Degarius Rayshunn Curry v. The State of Texas, 05-25-01506-CR, November 20, 2026.
On appeal from 204th Judicial District Court, Dallas County, Texas
Synopsis
Texas Rule of Evidence 605 prohibits the presiding judge from testifying as a witness, but it does not convert judicial questions or record-based comments into testimony. Because the trial judge’s questions and comments in Curry addressed the appellant’s testimony and materials before the court rather than supplying facts from the judge’s personal knowledge, the Fifth Court of Appeals found no Rule 605 violation.
Relevance to Family Law
Although Curry arose from a deferred-adjudication revocation proceeding, its evidentiary rule applies directly to Texas divorce, conservatorship, possession, enforcement, contempt, and protective-order hearings. Family courts frequently question parties, clarify financial schedules, test competing accounts of family violence, or refer to pleadings, prior orders, and court files. Curry confirms that such participation is not automatically testimony under Rule 605, but it also highlights the critical boundary: the court may examine the evidence before it, yet it may not become a source of evidence by supplying material facts from personal knowledge.
The distinction is particularly important in bench trials and temporary-orders hearings, where the court often takes an active role. Counsel should separate a true Rule 605 problem from related but analytically distinct objections involving judicial notice, hearsay, lack of authentication, evidence outside the record, or the appearance of partiality.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
Degarius Rayshunn Curry pleaded guilty to aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. The trial court deferred adjudication and placed him on community supervision for four years. The State later moved to adjudicate guilt, alleging that Curry committed a new assault-family-violence offense in Denton County and failed to participate in a required felony domestic-violence course.
Curry pleaded true to the alleged violations but requested continued community supervision. During his testimony, he disputed or minimized facts associated with both the original Dallas County offense and the subsequent Denton County offense. The original offense involved an allegation that he pointed a rifle at his girlfriend’s head and threatened to kill her. The Denton County case involved an allegation that he punched his pregnant girlfriend in the stomach.
The trial court admitted Curry’s written plea of true and stipulation of evidence. Without objection, the court also took judicial notice of the contents of its file and the Dallas County probation file. During cross-examination, the prosecutor referred to a Denton County probable-cause affidavit. When Curry offered a different account of how the Denton County matter had been reported, the judge stated that she had read the affidavit and questioned him about discrepancies between his testimony and the officer’s account.
The trial court adjudicated Curry guilty and sentenced him to fifteen years’ imprisonment. On appeal, Curry argued that the judge had abandoned neutrality, considered information outside the record, and effectively testified in violation of Texas Rule of Evidence 605.
Issues Decided
- Whether the judge’s questions and comments demonstrated judicial bias or an abandonment of the role of neutral adjudicator in violation of due process and due course of law.
- Whether the trial court improperly considered a Denton County probable-cause affidavit or other evidence outside the record when determining punishment.
- Whether the judge’s references to record materials and questions directed to Curry constituted testimony by the presiding judge in violation of Texas Rule of Evidence 605.
- Whether the absence of a contemporaneous objection prevented appellate review of the judicial-bias and outside-the-record complaints.
Rules Applied
Texas Rule of Evidence 605 provides that the presiding judge may not testify as a witness at trial. The rule further states that a party need not object to preserve a claim that the judge violated Rule 605. The prohibition is directed at the judge acting as an evidentiary witness; it does not categorically prevent a judge from questioning a witness, clarifying testimony, or commenting on materials properly before the court.
Texas Rule of Evidence 614(b) separately permits a court to examine a witness regardless of which party called the witness. That authority does not permit the court to supply missing proof or communicate material facts obtained through personal knowledge outside the judicial proceeding.
Due process and due course of law require a neutral and detached decision-maker in a community-supervision revocation proceeding. At the same time, neutrality does not require the trial judge to remain silent. Judicial remarks, critical questions, and adverse rulings ordinarily do not establish bias unless the record shows reliance on an extrajudicial source or such a high degree of favoritism or antagonism that fair judgment becomes impossible. The court relied on principles discussed in Brumit v. State, 206 S.W.3d 639 (Tex. Crim. App. 2006), and Liteky v. United States, 510 U.S. 540 (1994).
The court also applied the rule that the entire record must be examined when judicial bias is alleged. Absent a clear showing of bias, the trial court’s conduct is presumed correct. Revocation and adjudication decisions are reviewed for abuse of discretion, with the central inquiry being whether the defendant received due process.
Although the record reflected no objection to the court’s questions, comments, or references to the affidavit, the Fifth Court assumed without deciding that Curry’s constitutional judicial-bias claims could be reviewed. Rule 605 itself does not require an objection to preserve a complaint that the judge testified.
Application
The Fifth Court examined the challenged exchanges in the context of the full adjudication hearing. Curry had pleaded true to the State’s allegations, admitted that he had not progressed beyond the first phase of the required domestic-violence course, and acknowledged that he had accepted deferred adjudication in the Denton County case. He nevertheless disputed important aspects of the underlying conduct while asking the trial court to continue his community supervision.
The judge’s questions focused on inconsistencies between Curry’s testimony and the information reflected in the materials under discussion at the hearing. The prosecutor had referred to the Denton County probable-cause affidavit during cross-examination, and neither the prosecutor’s use of the document nor the court’s references to it drew an objection. The court had also taken judicial notice of the court file and probation file without objection. Curry testified that he had provided documents concerning the Denton County case to his Dallas County probation officer, supporting the inference that the information was included in the probation materials before the court.
Against that record, the court of appeals rejected the characterization of the probable-cause affidavit as necessarily extrajudicial information. Nothing established that the judge obtained knowledge she was not entitled to possess or relied on facts acquired through a personal, nonjudicial source. The judge’s questions tested Curry’s account against information associated with a charged violation and relevant to sentencing.
The same reasoning defeated the Rule 605 claim. The judge did not take the witness stand, offer personal knowledge of the assaults, or provide an independent factual account of events. She questioned Curry and commented on discrepancies between his testimony and record-based information. Those judicial acts did not become witness testimony merely because they communicated skepticism about his account.
The court also distinguished active judicial participation from constitutionally disqualifying bias. A trial court’s questioning may be direct or critical without demonstrating that the court has abandoned neutrality. Viewed in context, the challenged remarks reflected the court’s evaluation of credibility and the sentencing evidence rather than an extrajudicial prejudice that made fair judgment impossible.
Holding
The Fifth Court held that the trial judge’s questions and comments did not violate Texas Rule of Evidence 605. Rule 605 prohibits the presiding judge from serving as a witness, but it does not classify ordinary judicial questioning, clarification, or record-based commentary as testimony.
The court also rejected Curry’s due-process and due-course claims. Considering the entire hearing, the record did not clearly demonstrate judicial bias, partiality, or an abandonment of the court’s adjudicative role.
The court further concluded that Curry had not established that the trial court relied on evidence improperly obtained from outside the record. The probable-cause affidavit had been discussed without objection, the court had taken judicial notice of relevant files without objection, and the record did not show that the judge possessed material knowledge from an improper extrajudicial source.
The Fifth Court therefore affirmed the judgment adjudicating Curry guilty and imposing a fifteen-year sentence.
Family Law Crossover
The procedural mechanism in Curry is the interaction between Rule 605’s prohibition on judicial testimony and the court’s authority to question witnesses and evaluate the evidentiary record. In a Texas family-law proceeding, the issue may arise when the judge asks a parent about statements in a social study, compares testimony with a prior temporary order, questions a spouse about an inventory and appraisement, or refers to documents contained in the court’s file.
The operative distinction is between adjudication and evidence creation. A judge may ask questions designed to clarify testimony, resolve inconsistencies, understand exhibits, or evaluate credibility. Those questions do not become testimony simply because they reveal that the court has read the record or doubts a witness’s explanation. Rule 605 is implicated when the judge supplies material facts based on personal knowledge—such as recounting an unrecorded event, independently describing a party’s conduct, or introducing information obtained outside the proceedings.
Counsel should also distinguish Rule 605 from judicial notice. A court’s awareness that a pleading, order, or document exists does not necessarily establish the truth of every factual assertion in that document. If the court refers to allegations in another case, an unsworn report, a prior affidavit, or a document that has not been admitted, counsel should identify the precise evidentiary problem. Depending on the circumstances, the appropriate objection may concern hearsay, authentication, relevance, improper judicial notice, lack of notice and an opportunity to respond, or consideration of evidence outside the record—not Rule 605 alone.
Practical Application
In a conservatorship trial, the court may question a parent about a discrepancy between live testimony and an admitted family-violence exhibit. Under Curry, the fact that the judge identifies the discrepancy does not mean the judge has become a witness. The analysis changes if the court states that it personally observed an event outside the courtroom or learned disputed facts through an off-record communication.
In a temporary-orders hearing, the judge may ask targeted questions about possession schedules, school attendance, account balances, or the source of funds used to pay expenses. Counsel should treat those questions as part of the evidentiary examination and ensure that the witness answers from personal knowledge. If the question assumes an unproved fact, counsel should object to the premise rather than broadly asserting that the judge is testifying.
In property litigation, a court may compare a spouse’s testimony with an admitted inventory, bank statement, business record, or prior sworn pleading. That comparison ordinarily reflects judicial evaluation of the record. But counsel should object if the court relies on private calculations, outside research concerning disputed adjudicative facts, or documents that were never admitted or properly noticed.
In protective-order and family-violence proceedings, judicial questioning may be especially pointed because credibility and immediate safety concerns are central. Curry demonstrates that forceful credibility testing is not, without more, testimony or bias. The record must show that the judge supplied evidence from personal knowledge or displayed a level of antagonism or favoritism that made fair adjudication impossible.
In enforcement and contempt proceedings, precision is essential because the court may possess extensive familiarity with prior orders and hearings. The judge may refer to the terms of an existing order, but counsel should ensure that any disputed historical facts are established through admissible evidence. Familiarity with the case file does not eliminate the movant’s burden of proof.
Finally, Curry reinforces the importance of differentiated preservation. Rule 605 expressly dispenses with the need for an objection to judicial testimony, but that exception should not be treated as covering every complaint about judicial questioning. Objections based on hearsay, improper judicial notice, lack of authentication, relevance, or consideration of material outside the record ordinarily should be made promptly and specifically.
Checklists
When the Court Questions a Witness
- Identify whether the question seeks clarification or supplies a disputed fact.
- Determine whether the assumed facts are supported by admitted evidence, stipulated facts, or a proper subject of judicial notice.
- Allow legitimate clarification while protecting against questions that shift the burden of proof or introduce unsupported premises.
- If necessary, object to the specific evidentiary defect rather than characterizing all judicial questioning as testimony.
- Request an opportunity to conduct follow-up examination after the court finishes questioning.
- Make a clear record identifying the source—or absence of a source—for the fact at issue.
Evaluating a Potential Rule 605 Violation
- Ask whether the judge communicated a material factual assertion rather than posing a question or evaluating existing evidence.
- Determine whether the asserted fact came from the record or from the judge’s personal knowledge.
- Identify whether the judge described an event the judge personally witnessed outside the judicial proceeding.
- Distinguish record-based comments from information obtained through an extrajudicial source.
- State on the record why the judicial statement adds evidence rather than merely commenting on evidence.
- Request appropriate relief, including clarification, an instruction that the statement will not be treated as evidence, recusal, or mistrial when legally justified.
Challenging Reliance on Court Files or Other Proceedings
- Ask the court to identify the document or file being considered.
- Determine whether the document has been admitted, stipulated to, or properly judicially noticed.
- Distinguish judicial notice of a document’s existence from acceptance of disputed allegations as true.
- Assert hearsay, authentication, relevance, and due-process objections separately when applicable.
- Request an opportunity to inspect the material and present contrary evidence.
- Obtain a ruling on each objection.
- Ensure that the document or an appropriate offer of proof is included in the appellate record.
Preserving Judicial-Bias and Outside-the-Record Complaints
- Object promptly when the basis for the complaint becomes apparent.
- Identify the specific question, comment, ruling, or information at issue.
- Explain whether the complaint concerns bias, judicial notice, Rule 605, or another evidentiary rule.
- Avoid relying solely on Rule 605’s no-objection provision for analytically distinct claims.
- Request clarification concerning whether the court is relying on challenged material.
- Seek a running objection if the issue will recur.
- Consider a motion for recusal, motion for mistrial, or motion for new trial when supported by the record and applicable procedure.
- Secure the reporter’s record and ensure that all referenced exhibits and judicially noticed materials appear in the clerk’s record.
Preparing for an Active Bench Trial
- Organize exhibits so the court can readily identify the evidentiary source for each disputed fact.
- Anticipate inconsistencies among testimony, pleadings, inventories, social studies, prior orders, and discovery responses.
- Prepare witnesses to answer direct judicial questions without speculation or argument.
- Correct inaccurate factual premises respectfully and with a citation to the record.
- Ask for limited redirect or recross after judicial questioning.
- Propose express findings when the distinction between admitted evidence and noticed material may affect appellate review.
Citation
Curry v. State, No. 05-25-01506-CR (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 20, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
~~88e68902-cf4e-4d49-a68e-e057f8434996~~
Share this content:

