Site icon Thomas J. Daley

Rule 251 Requires Affidavit for Continuance | Marsh v. Marsh (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Marsh v. Marsh, 02-26-00120-CV, November 10, 2026.

On appeal from 360th District Court, Tarrant County, Texas

Synopsis

Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 251 requires a motion for continuance to be verified or supported by affidavit. When the motion lacks that support, an appellate court presumes the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the continuance—even when the movant requests additional time to retain counsel and prepare for a significant property hearing.

Relevance to Family Law

Continuance disputes arise frequently in divorce, custody, enforcement, and post-decree property litigation, often when counsel has recently appeared, discovery remains incomplete, a key witness is unavailable, or a party is attempting to retain counsel. Marsh reinforces that the merits of those circumstances may never carry the appellate issue if the motion does not satisfy Rule 251’s threshold affidavit requirement.

The decision is particularly important in expedited property proceedings. Hearings involving receivers, sales of marital residences, writs of possession, temporary orders, and enforcement measures may proceed on compressed timelines. A family-law litigant seeking additional time must create a procedurally compliant and factually specific record before the hearing; assertions in an unverified motion are not an adequate substitute.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Ekeila Marsh and Brent Marsh divorced in October 2025. Their final divorce decree required the marital residence to be sold by a court-appointed receiver and authorized the receiver to establish the terms and conditions of the sale. After payment of specified expenses, Wife was to receive 60% of the net proceeds, while Husband was to receive 40%. The decree also required Wife to vacate the property 48 hours before closing.

Wife did not appeal the divorce decree, and it became final. The receiver subsequently marketed the property, received a $685,000 offer, and filed a report of sale and motion requesting confirmation of the proposed transaction. The receiver represented that the offer was the highest and best price reasonably obtainable after appropriate marketing and due diligence. The receiver also requested an order requiring Wife to release a lis pendens concerning the property.

After Wife objected, the trial court set the receiver’s motion for a February 23, 2026 hearing. Five days before the hearing, Wife—then proceeding pro se—requested a 21-day continuance so that she could retain counsel and adequately prepare. Her motion was neither verified nor supported by an affidavit.

At the hearing, the trial court denied the requested continuance, approved the proposed sale, and ordered Wife to release the lis pendens. The court later signed an order confirming the sale. Wife appealed and challenged the denial of the continuance along with several other postjudgment rulings concerning the receiver, the lis pendens, possession of the property, and enforcement of the decree.

Issues Decided

For purposes of the continuance ruling, the Second Court of Appeals addressed:

The broader appeal also challenged the receiver’s authority and failure to post a bond, the handling of Wife’s unauthorized courtroom recording, the amount of the supersedeas bond, the issuance of a writ of possession, the absence of requested findings and conclusions, and whether the postjudgment enforcement orders improperly altered the divorce decree. The court affirmed the challenged orders.

Rules Applied

The governing standard of review was abuse of discretion. Rule 251 noncompliance substantially constrained Wife’s ability to establish that the trial court acted arbitrarily or unreasonably.

Application

Wife filed her motion only five days before the scheduled hearing and requested 21 additional days to secure counsel and prepare. Those circumstances potentially supplied a substantive explanation for the request, but the motion did not place supporting evidence before the trial court in the form required by Rule 251. It was neither sworn nor accompanied by an affidavit establishing Wife’s efforts to retain counsel, the preparation she still needed to complete, why that preparation could not have occurred earlier, or how proceeding on the scheduled date would cause concrete prejudice.

Because the motion did not comply with Rule 251, the court of appeals applied the presumption recognized in Finley: the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying the continuance. Wife’s pro se status did not excuse the procedural defect.

The court also rejected Wife’s attempt to constitutionalize the issue. She argued that denying the continuance subordinated her right to counsel to the prospective purchaser’s closing schedule. But because the proceeding was civil and there is no general constitutional right to counsel in civil litigation, that argument did not establish reversible error.

The result illustrates the difference between having a potentially legitimate reason for delay and preserving an appellate complaint about the denial of that delay. Wife’s stated need to obtain counsel and prepare did not overcome the absence of sworn factual support.

Holding

A motion for continuance must comply with Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 251 by being verified or supported by affidavit when it relies on factual grounds constituting sufficient cause. Wife’s unsupported motion did not satisfy that requirement.

Because the motion was neither verified nor supported by affidavit, the court of appeals presumed that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the requested continuance. The court therefore overruled Wife’s first appellate issue.

The denial did not violate Wife’s asserted constitutional right to counsel. Texas law does not recognize a general constitutional right to counsel in a civil divorce or postjudgment property proceeding.

Practical Application

Marsh should be treated as a drafting and preservation case. A motion for continuance should not merely announce that counsel needs additional time or that a party is attempting to retain counsel. It should establish the relevant facts through a verification or supporting affidavit and explain why those facts amount to sufficient cause.

In a divorce trial, counsel should identify the unfinished discovery, valuation work, tracing analysis, expert review, or witness preparation that makes the continuance necessary. The affidavit should explain what has already been done, why the remaining work could not reasonably have been completed, and how proceeding would materially impair presentation of the case.

In a custody or modification proceeding, the motion should address the child-centered evidence that remains unavailable, such as a custody evaluation, counseling records, school records, medical evidence, or testimony from a material witness. The motion should connect the requested delay to the court’s ability to make an informed best-interest determination rather than relying on generalized assertions that more preparation is needed.

In a receiver or marital-property sale dispute, time is often critical because third-party purchasers, financing commitments, closing dates, carrying costs, and property deterioration may weigh against delay. A party requesting a continuance should confront those considerations directly and propose a limited extension that minimizes prejudice to the estate and third parties.

When the continuance is based on an absent witness or missing testimony, counsel should also evaluate the additional requirements of Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 252. Rule 251 supplies the general affidavit requirement, but witness-based continuances ordinarily demand more particularized showings concerning materiality, diligence, the cause of the absence, and the likelihood that the testimony can be obtained.

Finally, a compliant affidavit does not guarantee a continuance. It prevents an avoidable procedural default and gives the trial court—and later the appellate court—a record on which to evaluate diligence, materiality, prejudice, and the reasonableness of the requested delay.

Checklists

Drafting a Rule 251 Motion

Seeking Time to Retain or Substitute Counsel

Continuances Based on Missing Evidence or Witnesses

Preparing for the Continuance Hearing

Avoiding the Result in Marsh

Citation

Marsh v. Marsh, No. 02-26-00120-CV (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Nov. 10, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion in Marsh v. Marsh.

~~f4842e8e-ddd8-4f34-8c71-166afae57608~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version