Site icon Thomas J. Daley

CROSSOVER: No Asset Proof, No Receiver: Turnover Relief Requires Evidence of a Spouse’s Nonexempt Property

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Concord Surgical Care, LLC and Lori S. Aaron v. Dania Rimlawi, 05-26-00272-CV, November 18, 2026.

On appeal from 193rd Judicial District Court, Dallas County, Texas

Synopsis

A judgment alone does not support turnover relief or appointment of a receiver under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 31.002. The judgment creditor must present substantive, probative evidence that the judgment remains unpaid and that the debtor presently owns nonexempt property; an unverified application and unauthenticated documents never admitted into evidence do not satisfy that burden.

Relevance to Family Law

This evidentiary requirement applies when a family-law litigant uses § 31.002 to collect a final money judgment, including a property-division equalization judgment, contractual payment obligation reduced to judgment, attorney’s-fee award, or sanctions award. The same issue may arise after divorce when a creditor spouse seeks turnover of business interests, distributions, accounts, receivables, or other assets allegedly controlled by the debtor spouse. Although child-support and spousal-maintenance enforcement may involve additional remedies under the Texas Family Code, a practitioner invoking the general turnover statute must still prove each statutory prerequisite with admissible evidence.

The opinion also highlights the distinction between evidence that an asset exists and evidence that the judgment debtor owns it. Financial information concerning a spouse, a related entity, or an affiliated business does not establish that the actual judgment debtor owns nonexempt property unless the proponent supplies competent evidence connecting the debtor to the asset.

Family Law Crossover

Section 31.002 is a post-judgment collection mechanism, not a substitute for discovery or a vehicle for determining disputed ownership. The creditor bears the initial burden to establish an existing judgment, nonpayment, and the debtor’s ownership of property that is not exempt from attachment, execution, or seizure. Once those elements are supported by substantive, probative evidence, the trial court may order turnover or appoint a receiver to take possession of the identified nonexempt property, sell it, and apply the proceeds to the judgment.

In a Texas family-law matter, this procedure may arise when a former spouse does not satisfy a money judgment contained in a divorce decree or when a party seeks to collect an attorney’s-fee judgment entered in divorce, custody, modification, or enforcement litigation. The application should identify the property or property category at issue, establish the debtor’s ownership with admissible evidence, and address exemption status. If ownership belongs to a separate entity or third party, the creditor must establish a legally sufficient nexus rather than relying merely on personal, familial, or managerial relationships.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Dania Rimlawi obtained an arbitration award providing for a $22,500 severance payment, a $250,000 bonus payment, interest, and attorney’s fees. Seven months later, she filed suit to confirm and enforce that award. On July 22, 2024, the trial court rendered a default judgment confirming the arbitration award.

Rimlawi later filed an unverified application for a turnover order and appointment of a receiver. She attached copies of the arbitration award and default judgment. Concord Surgical Care, LLC and Lori S. Aaron responded that the application lacked evidence showing that Concord possessed nonexempt property subject to turnover.

Five days before the hearing, Rimlawi filed a letter enclosing exhibits she intended to introduce. Those materials included a one-page summary of Lori and Phillip Aaron’s personal finances as of January 31, 2019, and a 2021 financial statement for Minimally Invasive Surgery Institute, LLC. The personal-finance summary did not identify its author or the source of its information, and the financial statement did not explain how the other entity’s assets were connected to Concord. Neither document was authenticated or offered into evidence.

At the hearing, Rimlawi’s counsel stated that Rimlawi was willing to testify about Concord’s financial worth. She was not called as a witness, however, and no other evidence was offered. The trial court granted the turnover application and appointed a receiver.

Issues Decided

Rules Applied

Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 31.002(a) permits a court to aid a judgment creditor in reaching property to satisfy a judgment when the judgment debtor owns property that cannot readily be attached or levied upon by ordinary legal process and that is not exempt from attachment, execution, or seizure. Under § 31.002(b)(3), the court may appoint a receiver to take possession of the debtor’s nonexempt property, sell it, and apply the proceeds to the judgment.

The judgment creditor bears the initial burden to establish:

  1. The existence of an underlying judgment;
  2. That the judgment remains unpaid; and
  3. That the judgment debtor owns nonexempt property.

Under Vaccaro v. Raymond James & Associates, Inc., 655 S.W.3d 485, 489 (Tex. App.—Fort Worth 2022, no pet.), the creditor must present substantive, probative evidence of each element. The Dallas Court of Appeals also relied on Diaz v. SMS Financial Capital, LLC, No. 05-21-00696-CV, 2023 WL 5604236, at *6 (Tex. App.—Dallas Aug. 30, 2023, no pet.), for the principle that a trial court abuses its discretion by granting § 31.002 relief when the creditor fails to establish all required elements.

An unverified application is not evidence. See Weir v. Sterling State Bank, No. 05-16-00500-CV, 2017 WL 1684634, at *1 (Tex. App.—Dallas May 2, 2017, no pet.). Likewise, documents merely filed with the court do not become evidence when they are not authenticated, offered, and admitted.

Application

The arbitration award and default judgment established that a judgment existed against Concord. They did not, however, prove that Concord presently owned any nonexempt property subject to turnover. Nor did they independently establish all other elements required by § 31.002.

The additional financial documents did not cure the evidentiary deficiency. The summary of the Aarons’ personal finances was unauthenticated, did not disclose its author or information source, and concerned financial information from years before the turnover hearing. The separate financial statement concerned MISI, not Concord, and contained no evidence connecting MISI’s assets to the judgment debtor. Most importantly, neither document was offered or admitted into evidence.

Counsel’s statement that Rimlawi was willing to testify likewise supplied no evidence. Rimlawi never took the stand, and the trial court therefore received no testimony regarding Concord’s ownership of property, the property’s present location or value, or its nonexempt status.

Because the evidentiary record proved only the existence of the judgment, the trial court had no substantive, probative evidence supporting every statutory prerequisite. The breadth of a trial court’s discretion in fashioning turnover relief does not eliminate the creditor’s initial evidentiary burden.

Holding

The court held that turnover relief and appointment of a receiver under § 31.002 require substantive, probative evidence that the judgment debtor owns nonexempt property. Proof of an underlying judgment, by itself, is insufficient.

The court further held that an unverified application is not evidence and that unauthenticated documents not offered into evidence cannot support a turnover order. Filing documents before the hearing did not make them part of the evidentiary record.

Because Rimlawi failed to present evidence establishing all elements required for turnover relief—including Concord’s ownership of nonexempt property—the trial court abused its discretion by granting the application and appointing a receiver. The court of appeals reversed the order and remanded the matter for further proceedings.

Practical Application

For family-law litigators, the central lesson is to treat a turnover hearing as an evidentiary proceeding—not as a routine presentment of a proposed order. The decree or fee judgment proves only one part of the required case. Counsel should be prepared to prove nonpayment, current ownership, and nonexempt status through admissible testimony, authenticated records, discovery responses, and other competent evidence.

In post-divorce property enforcement, useful evidence may include current bank records, brokerage statements, business ownership records, K-1s, distribution statements, accounts-receivable reports, vehicle titles, real-property records, and authenticated financial statements. The evidence should connect the asset to the specific judgment debtor and should be sufficiently current to support an inference of present ownership.

Entity separateness requires particular attention. Evidence that a former spouse manages a company, receives compensation from it, or is related to its owners does not necessarily establish that the spouse owns the company’s assets. Counsel should distinguish among ownership of an entity interest, rights to distributions, wages, accounts receivable, and assets owned directly by the entity. A turnover order ordinarily cannot be used to bypass those distinctions.

The creditor should also address exemptions with precision. Homestead interests, current wages, retirement assets, and other property may be protected by constitutional or statutory exemptions, subject to exceptions and specialized family-law enforcement provisions. The application and proof should identify why the particular asset is legally reachable rather than relying on a generalized assertion that the debtor has financial resources.

For the responding party, the most effective objection may be a record-based challenge to the creditor’s proof. Counsel should object when documents are unauthenticated, ownership is speculative, the evidence is stale, third-party assets are treated as the debtor’s property without a legal nexus, or the application is offered as though its allegations were evidence.

Checklists

Preparing a Turnover Application

Building the Evidentiary Record

Pursuing a Family-Law Money Judgment

Opposing Unsupported Turnover Relief

Drafting the Proposed Order

Citation

Concord Surgical Care, LLC and Lori S. Aaron v. Dania Rimlawi, No. 05-26-00272-CV, slip op. (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 18, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion

~~66aac43f-6ea2-45c4-89c2-3ae3fb2761d8~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version