Site icon Thomas J. Daley

CROSSOVER: Raised Bat, No Words Required: Threatening Conduct Can Prove Imminent-Harm Assault

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Christian Michael Chortanoff v. The State of Texas, 10-25-00430-CR, November 19, 2026.

On appeal from 12th District Court of Walker County, Texas

Synopsis

An intentional or knowing threat of imminent bodily injury may be communicated entirely through conduct; neither threatening words nor forward movement is required. Evidence that an agitated defendant confronted an officer from approximately three feet away with an aluminum baseball bat raised overhead—after using it to smash objects and while refusing commands to disarm—supported both the assault-by-threat mens rea and the deadly-weapon finding.

Relevance to Family Law

Although Chortanoff is a criminal appeal, its treatment of nonverbal threats is directly relevant when Texas family courts evaluate alleged family violence, protective-order applications, temporary conservatorship disputes, possession restrictions, and a child’s best interest. Family violence can include a threat that reasonably places a family or household member in fear of imminent physical harm, bodily injury, assault, or sexual assault. See Tex. Fam. Code § 71.004. Thus, in a divorce or SAPCR, counsel should not evaluate a threat allegation solely by asking whether the person spoke threatening words or attempted to strike the other party. The person’s proximity, posture, possession and display of an object, preceding actions, refusal to comply with requests to disarm, and the surrounding circumstances may collectively establish an implied threat.

The opinion does not collapse the distinct elements, burdens of proof, and remedies governing criminal assault, protective orders, and conservatorship determinations. It does, however, provide a useful evidentiary framework: courts may infer a communicated threat and the actor’s state of mind from the cumulative force of conduct and context rather than examining each fact in isolation.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Christian Michael Chortanoff called 9-1-1 because he believed another man might assault him in retaliation for Chortanoff’s alleged assault of the man’s mother. When officers arrived, Chortanoff was in the front yard with several other people. Officers described him as extremely agitated, angry, and apparently intoxicated. He cursed at an officer and directed the officer to leave the property.

Law enforcement’s role eventually shifted from investigating a domestic disturbance to conducting a civil standby while a woman removed her belongings from the residence. Sergeant Blair arrived and spoke with Chortanoff before they entered the home. Chortanoff went into a bedroom, closed the door, and played loud music.

While Sergeant Blair watched the woman collect her property, glass suddenly flew onto him. He drew his weapon and turned to find Chortanoff approximately three feet away holding an aluminum baseball bat. Chortanoff had used the bat to smash dishes and other objects in the kitchen. He then held the bat overhead in a position suggesting that he was prepared to swing it again.

Sergeant Blair characterized the encounter as Chortanoff confronting him with the bat and testified that he felt threatened. Chortanoff did not lower the bat when ordered to do so. Blair closed the distance, seized the bat, holstered his weapon, used the bat to push Chortanoff backward onto the floor, and discarded it. The officers then restrained Chortanoff after continued noncompliance.

A jury convicted Chortanoff of aggravated assault against a public servant. After he pleaded true to two felony enhancement allegations, the trial court sentenced him to fifty years’ imprisonment. On appeal, Chortanoff argued that the evidence did not establish the required mens rea or support the finding that the bat was used or exhibited as a deadly weapon.

Issues Decided

  1. Whether the evidence permitted a rational jury to find that Chortanoff intentionally or knowingly threatened the officer with imminent bodily injury, even though he made no verbal threat and did not move toward the officer.

  2. Whether the evidence permitted a rational jury to find that the aluminum baseball bat, in the manner of its use or intended use, was a deadly weapon.

Rules Applied

Application

The court rejected the premise that the State had to prove either a verbal threat or physical movement toward the officer. Chortanoff’s intent could be inferred from his conduct and the circumstances surrounding the encounter. He was angry and agitated, knew that Sergeant Blair was inside the residence, and had just swung the bat forcefully enough to shatter objects and send glass onto the officer. He then stood approximately three feet from Blair with the bat raised overhead.

The court also treated Chortanoff’s refusal to obey the command to lower the bat as part of the threat communication. The jury was entitled to consider the threatening posture, close proximity, preceding destruction, continued possession of the bat, and refusal to disarm together. It was not required to isolate each circumstance or treat the absence of threatening words and forward movement as dispositive.

The subsequent struggle reinforced the jury’s assessment of Chortanoff’s intent. Sergeant Blair had to close the distance, take hold of the bat, and wrest it away after pushing Chortanoff to the floor. Viewed in the light most favorable to the verdict, the cumulative evidence permitted a rational inference that Chortanoff intentionally or knowingly communicated an imminent threat.

The same circumstances supported the deadly-weapon finding. The jury saw a photograph of the aluminum bat and heard testimony that a blow from it could cause broken bones, facial fractures, a cracked skull, or temporary blindness. Chortanoff had already demonstrated the bat’s force by smashing objects. He then displayed it overhead at close range and retained it despite commands to disarm. That manner of use and intended use permitted the jury to find that the bat was capable of causing death or serious bodily injury.

Holding

The Tenth Court of Appeals held that the evidence was sufficient to establish the mens rea for assault by threat. A threat may be communicated through conduct alone, and the defendant’s actions—considered in context—permitted a rational jury to find that he intentionally or knowingly threatened the officer with imminent bodily injury.

The court also held that the evidence supported the deadly-weapon finding. The bat’s physical characteristics, Chortanoff’s prior use of it to smash objects, his proximity to the officer, the overhead position of the bat, his refusal to lower it, and testimony about the injuries it could inflict established that it was used or exhibited as a deadly weapon.

The court overruled both appellate issues and affirmed the judgment.

Practical Application

For Texas family-law litigators, Chortanoff underscores that the proof of a threat should be developed as a sequence rather than reduced to a quotation. In a protective-order proceeding, the absence of “I will hurt you” or similar language does not necessarily defeat an allegation that conduct placed a family or household member in reasonable fear of imminent harm. Counsel should develop the actor’s posture, distance from the applicant, handling of any object, preceding destructive acts, response to requests to stop or disarm, available exits, presence of children, and the applicant’s contemporaneous reaction.

In temporary-orders proceedings, the same evidence may bear on conservatorship, possession, exchanges, communication protocols, geographic restrictions, exclusive use of property, and safety conditions. If children witnessed the event, counsel should establish where they were, what they could see or hear, whether they attempted to intervene, and whether the incident affected their immediate safety or emotional condition. Any requested relief should remain tied to the governing Family Code standard rather than being presented as an automatic consequence of a criminal allegation.

For final-trial preparation, counsel should preserve the complete evidentiary context. A short recording showing only a raised object may be ambiguous; testimony about what occurred immediately before and after the recording can be decisive. Conversely, counsel opposing the allegation should test proximity, physical barriers, camera perspective, whether the object was directed toward anyone, whether commands were audible, whether the accused knew another person was present, and whether the asserted fear was contemporaneously documented.

Property disputes can also produce threatening-conduct evidence, particularly during retrieval of personal effects, inventorying of a residence, vehicle exchanges, or enforcement of an award of possession. Structured exchanges, neutral locations, written protocols, third-party attendance, and law-enforcement civil standbys can reduce risk while producing a clearer record if a dispute occurs.

Checklists

Develop the Nonverbal-Threat Evidence

Connect the Evidence to the Family Code

Prepare for Temporary Orders or a Protective-Order Hearing

Challenge an Overstated Inference

Preserve the Record for Appeal

Citation

Christian Michael Chortanoff v. State of Texas, No. 10-25-00430-CR (Tex. App.—Waco Nov. 19, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op., not designated for publication).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion.

Family Law Crossover

The crossover rule is evidentiary: an intentional or knowing threat may be proved through conduct, and the factfinder may infer the communication and the actor’s mental state from the cumulative circumstances. No independent verbal threat or forward movement is categorically required. On sufficiency review, the evidence is considered as a whole and in the light most favorable to the finding; courts do not employ a divide-and-conquer analysis that discounts each circumstance in isolation.

In a Texas family-law matter, this principle may arise when a court determines whether conduct constitutes family violence under Texas Family Code § 71.004, whether protective-order relief is appropriate, or whether evidence of family violence affects conservatorship and possession under Chapter 153. The procedural vehicle may be an application for a temporary ex parte protective order followed by a final protective-order hearing, a request for temporary orders in a divorce or SAPCR, or the presentation of family-violence evidence at final trial.

The family court must apply the governing Family Code provisions and the applicable burden of proof; Chortanoff does not substitute criminal-assault elements for those standards. Its practical significance is that the proponent may prove a threat through testimony, recordings, physical evidence, and reasonable inferences concerning posture, proximity, objects displayed, preceding acts, and responses to requests to stop. The opposing party may contest those inferences through cross-examination, competing contextual evidence, and proof concerning distance, barriers, direction, timing, and alternative explanations for the conduct.

~~b00cb162-3f8c-44a2-9cbf-d3a1d1f7b669~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version