Archer v. State, 05-25-01090-CR, November 16, 2026.
On appeal from 15th Judicial District Court, Grayson County, Texas
Synopsis
An affirmative statement of “no objection” when evidence is offered forfeits an earlier objection unless the record demonstrates that the party did not intend to abandon the prior objection. Because Archer’s counsel stated “no objection” when the protective order was admitted, the Fifth Court of Appeals held that the evidentiary complaint was waived under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 33.1.
Relevance to Family Law
Although Archer is a criminal case, its preservation holding applies directly to evidentiary disputes in divorce, conservatorship, protective-order, enforcement, and property litigation. Family-law attorneys frequently obtain pretrial rulings concerning family-violence evidence, recordings, criminal records, financial documents, expert opinions, and third-party records. If counsel later affirmatively states “no objection” when the evidence is offered, the appellate court may treat that statement as an abandonment of the earlier objection. The lesson is especially important when multiple attorneys are trying a case or when a pretrial ruling, motion in limine, running objection, or hearing outside the factfinder’s presence creates uncertainty about what must be said when the exhibit is formally offered.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
James Edward Archer was convicted of continuous family violence and evading arrest with a motor vehicle. The trial court found two enhancement paragraphs true and sentenced him to thirty years’ confinement.
The complainant, Kimberly Trammell, had been in a dating relationship with Archer, and they had lived together. On October 12, 2023, she called 911, identified Archer, and reported that he was beating her. When police arrived, she appeared upset and panicked and had red marks on her neck. She reported that Archer had choked her the preceding night and struck the back of her head that day.
The evidence also showed that an emergency protective order had been issued approximately one month earlier. The order prohibited Archer from committing family violence against Trammell or her son. The State referred to the protective order during opening statement, and testimony and body-camera footage mentioning the order were presented without objection. Defense counsel also referenced the protective order during opening statement.
Before an investigator testified, Archer’s counsel objected outside the jury’s presence to the admission of the protective order. Counsel argued that the order was outside the scope of the charged offenses and was irrelevant. The trial court overruled the objection, expressing the view that the evidence was admissible under article 38.371 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.
During the investigator’s testimony, the State formally offered the protective order as State’s Exhibit 12. At that point, defense counsel stated, “No objection, Your Honor.” The exhibit was admitted. Archer later challenged its admission on appeal as improper extraneous-offense evidence that denied him a fair trial and the presumption of innocence.
Issues Decided
-
Whether Archer preserved an appellate challenge to the admission of the protective order after counsel had previously objected but affirmatively stated “no objection” when the exhibit was offered.
-
Whether the evidence was legally sufficient to support the convictions for continuous family violence and evading arrest or detention with a motor vehicle.
Rules Applied
-
Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 33.1(a). To preserve a complaint for appellate review, the record must show a timely request, objection, or motion stating the grounds for the requested ruling with sufficient specificity, followed by an express or implicit ruling.
-
Preservation as a systemic requirement. An appellate court must determine whether a complaint was preserved before reaching its merits. Darcy v. State, 488 S.W.3d 325, 327–28 (Tex. Crim. App. 2016).
-
Effect of “no objection.” When a party states that it has “no objection” to evidence, and the record does not demonstrate whether abandonment of an earlier objection was intended or understood, the statement ordinarily waives the previously preserved complaint. Thomas v. State, 408 S.W.3d 877, 885–86 (Tex. Crim. App. 2013).
-
Ambiguity is resolved in favor of waiver. If review of the entire record leaves it ambiguous whether counsel intended to waive the earlier objection, the ambiguity is resolved in favor of waiver. Stairhime v. State, 463 S.W.3d 902, 906 (Tex. Crim. App. 2015).
-
Relationship evidence in family-violence prosecutions. The trial court relied on article 38.371 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure in determining that evidence concerning the relationship between the accused and the alleged victim was admissible.
-
Legal-sufficiency review. A conviction is supported by legally sufficient evidence when, viewing the combined and cumulative force of the admitted evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict, a rational factfinder could find each element beyond a reasonable doubt. Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 318–19 (1979); David v. State, 663 S.W.3d 673, 678 (Tex. Crim. App. 2022).
Application
Archer initially presented an objection to the protective order during a hearing outside the jury’s presence. Standing alone, that objection and the trial court’s adverse ruling could have established a basis for appellate review. But the preservation analysis did not end with the pre-admission hearing.
When the State later offered the protective order as State’s Exhibit 12, defense counsel affirmatively stated, “No objection, Your Honor.” The appellate record contained no qualification preserving the earlier objection and no statement that counsel was relying on the trial court’s prior ruling. Nor did the record otherwise demonstrate that the “no objection” statement was limited to authenticity, foundation, or some other matter.
The broader trial record reinforced the waiver conclusion. The State discussed the protective order during opening statement without objection. Defense counsel also referred to it during opening statement. A police witness testified about the order without objection, and the jury heard references to it in body-camera footage. Counsel did not request or obtain a running objection to the investigator’s testimony concerning the order.
Under Thomas and Stairhime, the court treated the unqualified “no objection” statement as an abandonment of the earlier objection. Because preservation is a systemic prerequisite to appellate review, the court did not reach the merits of Archer’s extraneous-offense challenge.
The court also reviewed the sufficiency of the evidence under the deferential standard applicable to jury verdicts. Considering the admitted evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict, the court rejected Archer’s sufficiency challenge and affirmed both convictions.
Holding
The Fifth Court of Appeals held that Archer waived his complaint about the admission of the protective order. Although he objected during an earlier hearing, counsel’s subsequent and unqualified statement of “no objection” when the exhibit was formally offered forfeited the earlier objection under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 33.1.
The court further rejected Archer’s legal-sufficiency challenge to his convictions for continuous family violence and evading arrest or detention. It affirmed the trial court’s judgment in its entirety.
Practical Application
The procedural rule in Archer should be incorporated into trial planning for every Texas family-law case involving contested evidence.
-
Divorce proceedings: A party may obtain a pretrial ruling concerning bank records, business valuations, electronic communications, alleged waste, or evidence of a paramour. If counsel says “no objection” when the exhibit is later offered, the appellate challenge may be lost despite the earlier hearing.
-
Conservatorship and possession disputes: Evidence of family violence, substance use, criminal activity, CPS involvement, medical treatment, or mental-health history often becomes the subject of pretrial objections. Counsel must preserve the objection when the evidence is introduced and avoid language suggesting that the prior objection has been withdrawn.
-
Protective-order proceedings: Police reports, 911 recordings, body-camera footage, photographs, medical records, and evidence of prior incidents may be offered in rapid succession. A clear exhibit-by-exhibit preservation plan is essential, particularly when the court has already ruled on admissibility outside the witness’s presence.
-
Property disputes: Business records, appraisals, tracing schedules, summaries, and expert reports may draw objections based on hearsay, authentication, reliability, or unfair prejudice. An unqualified “no objection” can extinguish an appellate complaint even when counsel vigorously contested the evidence before trial.
-
Bench trials: The absence of a jury does not eliminate preservation requirements. Counsel should obtain a ruling and maintain the objection when the evidence is formally offered unless the record clearly establishes that the prior ruling remains operative.
-
Multiple-lawyer trial teams: Every attorney handling witnesses or exhibits must know which objections remain active. A second-chair lawyer’s “no objection” response can undermine a preservation strategy developed by lead counsel.
When a court has already ruled adversely, a safer response is: “Subject to and without waiving our prior objection and the court’s prior ruling, no additional objection.” Counsel should also consider requesting a running objection and ensuring that its scope—including the witnesses, subjects, and exhibits covered—is stated on the record.
Checklists
Before the Evidentiary Hearing
- Identify each exhibit or category of testimony likely to generate an appellate issue.
- State each legal ground with sufficient specificity.
- Obtain an express ruling on each objection.
- Confirm that the court reporter is present and that the exhibit is identified in the record.
- Determine whether the ruling is final or merely a ruling on a motion in limine.
- Ask whether the court will recognize the objection as continuing when the evidence is offered.
- Request a running objection when repeated testimony or related exhibits are anticipated.
- Define the precise scope of any running objection on the record.
When the Evidence Is Offered
- Do not respond with an unqualified “no objection” if an appellate complaint must be preserved.
- State that the exhibit is offered “subject to” the previously asserted objection.
- Reference the prior hearing and ruling sufficiently to eliminate ambiguity.
- Renew the objection if there is any doubt about whether the earlier ruling preserved it.
- Obtain a ruling if the trial court does not immediately rule.
- Distinguish between objections to authenticity, hearsay, relevance, unfair prejudice, and other grounds.
- Make clear if counsel has no objection to authenticity but maintains another admissibility objection.
- Request a limiting instruction when evidence is admissible for only a restricted purpose.
During Witness Examination
- Monitor testimony that communicates the same information contained in a disputed exhibit.
- Object before the witness answers whenever practicable.
- Move to strike an answer if the objectionable information is given before an objection can be made.
- Avoid allowing substantially similar evidence to enter elsewhere without objection.
- Confirm that a running objection covers the current witness and subject matter.
- Renew the objection if questioning moves beyond the scope of the running objection.
Managing a Trial Team
- Maintain an exhibit list identifying all pending and preserved objections.
- Brief every attorney on prior evidentiary rulings before the attorney handles a witness.
- Use a standard response for exhibits subject to prior objections.
- Assign one attorney to monitor preservation and obtain rulings.
- Conduct a record check before resting to identify unresolved objections or missing rulings.
- Confirm that excluded exhibits have been included in an offer of proof when necessary.
Protecting the Appellate Record
- Ensure the reporter’s record includes every relevant pretrial and bench conference.
- Make an offer of proof for excluded evidence.
- Secure a ruling on each objection, request, or motion.
- Confirm that disputed exhibits are correctly numbered and included in the clerk’s or reporter’s record.
- State any constitutional or statutory ground at trial rather than raising it for the first time on appeal.
- Avoid appellate arguments that do not comport with the objection made in the trial court.
- Review the record for later statements that could be construed as withdrawing or abandoning an earlier objection.
Citation
Archer v. State, No. 05-25-01090-CR (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 16, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
Read the full opinion in Archer v. State.
Family Law Crossover
The crossover rule is procedural: an affirmative and unqualified statement of “no objection” when evidence is offered may abandon an earlier objection and foreclose appellate review under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 33.1. If the record remains ambiguous about whether counsel intended to preserve or relinquish the earlier complaint, Archer applies the principle that the ambiguity is resolved in favor of waiver.
That mechanism can arise in a family-law case when the court rules before trial or outside the factfinder’s presence on the admissibility of family-violence allegations, protective orders, recordings, financial records, expert reports, social-media evidence, or third-party records. When the exhibit is later formally offered, counsel must ensure that the response is consistent with the preservation position already taken. The record should expressly reflect that the prior objection is renewed or maintained, or that any statement of “no additional objection” is subject to the earlier objection and ruling.
~~54ba236a-6f08-4c58-886f-2817e99165af~~
Share this content:

