(1) addressed visual images of statutorily defined intimate areas when the person had a reasonable expectation that the area was not subject to public view. Subsection (b)(2) addressed visual recording in bathrooms and changing rooms.
The court applied the following constitutional and procedural principles:
-
The purposeful creation of photographs and visual recordings can constitute expressive activity protected by the First Amendment. Ex parte Thompson, 442 S.W.3d 325, 334–37 (Tex. Crim. App. 2014).
-
A law directed at expression based on its content is presumptively unconstitutional unless it falls within an established category of unprotected speech or satisfies strict scrutiny. Reed v. Town of Gilbert, 576 U.S. 155, 163 (2015).
-
Strict scrutiny requires the State to establish that the restriction is necessary to serve a compelling governmental interest and is narrowly drawn to achieve that interest. Ex parte Lo, 424 S.W.3d 10, 15 (Tex. Crim. App. 2013).
-
A facial overbreadth claim is analytically distinct from a strict-scrutiny challenge. Overbreadth asks whether a statute prohibits a substantial amount of protected speech in relation to its legitimate sweep. Ex parte Lowry, 693 S.W.3d 388, 418 (Tex. Crim. App. 2024); Ex parte Nuncio, 662 S.W.3d 903, 920 (Tex. Crim. App. 2022).
-
A facial challenge to the portion of a statute defining the charged offense may be raised by pretrial habeas corpus, but pretrial habeas is not generally available to litigate an as-applied claim that depends upon development of the facts at trial.
-
A party seeking broader protection under the Texas Constitution must separately brief and support that state-constitutional argument. Merely invoking both constitutions does not require a separate state analysis.
The court’s analysis aligned with Ex parte Metzger, 610 S.W.3d 86 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 2020, pet. ref’d), and Ex parte Hamilton, 599 S.W.3d 312 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2020, pet. ref’d), both of which sustained the 2015 statute against comparable constitutional challenges.
Application
The court assumed without deciding that Section 21.15(b) was content based and reached some expression protected by the First Amendment. That assumption placed the burden on the State to satisfy strict scrutiny.
The State met that burden because the statute served the compelling governmental interest of protecting individuals from nonconsensual, sexually invasive visual recording. The statute did not broadly prohibit photography or videography merely because the subject objected to being recorded. Its operative elements narrowed criminal liability to recordings made without consent and with the specific intent to invade another person’s privacy.
Subsection (b)(1) imposed additional objective limitations. The visual image had to depict a statutorily defined intimate area, and the recorded person had to possess a reasonable expectation that the intimate area was not subject to public view. Subsection (b)(2) was likewise limited by location, applying to bathrooms and changing rooms—settings in which privacy interests are particularly acute.
Those limitations created a close relationship between the prohibited conduct and the privacy harm the Legislature sought to prevent. The statute targeted the nonconsensual creation of sexually invasive images rather than the discussion, criticism, or lawful documentation of matters occurring in public view.
The same limitations defeated the facial overbreadth claim. Although hypothetical applications might implicate protected expression, the relevant question was whether the statute prohibited a substantial amount of protected speech relative to its legitimate applications. Given the requirements of nonconsent, intent to invade privacy, intimate-area imagery or a protected location, and—in subsection (b)(1)—a reasonable expectation of privacy, the court concluded that the statute’s potentially unconstitutional reach was not substantial.
The property-based argument did not alter the facial analysis. Wasek asserted that application of the statute inside property owned or controlled by the person making the recording improperly subordinated the owner’s property rights to the privacy interests of others. The court did not adjudicate that theory on its merits. Instead, it held that the as-applied takings claim was not cognizable in pretrial habeas proceedings.
Holding
The court held that the 2015 version of Texas Penal Code § 21.15(b) survives First Amendment strict scrutiny. Protecting individuals against nonconsensual, sexually invasive recording is a compelling governmental interest, and the statute’s consent, intent, subject-matter, location, and reasonable-expectation-of-privacy requirements narrowly tailor the prohibition to that interest.
The court separately held that Section 21.15(b) is not facially overbroad. Any applications affecting protected expression were not substantial when measured against the statute’s legitimate prohibition of intentional, nonconsensual recording of intimate areas or persons in bathrooms and changing rooms.
The court further held that the as-applied takings challenge could not be resolved through pretrial habeas corpus. The court therefore affirmed the denial of relief without deciding whether the takings theory could prevail in another procedural posture.
Practical Application
Family-law counsel should distinguish between evidence that is relevant and evidence that may lawfully be created. A spouse’s ownership of the residence, payment of the mortgage, access to a room, or right to possess community property does not necessarily eliminate another occupant’s reasonable expectation of privacy or supply consent to intimate recording.
Before advising a client concerning cameras or recording devices, counsel should identify the proposed location, field of view, recording method, persons likely to be captured, and whether the device records audio. A camera used for ordinary exterior security is materially different from a concealed device directed toward a bathroom, dressing area, bed, or other place where intimate exposure is foreseeable.
In divorce litigation, covert visual recording may arise when a client seeks evidence of adultery or dissipation of community assets. The evidentiary objective does not displace Section 21.15’s elements. Discovery, subpoenas, financial tracing, admissions, third-party records, and properly obtained surveillance in locations open to public view generally present safer investigative alternatives.
In conservatorship litigation, a parent may propose in-home cameras to document the other parent’s conduct, a child’s condition, or compliance with temporary orders. Counsel should not assume that the best-interest standard authorizes surveillance that would otherwise violate criminal law. Cameras in children’s bedrooms, bathrooms, or changing areas require especially careful review because additional statutes may apply when minors are recorded.
In exclusive-use or occupancy disputes, possession of the marital residence should not be conflated with unrestricted authority to monitor everyone who enters it. Temporary orders may allocate possession between spouses, but they do not necessarily extinguish the privacy rights of children, guests, caregivers, tenants, or the nonpossessing spouse during authorized access.
The opinion concerns visual recording, but many hidden cameras also capture sound. Audio interception raises separate issues under Texas Penal Code § 16.02, federal wiretap law, and potential civil causes of action. A device should therefore be evaluated for both its visual and audio functions.
Finally, admissibility is a separate question from legality. Counsel receiving a recording should assess preservation, authentication, completeness, relevance, Rule 403 concerns, privileges, privacy protections, and the circumstances under which the recording was made. The file should be preserved without unnecessary dissemination, and counsel should avoid directing a client to continue potentially unlawful recording activity.
Checklists
Evaluate a Proposed Recording
- Identify every room or physical area within the camera’s field of view.
- Determine whether a bathroom, changing area, bedroom, or intimate activity could be captured.
- Identify all persons reasonably likely to be recorded.
- Determine whether each person has consented to the recording.
- Confirm whether consent is express, documented, limited, or revocable.
- Evaluate whether any subject would reasonably expect an intimate area not to be publicly visible.
- Determine whether the device is concealed, disguised, or motion activated.
- Confirm whether the device records audio as well as video.
- Review the current version of Texas Penal Code § 21.15, not merely the 2015 version addressed in Wasek.
- Consider less intrusive methods of obtaining the evidence.
Respond to a Client Who Already Has a Recording
- Instruct the client not to create additional recordings until counsel has completed a legal review.
- Preserve the original file, device, metadata, and storage media.
- Do not edit, crop, annotate, enhance, or overwrite the original.
- Determine when, where, and how the recording was created.
- Identify who installed, activated, accessed, copied, or transmitted the recording.
- Determine whether audio was captured.
- Limit dissemination while evaluating criminal, civil, privacy, and discovery consequences.
- Assess whether the recording or device is responsive to pending discovery requests.
- Evaluate preservation obligations and the risk of spoliation.
- Consider obtaining separate criminal-law advice when Section 21.15 or another penal statute may be implicated.
Develop Evidence Without Covert Intimate Recording
- Use requests for production, interrogatories, admissions, and depositions.
- Subpoena financial institutions, employers, hotels, communications providers, and other appropriate custodians.
- Trace community funds through account records and transaction histories.
- Obtain public records and lawfully accessible social-media evidence.
- Use qualified investigators operating within lawful public-view boundaries.
- Seek temporary orders concerning access, property preservation, or prohibited conduct.
- Request an inspection, inventory, appraisal, or neutral forensic examination when appropriate.
- Consider appointment of an amicus attorney, attorney ad litem, custody evaluator, or other authorized professional in conservatorship disputes.
- Build corroboration through witnesses and records rather than relying on a single disputed recording.
Prepare to Use or Challenge a Recording
- Establish or contest authentication under Texas Rule of Evidence 901.
- Examine metadata, timestamps, continuity, and possible editing.
- Identify the device and software used to create and store the file.
- Determine whether the recording fairly and accurately depicts the relevant event.
- Analyze hearsay issues separately from visual authentication.
- Evaluate relevance and the danger of unfair prejudice under Rule 403.
- Consider whether intimate portions should be redacted, sealed, or reviewed in camera.
- Seek an appropriate protective order before producing sensitive material.
- Address completeness and contextual portions of the recording.
- Preserve objections concerning the manner of acquisition without assuming that illegality automatically resolves admissibility.
Frame a Pretrial Constitutional Challenge
- Distinguish a facial challenge from an as-applied challenge.
- Identify whether the challenged statutory provision defines the charged offense.
- Separate strict-scrutiny analysis from overbreadth analysis.
- Brief federal and Texas constitutional grounds independently.
- Explain why the Texas Constitution should provide broader protection if that position is asserted.
- Confirm that the requested relief is cognizable through pretrial habeas corpus.
- Avoid using pretrial habeas to present a fact-dependent defense requiring adjudication at trial.
- Preserve any noncognizable as-applied argument through the proper trial and appellate procedure.
Citation
Ex parte Mitchell Wasek, Nos. 03-26-00034-CR through 03-26-00039-CR, slip op. (Tex. App.—Austin Nov. 20, 2026, no pet. h.).
Full Opinion
Family Law Crossover
The principal procedural crossover is the use—and limitation—of a pretrial application for writ of habeas corpus to challenge the constitutionality of the statute defining a charged offense. A facial challenge may be resolved before trial because it presents a legal question concerning whether the statute is valid across its applications. By contrast, a fact-dependent as-applied challenge generally cannot be used to obtain pretrial adjudication of the prosecution’s evidence or a defense that depends on the particular circumstances of the alleged conduct.
That distinction can matter when criminal allegations concerning recordings overlap with a divorce or conservatorship case. A party charged under Section 21.15 may pursue an available facial constitutional challenge through pretrial habeas, but property ownership, consent, camera placement, privacy expectations, and the recording’s contents may present fact-specific questions reserved for the criminal proceeding. The family court likewise should not be asked to treat a pending constitutional challenge as establishing that the recording was lawful.
Substantively, the crossover rule is that property rights and privacy rights are separate inquiries. Ownership or possession of the marital residence may be relevant to access, control, and property division, but it does not categorically defeat the statutory protection afforded to a person who does not consent to an intentionally privacy-invasive recording. Family-law counsel should therefore evaluate surveillance evidence under the governing privacy and recording statutes before attempting to use it in divorce, conservatorship, enforcement, or property litigation.
~~8d36e965-087b-4cb1-b90c-959c6f9ccb84~~
Share this content:

