Shyla Desiree Russell v. Mark Anthony Lebedzinski, 10-26-00036-CV, November 12, 2026.
On appeal from 278th District Court of Walker County, Texas
Synopsis
A post-answer default does not relieve the appearing party of the burden to prove recoverable attorney’s fees. Because the record contained no evidence establishing the reasonableness and necessity of the fees awarded under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 37.009, the Tenth Court of Appeals deleted the fee award and affirmed the judgment as modified.
Relevance to Family Law
The holding applies directly to divorce, custody, enforcement, and marital-property proceedings in which one party has answered but does not appear for trial. A family-law court may proceed, but the appearing party must still present admissible evidence supporting the requested relief—particularly attorney’s fees, unliquidated damages, property valuations, reimbursement claims, and fact-dependent conservatorship findings. A proposed order, pleading, billing statement, or counsel’s argument does not automatically establish that fees are reasonable and necessary.
The case also matters when a family-law dispute includes a declaratory-judgment claim, such as a dispute concerning the validity or construction of a deed, trust, marital agreement, or other instrument. Even if section 37.009 provides a potential basis for fees, the party requesting them must establish the amount through competent evidence and must show that the fees are attributable to a claim for which they are legally recoverable.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
Shyla Desiree Russell and Mark Anthony Lebedzinski owned adjacent tracts of land. Lebedzinski alleged that Russell erected fencing that blocked his access to part of his property. He requested declarations concerning ownership, injunctive relief preventing interference with his use of the property, and relief concerning a 2021 deed through which Russell and her husband purported to convey several tracts to Russell’s mother.
Russell answered the suit, making the eventual judgment a post-answer default rather than a no-answer default. After a period of inactivity, the trial court entered a scheduling order setting the case for a bench trial. Russell did not appear, and the trial court granted the relief requested by Lebedzinski, including attorney’s fees.
On appeal, Russell argued that she did not receive notice of the trial setting. The record showed, however, that she had moved without timely notifying the clerk of her new address. Her written change of address was not filed until after trial. She also challenged the sufficiency of the evidence supporting the property-related relief and attorney’s fees, raised a necessary-party issue, and complained of procedural irregularities.
Although the court rejected the grounds seeking reversal of the underlying judgment, it concluded that the attorney’s-fee award lacked evidentiary support. The judgment therefore was modified to delete the fees and affirmed as modified.
Issues Decided
The Tenth Court of Appeals addressed:
- Whether proceeding to trial in Russell’s absence violated due process when she had appeared but had not timely provided the clerk with her current address.
- Whether the pleadings and evidence supported the property-related declarations and relief awarded by the trial court.
- How the pleaded property dispute should be characterized, including the distinctions among declaratory relief, trespass to try title, and a suit to quiet title.
- Whether the judgment could stand despite Russell’s necessary-party and procedural complaints.
- Whether the evidence supported an award of attorney’s fees under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 37.009.
- Whether the appropriate appellate disposition was reversal, remand, or modification of the judgment.
Rules Applied
- Post-answer defaults. When a defendant has answered but fails to appear for trial, the defendant’s absence does not operate as a confession of the plaintiff’s claims. The plaintiff must present evidence sufficient to support the requested judgment.
- Notice after an appearance. A party who has appeared is ordinarily entitled to notice of the trial setting as a matter of due process. See LBL Oil Co. v. International Power Services, Inc., 777 S.W.2d 390, 390–91 (Tex. 1989) (per curiam).
- Continuing duty to update contact information. Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 30.015(d) requires a party or the party’s attorney to provide written notice when the party’s address changes. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 21a likewise operates on the premise that parties will maintain current service information.
- Conscious indifference and reasonable explanation. A reasonable explanation may negate conscious indifference. See In re Marriage of Sandoval, 619 S.W.3d 716, 721 (Tex. 2021) (per curiam). Conversely, a party who fails to maintain current contact information or monitor the case may be unable to obtain reversal based on nonreceipt of a setting. See Manning v. Johnson, 642 S.W.3d 871, 880 (Tex. App.—Texarkana 2021, no pet.).
- Liberal construction of unchallenged pleadings. In the absence of special exceptions or another proper challenge, courts construe pleadings liberally in favor of the pleader and examine their substance rather than their labels. See Brumley v. McDuff, 616 S.W.3d 826, 831–35 (Tex. 2021).
- Declaratory relief involving real property. Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 37.004 permits certain declarations concerning written instruments and, in specified circumstances, boundary disputes. Courts must nevertheless distinguish a proper declaratory claim from trespass-to-try-title and quiet-title claims.
- Attorney’s fees under the Declaratory Judgments Act. Section 37.009 permits a court to award reasonable and necessary attorney’s fees that are equitable and just. The statute gives the trial court discretion over whether to award recoverable fees; it does not eliminate the claimant’s obligation to prove the fees’ reasonableness and necessity.
- Proof of attorney’s fees. Fee evidence ordinarily should address the services performed, who performed them, the time reasonably expended, reasonable hourly rates, and any necessary segregation between recoverable and nonrecoverable claims. Counsel’s unsworn argument and the amount inserted into a proposed judgment are not evidence.
Application
Russell had answered and therefore was entitled to notice of the trial setting. But the appellate record showed that the address used in the case was the address Russell had provided and that she did not file a change of address until after trial. Although her post-trial filing stated that she had not lived at the original address for years, it did not provide a sufficient explanation for failing to update the clerk or monitor the pending case. The court therefore rejected her due-process challenge.
The court next looked beyond the labels used in Lebedzinski’s pleading. Although the petition referenced the Declaratory Judgments Act and trespass to try title, the substance of the allegations sought to establish Lebedzinski’s superior title and remove a purported adverse claim created by the later deed. The court treated the nature of the requested relief according to the pleaded facts rather than relying exclusively on the petition’s captions.
Russell’s absence from the bench trial did not relieve Lebedzinski of his evidentiary burden. The trial court could evaluate the admitted evidence supporting ownership, access, the challenged deed, and injunctive relief, but it could not award attorney’s fees merely because no opposing party appeared to contest them.
The decisive defect was the absence of evidence showing that the fees awarded were reasonable and necessary. Section 37.009 authorized a discretionary fee award only upon the required evidentiary predicate. Because the record did not establish that predicate, the fee award could not stand. The defect did not require retrial of the otherwise supported relief, so the court corrected the judgment by deleting the unsupported fees.
Holding
The court held that Russell did not establish a due-process violation based on nonreceipt of the trial setting. Although an appearing party is entitled to notice, Russell did not timely notify the clerk of her changed address or provide a sufficient explanation for failing to maintain current contact information and monitor the case.
The court rejected Russell’s challenges seeking reversal of the property-related relief. Construing the pleadings by their substance and evaluating the record under the standards applicable to a post-answer default, the court left the underlying adjudication and injunctive relief intact.
The court also found no reversible error requiring a new trial based on the necessary-party and procedural complaints presented on appeal. Those arguments did not justify disturbing the substantive judgment on the appellate record.
The court held that the attorney’s-fee award was unsupported by evidence of reasonableness and necessity. A post-answer default does not dispense with that proof, even when fees are requested under section 37.009 of the Declaratory Judgments Act.
The court modified the judgment to delete the attorney’s-fee award and affirmed the judgment as modified.
Practical Application
For family-law litigators, the central lesson is that a post-answer default remains an evidentiary hearing. Do not treat the opposing party’s failure to appear as permission to submit a proposed decree without a developed record.
In a divorce, the petitioner should prove the statutory predicates for divorce, the characterization and value of significant assets and liabilities, any reimbursement or fraud-on-the-community claim, and the factual basis for a just-and-right division. An absent respondent does not supply missing tracing evidence, authenticate account records, or establish the value of a closely held business.
In a conservatorship or possession case, the appearing party must present evidence tied to the child’s best interest. The court should have evidence supporting requested geographic restrictions, possession deviations, decision-making rights, child-support calculations, health-care obligations, and any requested findings under the Family Code.
In an enforcement proceeding, counsel must prove the underlying order, the respondent’s noncompliance, each requested monetary amount, and any statutory predicates for mandatory fees. When contempt is requested, the motion, notice, service, and proof must satisfy the more exacting requirements governing contempt proceedings.
For attorney’s fees, counsel should make a clean record even when no objection is expected. Identify the lawyer and legal staff performing the work, their experience, reasonable hourly rates, hours expended, services performed, and the connection between those services and a fee-authorizing claim. If claims with different fee consequences are intertwined, address segregation expressly rather than leaving the appellate court to speculate.
The source of fee authority also matters. Depending on the proceeding, a family-law fee request may arise under Family Code sections 6.708, 9.014, 9.205, 106.002, or 157.167, another statute, a contract, or the Declaratory Judgments Act. Counsel should identify the correct authority and prove any elements specific to that source. A declaratory label should not be used merely to obtain fees otherwise unavailable under the substantive claim.
Finally, this opinion underscores the importance of service information. Counsel and self-represented parties have a continuing obligation to keep the clerk and other parties informed of current addresses and electronic-service information. Trial-setting disputes are much easier to prevent than to reconstruct on appeal.
Checklists
Prepare for a Post-Answer Default Prove-Up
- Confirm that the opposing party filed an answer or otherwise appeared.
- Verify that the trial setting was served in compliance with the applicable rules and scheduling order.
- Place the notice and proof of service in the clerk’s or reporter’s record.
- Confirm the party’s most recent address and electronic-service information.
- Prepare to prove every element of each claim as though opposing counsel were present.
- Authenticate and offer exhibits formally.
- Obtain rulings admitting each exhibit.
- Present evidence supporting every material component of the requested order.
- Ensure the proposed judgment conforms to both the pleadings and the evidence.
- Request a reporter’s record of the prove-up.
Prove Attorney’s Fees
- Identify the statute, contract, or rule authorizing fees.
- Explain why the fee provision applies to the particular claim and requested relief.
- Identify each billing professional and relevant qualifications.
- Establish reasonable hourly rates.
- Establish the time reasonably expended.
- Describe the legal services performed.
- Introduce billing records when appropriate.
- Address work performed by paralegals or other professionals separately.
- Segregate fees between recoverable and nonrecoverable claims unless an exception applies.
- Explain why any unsegregated work was inextricably intertwined with recoverable work.
- Address fees for trial, post-judgment proceedings, and each appellate stage separately.
- Obtain an express ruling on the fee request.
Build the Family-Law Merits Record
- Prove jurisdiction, residency, standing, and any required statutory waiting period.
- Establish the factual predicates for the requested divorce or SAPCR relief.
- Introduce a sworn inventory and appraisement when property division is involved.
- Prove characterization, value, and tracing rather than relying solely on schedules attached to pleadings.
- Prove reimbursement, economic-contribution, or fraud claims with supporting calculations.
- Offer evidence concerning the child’s best interest.
- Support requested child support with income evidence and guideline calculations.
- Prove arrearages and credits with a transparent payment history.
- Tie requested injunctive relief to pleaded grounds and admissible evidence.
- Confirm that the final order does not exceed the relief requested in the pleadings.
Preserve Notice and Service
- File written notice of every change in mailing address, email address, and other required service information.
- Serve the change of contact information on all parties.
- Retain electronic-service confirmations and returned-mail records.
- Review the docket periodically for scheduling orders and trial settings.
- Confirm receipt of trial notices well before the hearing date.
- Correct inaccurate contact information immediately.
- Include relevant notices and service certificates in the appellate record if notice becomes disputed.
Defend Against an Unsupported Default Judgment
- Determine whether the judgment followed a no-answer or post-answer default.
- Obtain the clerk’s record and reporter’s record promptly.
- Examine whether the opposing party proved each element of the requested relief.
- Identify unsupported findings, unadmitted exhibits, and relief exceeding the pleadings.
- Challenge attorney’s fees for lack of evidence, lack of segregation, or absence of statutory authority.
- Evaluate whether a motion for new trial is required for the intended complaint.
- Preserve notice complaints with affidavits and supporting documents.
- Provide a specific, reasonable explanation for any failure to appear.
- Calendar plenary-power and appellate deadlines immediately.
- Consider whether modification or rendition is available instead of a complete remand.
Citation
Russell v. Lebedzinski, No. 10-26-00036-CV (Tex. App.—Waco Nov. 12, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
Family Law Crossover
The procedural mechanism is a post-answer default prove-up. Once a respondent has answered, a failure to appear at trial generally permits the court to proceed, but it does not convert the respondent’s answer into an admission or eliminate the petitioner’s burden of proof. The petitioner must offer admissible evidence supporting the requested relief, and the resulting judgment remains subject to an evidentiary-sufficiency challenge.
In a Texas family-law case, the issue can arise when a respondent answers a divorce, SAPCR, modification, or enforcement action but does not attend the final hearing. The court may hear the case in the respondent’s absence, yet the petitioner must still establish the statutory and factual basis for the decree or order. The same rule applies to attorney’s fees: the court needs evidence supporting recoverability, reasonableness, necessity, and the amount awarded.
The fee analysis may differ depending on the governing statute. Some Family Code provisions make fees discretionary, while others may make qualifying fees mandatory. But even when entitlement is mandatory, the amount ordinarily must be supported by competent evidence. Russell therefore supplies a useful appellate checkpoint: confirm both the legal authority for fees and the evidence supporting their amount before asking the court to sign a post-answer default judgment.
~~36a7652f-dd4c-4647-9a75-d82fa396123a~~
Share this content:

