Kenyetta Hickmon, Individually, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Hickmon and as Next Friend of M.H. and E.H., Minors, Ashley Monae Hicks, Linda Louise Williams, and Orestia Williams v. Aqib Talib, 05-25-00730-CV, November 13, 2026.
On appeal from 193rd Judicial District Court, Dallas County, Texas
Synopsis
A plaintiff cannot defeat a no-evidence summary-judgment motion with evidence supporting a theory that was not pleaded. Because the live petition alleged bodily-injury assault under Penal Code § 22.01(a)(1), evidence directed only to assault by threat under § 22.01(a)(2) did not create a fact issue on the pleaded claim.
Relevance to Family Law
The pleading-and-proof alignment required in Hickmon applies directly to tort claims and statutory allegations arising in divorce, SAPCR, custody, and property litigation. Family-law cases frequently involve allegations that conduct constituted assault, family violence, threats, offensive contact, intentional infliction of emotional distress, fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, or waste. Those labels do not eliminate the need to plead the operative theory and identify evidence supporting each challenged element.
The distinction can be outcome-determinative. Evidence that a spouse threatened imminent bodily injury may support one assault theory, while evidence of actual bodily injury supports another. Likewise, evidence relevant to conservatorship, possession, protective measures, or the child’s best interest does not necessarily establish every element of an independent tort claim. When a party seeks affirmative tort relief—or relies on a specifically pleaded statutory ground—the live pleading, the summary-judgment response, and the cited evidence must address the same legal theory.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
Michael Hickmon coached a youth football team. Following a tense game at Lancaster Community Park, Hickmon entered the field to retrieve a football. The Hickmon Family’s fourth amended petition alleged that Aqib Talib confronted Hickmon and threw a punch, after which Talib’s brother shot Hickmon multiple times. Hickmon died from the gunshot wounds.
The Hickmon Family asserted claims including negligence, gross negligence, assault, and battery. As to assault, the live petition alleged that Talib and his brother attacked Hickmon and caused bodily harm. It further alleged that Talib initiated the confrontation that culminated in the shooting. The petition did not allege that Talib merely threatened Hickmon with imminent bodily injury.
Talib moved for no-evidence summary judgment on the assault claim, asserting that there was no evidence he acted with the required mental state, made contact with Hickmon, or caused bodily injury. In response, the Hickmon Family relied on assault by threat, arguing that physical contact and injury were unnecessary under Penal Code § 22.01(a)(2).
The response cited Talib’s deposition testimony that he threw a water bottle at Hickmon but did not hit him or throw a punch. The response also included screenshots that appeared to show Hickmon holding an object, falling, getting up, running, and later falling after being shot. Other exhibits had been excluded by the trial court, and the Hickmon Family did not challenge those evidentiary rulings on appeal.
The trial court granted summary judgment. On appeal, the Hickmon Family challenged only the disposition of the assault claim.
Issues Decided
- Whether the live petition alleged bodily-injury assault under Texas Penal Code § 22.01(a)(1) or assault by threat under § 22.01(a)(2).
- Whether a plaintiff who pleaded bodily-injury assault could defeat a no-evidence motion by presenting argument and evidence directed to assault by threat.
- Whether the Hickmon Family specifically identified competent summary-judgment evidence raising a genuine issue of material fact that Talib made contact with Hickmon and caused bodily injury.
- Whether evidence excluded by an unchallenged evidentiary ruling could be considered in reviewing the summary judgment.
Rules Applied
Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 166a(i) permits a party to move for summary judgment on the ground that there is no evidence of one or more essential elements on which the opposing party would bear the burden of proof at trial. Once a proper no-evidence motion is filed, the nonmovant must produce more than a scintilla of evidence raising a genuine issue of material fact on each challenged element.
The court emphasized that a nonmovant must expressly identify the fact issues and the specific evidence supporting them. A general reference to the summary-judgment record is insufficient, and the trial court is not obligated to search every document for evidence that might create a fact issue. The court relied on State v. Three Thousand, Seven Hundred Seventy-Four Dollars & Twenty-Eight Cents U.S. Currency, 713 S.W.3d 381, 391 (Tex. 2025), as well as established no-evidence authorities including Energen Resources Corp. v. Wallace, 642 S.W.3d 502, 514 (Tex. 2022), and First United Pentecostal Church of Beaumont v. Parker, 514 S.W.3d 214, 220 (Tex. 2017).
Civil-assault elements mirror the criminal-assault provisions in Texas Penal Code § 22.01(a). Under that statute, assault may occur when a person:
- Intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly causes bodily injury to another;
- Intentionally or knowingly threatens another with imminent bodily injury; or
- Intentionally or knowingly causes physical contact when the person knows or reasonably should believe the other will regard the contact as offensive or provocative.
Although each is denominated “assault,” the alternatives involve materially different elements. Evidence of a threat is not necessarily evidence of contact or bodily injury.
The court applied the former version of Rule 166a because the summary-judgment motion had been filed before the March 1, 2026 effective date of amendments to that rule. Practitioners should consult the version governing the motion in the case at hand.
Finally, evidence excluded by the trial court is not part of the reviewable summary-judgment record when the evidentiary ruling is not challenged on appeal.
Application
The court began with the Hickmon Family’s live pleading at the time of the summary-judgment hearing. The petition alleged that Talib confronted Hickmon, threw a punch, attacked him, and caused bodily harm. Those allegations described bodily-injury assault under Penal Code § 22.01(a)(1). They did not allege that Talib committed assault by threatening Hickmon with imminent bodily injury under § 22.01(a)(2).
That pleading determination defined the elements the Hickmon Family had to support in response to Talib’s motion. Because Talib challenged contact and causation of bodily harm, the Hickmon Family had to identify competent evidence raising a fact issue that Talib made contact with Hickmon and that the contact caused bodily injury.
The summary-judgment response instead shifted to assault by threat. It argued that no physical contact or injury was required because Talib intentionally threatened Hickmon with imminent bodily injury. While that proposition described § 22.01(a)(2), it did not answer the motion directed to the bodily-injury theory actually pleaded.
The cited evidence did not cure the mismatch. Talib testified that he threw a water bottle but denied hitting Hickmon or throwing a punch. The screenshots did not establish that Talib made bodily contact with Hickmon or caused him bodily injury. Moreover, exhibits stricken by the trial court could not be considered because the Hickmon Family did not challenge the evidentiary rulings on appeal.
The response therefore failed in two related respects: it relied on an unpleaded legal theory, and it did not specifically identify competent evidence supporting the challenged contact and bodily-injury elements of the pleaded theory.
Holding
The Fifth Court of Appeals held that the live petition pleaded assault causing bodily injury under Texas Penal Code § 22.01(a)(1), not assault by threat under § 22.01(a)(2). The petition’s allegations of an attack, a punch, and resulting bodily harm defined the operative theory.
The court further held that evidence supporting only an assault-by-threat theory could not defeat no-evidence summary judgment on the pleaded bodily-injury claim. A summary-judgment response does not substitute an unpleaded theory for the claim contained in the live petition.
Because the Hickmon Family did not identify competent evidence raising a genuine issue of material fact that Talib made contact with Hickmon and caused bodily injury, the trial court properly granted no-evidence summary judgment on the assault claim. The court affirmed the judgment.
Practical Application
Family-law litigators should treat the live pleading as the roadmap for both filing and opposing a no-evidence motion. Before responding, identify the precise cause of action or statutory ground pleaded, separate its alternative theories, and match the evidence to each challenged element.
In a divorce involving an independent assault claim, counsel should determine whether the alleged conduct involves bodily injury, a threat of imminent bodily injury, offensive or provocative contact, or more than one theory. If the evidence supports multiple alternatives, plead them expressly and, when appropriate, in the alternative. Do not assume that a general allegation of “assault” necessarily preserves every statutory variant.
In custody and conservatorship litigation, allegations of threats or violence may be relevant to the child’s best interest, conservatorship presumptions, possession restrictions, or family-violence findings. But evidence relevant to those family-law determinations may not prove the elements of a separately pleaded tort claim. Counsel should distinguish between evidence offered for a Family Code determination and evidence offered to establish civil liability and damages.
In protective-order practice, the statutory definitions and required findings should be pleaded and proved with equal precision. Evidence of threatening communications, physical injury, offensive contact, or fear may carry different legal significance depending on the statutory provision invoked. The petition, requested relief, and evidence should track the governing definitions rather than rely on generalized characterizations.
Property cases present the same procedural problem in a different form. A spouse responding to a no-evidence motion on fraud, fraudulent inducement, breach of fiduciary duty, waste, or reimbursement cannot rely on evidence supporting a different theory without ensuring that the theory appears in the live pleading. For example, proof of unfair disposition of community assets does not automatically establish every element of common-law fraud.
A party who discovers that the evidence supports a different theory should consider timely amendment rather than attempting to introduce the new theory through the summary-judgment response. Counsel must account for pleading deadlines, scheduling orders, objections to late amendments, and the need for adequate time to address the revised claim.
Finally, the response should provide a precise evidentiary map. For each challenged element, identify the supporting exhibit, page, paragraph, deposition line, or authenticated recording. Attaching a large record and asking the court to find the evidence is not an adequate response to a properly framed no-evidence motion.
Checklists
Audit the Live Pleading
- Identify the live pleading in effect on the date of the summary-judgment hearing.
- Separate each cause of action from alternative theories within that cause of action.
- Compare the pleaded factual allegations with the elements of each asserted theory.
- Confirm that every theory to be used in opposition to summary judgment has been pleaded.
- Plead alternative theories expressly when the available evidence may support more than one statutory or common-law basis.
- Review the scheduling order and amendment deadline before filing or responding to the motion.
- Determine whether leave of court is required for an amended pleading.
Analyze the No-Evidence Motion
- List every element specifically challenged by the movant.
- Determine whether the motion attacks the claim actually contained in the live pleading.
- Check whether an adequate time for discovery has passed.
- Identify any challenged element for which the record contains no competent evidence.
- Distinguish legal arguments from evidence capable of raising a fact issue.
- Assess whether the motion addresses alternative theories separately.
- Preserve any complaint that the motion is conclusory or fails to identify the challenged elements.
Build the Summary-Judgment Response
- Organize the response by claim, theory, and challenged element.
- State the legal standard applicable to each pleaded theory.
- Expressly identify the fact issue raised on each challenged element.
- Cite the precise exhibit, page, paragraph, or deposition line supporting each fact issue.
- Explain how the cited evidence supports the element rather than merely quoting the evidence.
- Avoid relying on a theory that appears only in the response.
- Seek leave to amend when the evidence supports a viable but unpleaded theory.
- File the response and evidence within the governing deadlines.
Prove an Assault Theory in a Family-Law Case
- Determine whether the theory is bodily-injury assault, assault by threat, offensive-contact assault, or multiple alternatives.
- Plead the required culpable mental state for each theory.
- For bodily-injury assault, identify evidence of contact, bodily injury, causation, and intent, knowledge, or recklessness.
- For assault by threat, identify the threatening act or statement, imminence, and evidence of intent or knowledge.
- For offensive-contact assault, identify the contact and evidence that the actor knew or reasonably should have believed it would be regarded as offensive or provocative.
- Separate evidence relevant to tort liability from evidence offered only for conservatorship, possession, family violence, or best-interest determinations.
- Address damages and causation independently from proof that the underlying act occurred.
Protect the Evidentiary Record
- Authenticate photographs, recordings, screenshots, messages, and social-media evidence.
- Confirm that deposition excerpts include the necessary context.
- Respond to objections to summary-judgment evidence.
- Obtain written or on-the-record rulings on evidentiary objections.
- Challenge adverse evidentiary rulings on appeal when the excluded evidence is necessary to reversal.
- Do not rely on excluded evidence in the appellate argument.
- Confirm that all cited exhibits were actually filed and included in the clerk’s record.
Preserve the Appeal
- Challenge every independent ground capable of supporting the judgment.
- Address the trial court’s evidentiary rulings when they affect the dispositive evidence.
- Identify where each argument was presented to the trial court.
- Use the same theory on appeal that was pleaded and presented below.
- Verify which version of Rule 166a governed the motion.
- Preserve complaints concerning pleading amendments, continuances, discovery, and excluded evidence.
Citation
Hickmon v. Talib, No. 05-25-00730-CV (Tex. App.—Dallas Nov. 13, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
Family Law Crossover
The crossover rule is procedural: a party opposing no-evidence summary judgment must raise a genuine issue of material fact on the challenged elements of the theory contained in the live pleading. The response must expressly direct the trial court to specific, competent evidence supporting those elements. Evidence of a legally distinct, unpleaded theory does not satisfy that burden, even when the alternative theory arises under the same statute or bears the same general label.
In a Texas family-law matter, the issue may arise when a party joins a tort claim with a divorce, seeks relief based on alleged fraud or waste, asserts a reimbursement theory, requests a family-violence finding, or relies on particular conduct to support conservatorship or possession restrictions. If the pleading alleges actual physical injury but the evidence shows only threats, or pleads common-law fraud while the evidence supports only constructive fraud or breach of fiduciary duty, the same mismatch may be dispositive.
The procedural response is to examine and, if necessary, amend the live pleading before the summary-judgment hearing, subject to applicable deadlines and leave requirements. Counsel should then structure the response element by element and provide pinpoint citations to admissible evidence. Hickmon reinforces that neither the trial court nor the appellate court must reconstruct an unpleaded theory or search the record for evidence the nonmovant did not specifically identify.
~~7dc17941-1930-47aa-a831-ea1e233e23f5~~
Share this content:

