Site icon Thomas J. Daley

CROSSOVER: No Reporter’s Record, No Sufficiency Challenge: Presumption Protects Texas Family-Court Findings

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Ragle, Inc. v. The Levy Company, Inc., 05-25-00814-CV, November 18, 2026.

On appeal from 44th Judicial District Court, Dallas County, Texas

Synopsis

A party cannot obtain meaningful appellate review of evidentiary challenges arising from a bench trial without providing the reporter’s record. When the record omits the trial evidence, the appellate court must presume that the missing evidence supports the trial court’s findings and judgment. Bennett v. Cochran, 96 S.W.3d 227, 230 (Tex. 2002).

Relevance to Family Law

Although Ragle is a commercial-contract case, its record-preservation rule applies directly to appeals from divorce, conservatorship, possession, child-support, property-division, reimbursement, and enforcement proceedings. Family-law judgments frequently rest on disputed testimony concerning credibility, valuation, tracing, best-interest factors, possession restrictions, earning capacity, and attorney’s fees. If the appellant does not provide a reporter’s record containing that evidence, challenges asserting that the findings are unsupported—or that the court should have weighed the evidence differently—will ordinarily fail under the presumption that the omitted evidence supports the judgment.

The consequence can extend beyond conventional sufficiency issues. A purported contract-construction, statutory, or abuse-of-discretion argument may still depend on what evidence was admitted, which defenses were tried, or what factual predicates the trial court resolved. Counsel should therefore distinguish a genuinely record-independent legal question from an issue that only appears legal but depends on the evidence presented at trial.

Family Law Crossover

Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6 supplies the procedural framework for including the reporter’s record in the appellate record. When an appellant challenges a bench-trial finding on legal- or factual-sufficiency grounds but provides no reporter’s record, the reviewing court cannot evaluate the testimony, exhibits, credibility determinations, or evidentiary conflicts that produced the finding. Under Bennett, the court must instead presume that the omitted evidence supports the trial court’s judgment.

In a Texas family-law matter, this mechanism may arise after a final divorce trial, a suit affecting the parent-child relationship, a modification proceeding, or an enforcement hearing. For example, an appellant challenging a disproportionate property division, a reimbursement finding, a geographic restriction, a child-support variance, or an attorney’s-fee award generally needs a record of the evidence on which the ruling was based. Findings of fact and conclusions of law identify the trial court’s determinations, but they do not substitute for the evidence needed to challenge those determinations.

The same concern applies when only part of the proceedings is recorded or requested. If the appellant elects to proceed with a partial reporter’s record, Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6(c) imposes specific requirements, including a statement of the points or issues to be presented. Compliance can produce a presumption that the designated partial record constitutes the entire record for those identified issues. An unexplained omission does not confer that protection.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

The Levy Company, Inc. sued Ragle, Inc. and Colonial American Casualty and Surety Company over unpaid electrical subcontract work performed on the Orange County Swing Bridge project. Levy alleged that it completed its work and was owed $122,219.83 under its final pay application. It also sought interest, attorney’s fees, and costs.

Ragle and Colonial denied liability, and Ragle asserted a counterclaim alleging that Levy’s deficient and delayed performance caused approximately $446,066 in damages. The trial court struck the counterclaim during a pretrial hearing, and the remaining dispute proceeded to a bench trial.

After trial, the court found that Levy completed its work and that Ragle refused to pay the final application without providing a written explanation. The court also found that project delays resulted from circumstances unrelated to Levy, including vessel accidents, design issues, other subcontractors, fabrication problems, defective equipment, and a TxDOT suspension of contract time.

The findings further stated that TxDOT increased Ragle’s performance period from 300 to 667 working days, assessed no liquidated damages against Ragle, and fully paid Ragle. Ragle had not formally assessed liquidated damages against Levy and had not paid delay damages to TxDOT. The court found that Levy did not cause delay outside the TxDOT suspension period and that Ragle sustained no damages from any delay attributed to Levy.

The trial court concluded that Ragle and Colonial materially breached the subcontract and were jointly and severally liable for Levy’s damages. It rendered judgment for $122,219.83 in principal, $14,997.39 in prejudgment interest, $60,222 in attorney’s fees, and $2,329 in court costs, together with postjudgment interest and conditional appellate fees.

Ragle and Colonial appealed, but the appellate record contained no reporter’s record from the bench trial.

Issues Decided

The Fifth Court of Appeals addressed whether:

Rules Applied

Texas appellate courts presume that omitted portions of the appellate record support the trial court’s judgment. When an appellant does not provide the reporter’s record necessary to evaluate an evidentiary complaint, the appellant cannot demonstrate that the evidence was legally or factually insufficient. Bennett v. Cochran, 96 S.W.3d 227, 230 (Tex. 2002); Vasquez v. Firebird SFE I, LLC, No. 05-19-00057-CV, 2020 WL 2059913, at *1 (Tex. App.—Dallas Apr. 29, 2020, no pet.) (mem. op.).

A legal-sufficiency challenge fails when more than a scintilla of evidence supports the challenged finding. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Canchola, 121 S.W.3d 735, 739 (Tex. 2003).

Ordinarily, a fee claimant must present sufficient evidence of reasonable hours and reasonable rates. The lodestar evidence should address the services performed, the persons who performed them, approximately when they were performed, the reasonable time required, and the applicable reasonable hourly rates. Rohrmoos Venture v. UTSW DVA Healthcare, LLP, 578 S.W.3d 469, 501–02 (Tex. 2019). Contemporaneous billing records are strongly encouraged but are not invariably required.

Chapter 38 provides an additional rule when the trial court determines attorney’s fees. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 38.004, the court may take judicial notice of usual and customary attorney’s fees and the contents of the case file. That judicial notice constitutes some evidence supporting the award. See Scott Pelley P.C. v. Wynne, 578 S.W.3d 694, 705 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2019, pet. denied); Logan v. Randall, No. 05-19-00043-CV, 2020 WL 948381, at *8 (Tex. App.—Dallas Feb. 27, 2020, pet. denied) (mem. op.).

Application

The appellants framed several issues in contractual terms, invoking the time-is-of-the-essence clause, delay provisions, and liquidated-damages language. But the resolution of those issues depended on the evidence presented at trial. The trial court had found that Levy completed its work, that unrelated events caused the project delays, that Levy caused no compensable delay, and that Ragle neither incurred nor assessed liquidated damages.

Without the reporter’s record, the court of appeals could not examine the testimony and exhibits underlying those findings. It therefore could not determine whether the evidence conclusively established a different result, whether the findings lacked more than a scintilla of supporting evidence, or whether the findings were against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence. Applying Bennett, the court presumed that the missing trial evidence supported each material finding.

That presumption also foreclosed the challenge to Colonial’s liability. The trial court found that Ragle materially breached the subcontract and that Ragle and Colonial were jointly and severally liable. Because the asserted absence of principal liability depended on overturning the underlying findings against Ragle, the missing reporter’s record prevented the appellants from establishing reversible error.

As to attorney’s fees, Levy submitted counsel’s affidavit identifying hourly rates and providing information concerning the attorneys involved in the representation. More importantly, the fee claim arose under Chapter 38 and was decided by the trial court rather than a jury. The trial court was permitted to take judicial notice of usual and customary fees and the contents of its file, and that judicial notice constituted some evidence supporting the award. The appellants therefore did not establish that the fee award lacked legally sufficient support.

Holding

The court held that the absence of a reporter’s record required it to presume that the trial evidence supported the findings that Levy performed, that project delays were not attributable to Levy, that Ragle sustained no delay damages, and that Ragle and Colonial materially breached their obligations. The court accordingly overruled the challenges concerning performance, delay, liquidated damages, and principal and surety liability.

The court also rejected the legal-sufficiency challenge to the attorney’s-fee award. In a Chapter 38 bench-trial proceeding, the trial court may take judicial notice of usual and customary fees and the contents of the case file, and that judicial notice supplies some evidence supporting the award.

The Fifth Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s judgment.

Practical Application

The lesson for family-law litigators is not merely “order the record.” Counsel must identify the portions of the proceedings necessary to overcome every presumption favoring the judgment.

In a property-division appeal, a reporter’s record is ordinarily essential when the complaint concerns characterization, tracing, valuation, reimbursement, fraud on the community, or the overall just-and-right division. Without the trial evidence, the appellate court generally must presume that the property division had sufficient evidentiary support.

In conservatorship and possession cases, the trial court’s decision typically turns on best-interest evidence and credibility determinations. A clerk’s record containing pleadings, orders, and findings does not reveal the testimony heard by the trial court. An appellant cannot ordinarily establish that a geographic restriction, possession condition, or conservatorship determination lacked evidentiary support without the relevant reporter’s record.

The same principle applies to child support and spousal maintenance. Challenges involving net resources, intentional unemployment or underemployment, proven needs, statutory eligibility, duration, or deviation from the guidelines ordinarily require the evidence from the hearing.

In enforcement proceedings, the record may be necessary to evaluate proof of the underlying order, notice, noncompliance, affirmative defenses, ability to comply, and attorney’s fees. If multiple hearings contribute to the final ruling, counsel should confirm that the record includes each material hearing rather than assuming that the final merits hearing alone is sufficient.

Finally, findings of fact and conclusions of law do not cure the absence of a reporter’s record. Findings define what must be challenged, but the reporter’s record supplies the evidence needed to demonstrate that a challenged finding is unsupported.

Checklists

Preserve the Trial Record

Perfect the Appellate Record

Proceed Carefully With a Partial Reporter’s Record

Evaluate Findings and Sufficiency Issues

Preserve Family-Law Fee Issues

Citation

Ragle, Inc. v. The Levy Company, Inc., No. 05-25-00814-CV (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 18, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion

~~34607140-3364-4d91-90f1-bc47e0eed3d4~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version