Site icon Thomas J. Daley

CROSSOVER: Texas Supreme Court Revives Charge Error: Family Litigators Can Preserve Jury-Charge Complaints Through Timely, Specific Requests and Objections

New SCOTX Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Santander Consumer USA Inc. v. Enterprise Financial Group, Inc., 25-0660, November 20, 2026.

On appeal from Court of Appeals for the Fifth District of Texas

Synopsis

Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 274 and 278 preserved Santander’s jury-charge complaints through written requests expressly refused by the trial court and specific objections made during the charge conference. A litigant need not repeat a properly refused request or use talismanic language when the record shows that the litigant timely and plainly identified the alleged charge defect and obtained a ruling.

Relevance to Family Law

Although Santander arose from a commercial contract dispute, its preservation analysis applies directly to jury trials involving divorce, characterization and valuation of marital property, reimbursement claims, disputed fault grounds, conservatorship, and other family-law issues properly submitted to a jury. Family-law charges frequently combine multiple theories, defenses, property claims, or damage-like economic findings in broad-form questions. Santander confirms that counsel can preserve complaints through the correct procedural vehicle: a substantially correct written request for an omitted question, instruction, or definition under Rule 278, or a timely and specific objection to defective material actually included in the charge under Rule 274.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Santander Consumer USA Inc. and Enterprise Financial Group, Inc. entered into a Vendor Services Agreement involving guaranteed asset protection products offered in connection with vehicle financing. After the business arrangement failed, Enterprise terminated the agreement and sued Santander for breach of contract and declaratory relief. Santander asserted competing contract and declaratory claims.

Before trial, both parties submitted proposed jury charges. On the final day of trial, the trial court marked the cover pages of both proposed charges “Refused” and signed them, expressly stating that the procedure would protect the parties’ records concerning the refusal of their requested charges. The court then prepared its own charge and conducted a charge conference.

One disputed portion of the court’s charge involved Questions 8A and 8B. Question 8A asked whether Santander’s breach resulted from gross negligence, bad faith, or willful misconduct. Question 8B asked the jury to determine Enterprise’s damages but did not define damages, identify the permissible measures of damages, or provide separate answer blanks for direct and consequential damages.

During the charge conference, Santander objected that the damages submission permitted the jury to award direct or consequential damages without the contractual predicate finding of gross negligence, bad faith, or willful misconduct. Santander further argued that Enterprise had not presented evidence supporting lost profits and that the jury should therefore receive instructions limited to direct damages. Enterprise responded on the merits, maintaining that the evidence supported the question and that the parties disputed the appropriate damages classification. The trial court overruled Santander’s objections.

The jury found that both parties breached the agreement but that Santander breached first and materially. It awarded Enterprise $5 million and Santander $4.2 million. The jury did not find that Santander’s breach resulted from gross negligence, bad faith, or willful misconduct. Because Enterprise’s breach was excused, the trial court disregarded Santander’s damages and rendered judgment awarding Enterprise $5 million, interest, and attorney’s fees.

On appeal, Santander challenged several aspects of the charge. It contended that the broad-form breach question allowed the jury to consider theories that were neither pleaded nor tried by consent; that the charge omitted a requested question addressing a particular waiver defense; and that the damages question improperly permitted an undifferentiated award that could include unsupported lost profits.

The Dallas Court of Appeals concluded that Santander had not preserved those complaints. The Supreme Court of Texas disagreed, reversed the court of appeals’ judgment, and remanded for consideration of whether the charge was erroneous and, if so, whether the error was harmful.

Issues Decided

Rules Applied

Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 274 requires a party objecting to a charge to point out distinctly the objectionable matter and the grounds for the objection. The rule governs complaints about defective questions, instructions, or definitions included in the court’s charge.

Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 278 governs requested questions, definitions, and instructions omitted from the charge. A party may preserve a complaint through a written request tendered in substantially correct wording and refused by the trial court. Once the trial court has properly refused the request, the requesting party generally need not repeat the request as an objection.

In State Department of Highways & Public Transportation v. Payne, 838 S.W.2d 235, 241 (Tex. 1992), the Court explained that the ultimate preservation inquiry is whether the party timely and plainly made the trial court aware of the complaint and obtained a ruling. Preservation does not turn on technical incantations when the record demonstrates that the court understood the asserted defect.

The Court also relied on Thota v. Young, 366 S.W.3d 678, 691 (Tex. 2012), which recognizes that a party may preserve a complaint concerning a broad-form submission by making a timely and specific objection that disputed items included in the question lack evidentiary support.

These rules reflect an important procedural distinction. A party ordinarily preserves a complaint about material included in the charge through an objection under Rule 274. A complaint about material omitted from the charge ordinarily requires a written request in substantially correct form under Rule 278.

Application

Santander’s objection to Question 8B identified both the challenged submission and the grounds for excluding the disputed damages theory. Santander told the trial court that the question permitted an award of direct or consequential damages without the contractually required predicate finding. It also argued that Enterprise had failed to present evidence of lost profits and that the charge should therefore limit the jury to direct damages.

The Supreme Court held that this was sufficiently specific. Santander identified the objectionable matter—the damages question’s ability to support an award encompassing lost profits—and explained the grounds—the absence of evidence supporting lost profits and the absence of the required contractual predicate. Enterprise’s substantive response further demonstrated that the objection was understood. The preservation inquiry did not require Santander to employ the appellate court’s preferred terminology or expressly call the question an improper “amalgamation.”

Nor was Santander required to request a separate answer blank for consequential damages. Its position was that consequential lost-profit damages should not be submitted at all. Requiring Santander to propose an answer blank for a damages category it contended was legally unavailable would have been inconsistent with the substance of its objection.

The Court also rejected the conclusion that Santander could not rely on its refused written requests. The trial court had marked and signed the parties’ proposed charges “Refused” and expressly indicated that it was doing so to protect the record. Under Rule 278, Santander was not required to repeat a substantially correct written request after the trial court had already refused it.

The Supreme Court addressed preservation only. It did not decide whether the challenged questions were erroneous or whether any error probably caused the rendition of an improper judgment. Those matters were left to the court of appeals on remand.

Holding

The Court held that Santander preserved its objection to Question 8B under Rule 274. Its charge-conference statements timely and plainly informed the trial court that the broad damages question permitted an award of unsupported lost profits and should have been limited to direct damages.

The Court further held that Santander’s written charge requests, expressly marked and signed “Refused” by the trial court, preserved the complaints governed by Rule 278. Santander was not required to repeat those requests during the charge conference.

Finally, the Court held that preservation did not depend on magic words, the use of a particular label such as “amalgamation,” or a request for separate findings that would have contradicted Santander’s position that the disputed damages theory should not be submitted. The Court reversed and remanded for the court of appeals to decide error and harm.

Practical Application

Family-law litigators should identify whether each charge complaint concerns an omission or a defect in submitted material. That classification determines the preservation method.

For an omitted question, instruction, or definition, prepare a separate written request in substantially correct wording, tender it before submission, and obtain an express ruling. Examples may include a requested characterization question, a valuation finding, a reimbursement issue, a disputed element of an affirmative defense, or an instruction limiting the jury’s consideration to a legally available theory.

For a defective question already in the court’s charge, make a timely Rule 274 objection that identifies the question, the precise defect, and the legal or evidentiary basis. If a broad-form question combines supported and unsupported theories, state which theory should not be submitted and why. Depending on the position being asserted, request a properly limited question or separate findings.

In a property case, counsel might object that a broad-form characterization or reimbursement submission combines distinct assets, transactions, or theories and prevents the verdict from revealing the basis for the jury’s answer. The objection should identify the affected assets or theories rather than merely asserting that the question is “improper.”

In a conservatorship case, counsel should account for the division between issues on which a jury verdict is binding and matters committed to the trial court. If the proposed charge submits a matter beyond the jury’s authority or fails to submit a properly triable controlling issue, the record should identify both the allocation-of-authority problem and the requested correction.

In a fault-based divorce or economic-misconduct dispute, an objection should connect the challenged instruction or question to the pleadings, evidence, and governing legal standard. If a theory is unsupported by legally sufficient evidence, counsel should say so expressly and identify the theory that must be removed.

The safest practice remains belt-and-suspenders preservation when time permits: submit written requests, object on the record, obtain an express ruling, and confirm that the clerk’s record contains the requested material. Santander prevents preservation doctrine from becoming an exercise in magic words, but it does not excuse an ambiguous complaint or a missing ruling.

Checklists

Preserve Complaints About Omitted Charge Material

Preserve Complaints About Defective Submitted Material

Build a Family-Law Charge Record

Prepare for Harm Analysis

Avoid Preservation Disputes

Citation

Santander Consumer USA Inc. v. Enterprise Financial Group, Inc., __ S.W.3d __, No. 25-0660 (Tex. Nov. 20, 2026) (per curiam).

Full Opinion

Read the Supreme Court of Texas opinion.

Family Law Crossover

The crossover rule is procedural: omitted charge material and defective submitted material are preserved through different, though sometimes overlapping, mechanisms. Under Rule 278, a substantially correct written request that the trial court expressly refuses preserves a complaint about an omitted question, instruction, or definition without requiring counsel to repeat the request. Under Rule 274, an objection to material included in the charge is preserved when counsel timely identifies the challenged material, plainly states the grounds, and obtains a ruling. Neither rule requires magic words.

In a Texas divorce trial, this framework may arise when the court omits a requested characterization, valuation, reimbursement, or affirmative-defense issue. In a custody case tried to a jury, it may arise when the charge omits a properly triable conservatorship issue, submits a matter reserved to the court, or combines distinct issues in a manner that obscures the verdict’s basis. The operative question is whether the record, viewed as a whole, shows that the trial court was timely and plainly informed of the asserted defect and given an opportunity to correct it before the charge went to the jury.

~~a601203c-2052-4bb4-bea5-8bbfe4793b26~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version