In Re Ekaterina Medyanik, 14-26-00906-CV, November 19, 2026.
On appeal from 507th District Court, Harris County, Texas
Synopsis
When a timely motion under Texas Family Code § 155.201(b) alleges that the children have resided in another county for at least six months, transfer is mandatory unless the opposing party timely files an affidavit actually denying the asserted transfer ground. An affidavit stating only that the affiant does not know where the children live does not controvert residence, so the court must transfer the proceeding without a hearing under § 155.204(c). A refusal to perform that ministerial duty is reviewable by mandamus.
Relevance to Family Law
In re Medyanik is a procedural warning for post-divorce enforcement and custody litigation in a court of continuing, exclusive jurisdiction. A facially valid and timely motion alleging six months of residence in another Texas county can shift the proceeding without sworn proof, testimony, or an evidentiary hearing unless the opponent files a timely affidavit that squarely denies the residence-based transfer ground.
The decision is particularly important in modification and enforcement proceedings involving conservatorship, possession, access, child support, and other parent-child provisions of a divorce decree. Counsel cannot defeat transfer by emphasizing inconvenience, the movant’s alleged failure to disclose the children’s address, or the characterization of the proceeding as an enforcement rather than a modification. If the case falls within § 155.201(b), the statutory transfer procedure applies to both modification suits and motions to enforce.
For mixed post-divorce litigation, practitioners should distinguish SAPCR matters governed by Chapter 155 from disputes involving only the division or enforcement of marital property. The continuing-jurisdiction and mandatory-transfer provisions do not automatically govern every dispute arising from a divorce decree. When child-related and property issues appear in the same filing, counsel should determine whether transfer affects the entire proceeding, whether claims should be severed, and which court retains authority over each form of requested relief.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
The 507th District Court of Harris County rendered a final divorce decree appointing Ekaterina Medyanik and MD Arshad Nasim joint managing conservators of their two children. By rendering the decree, the Harris County court acquired continuing, exclusive jurisdiction under Texas Family Code § 155.001(a).
In April 2026, the father filed a motion to enforce the decree. Among other allegations, he asserted that the mother had failed to provide information concerning the children’s permanent residence and school enrollment.
The mother timely moved to transfer the proceeding from Harris County to Montgomery County. Her motion alleged that she and the children had continuously resided in Montgomery County for more than six months. Although the motion was not verified, it invoked the mandatory-transfer provisions of Family Code §§ 155.201 and 155.204.
The father filed a response accompanied by a document labeled as a controverting affidavit. The affidavit stated that the father resided in Harris County, did not know where the children lived, considered the matter an enforcement rather than a modification, and did not want the case transferred because Montgomery County would be inconvenient for him. It did not deny that the children had resided in Montgomery County for at least six months, identify a different county of residence, or otherwise allege facts inconsistent with the mother’s transfer ground.
The trial court nevertheless conducted an evidentiary hearing. The mother testified and was questioned by counsel for both parties. At the conclusion of the hearing, the court orally denied the transfer motion without stating its reasons. The mother sought mandamus relief from the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.
Issues Decided
-
Whether a timely motion alleging that the children had resided in another Texas county for at least six months triggered mandatory transfer under Family Code § 155.201(b).
-
Whether the movant was required to verify the transfer motion or initially prove the residence allegation with evidence.
-
Whether an affidavit stating that the opposing party did not know where the children lived qualified as a controverting affidavit under § 155.204(d).
-
Whether the trial court could conduct an evidentiary hearing and rely on hearing evidence when no qualifying controverting affidavit had been filed.
-
Whether mandamus was available to correct the trial court’s refusal to perform the mandatory transfer.
Rules Applied
Texas Family Code § 155.001(a) provides that a court acquires continuing, exclusive jurisdiction when it renders a final order in a suit affecting the parent-child relationship.
Under § 155.201(b), when a modification suit or motion to enforce is filed in the court of continuing, exclusive jurisdiction, that court “shall” transfer the proceeding to another Texas county if a timely transfer motion is filed and the child has resided in the other county for six months or longer.
Section 155.204 establishes the procedure for deciding the transfer request:
-
A party seeking transfer must file a timely motion. Tex. Fam. Code § 155.204(b).
-
A party contesting transfer must timely file “a controverting affidavit denying that grounds for the transfer exist.” Tex. Fam. Code § 155.204(d).
-
If a qualifying controverting affidavit is timely filed, the parties are entitled to notice of a hearing on the motion. Tex. Fam. Code § 155.204(e).
-
If no qualifying controverting affidavit is timely filed, the proceeding must be transferred without a hearing within the statutory deadline. Tex. Fam. Code § 155.204(c).
The court relied on In re Nabors and In re Sanchez for the proposition that a transfer motion need not be sworn or verified. Proper venue allegations are sufficient to place the burden on the opposing party to file a legally sufficient controverting affidavit.
The court also relied on decisions including In re Avalos, In re T.H., In re L.C.R., In re Whitworth, and Martinez v. Flores. Those authorities establish that an affidavit is not a controverting affidavit merely because it bears that label. It must deny the asserted transfer ground or allege facts that genuinely controvert the child’s residence.
Finally, under Proffer v. Yates and related mandamus authorities, refusal to make a mandatory Family Code transfer is an abuse of discretion for which there is no adequate remedy by appeal. Section 155.204(h) also precludes an interlocutory appeal from the denial of mandatory transfer.
Application
The mother’s timely transfer motion alleged the operative venue fact: that she and the children had continuously resided in Montgomery County for more than six months. The motion did not need to be verified, and she did not have to attach evidence proving residence at the initial stage. Those allegations were sufficient to invoke § 155.201(b) and shift the procedural burden to the father.
The father’s affidavit did not meet that burden. His statement that he did not know where the children lived was not a denial that they had resided in Montgomery County for the required period. To the contrary, the statement expressly disclaimed personal knowledge concerning the controlling venue fact.
The father’s remaining assertions were also immaterial to the statutory inquiry. His own residence in Harris County did not determine the children’s residence. His inconvenience did not override the Legislature’s mandatory venue directive. Nor did his characterization of the case as an enforcement defeat transfer, because § 155.201(b) expressly applies when a motion to enforce is filed in the court of continuing, exclusive jurisdiction.
Because the affidavit did not deny the alleged transfer ground or provide inconsistent residence facts, the mother’s allegation was effectively uncontroverted. Section 155.204(c) therefore required the trial court to transfer the proceeding without a hearing. Testimony presented at the later hearing could not cure the father’s failure to file a qualifying affidavit or create discretion that the statute had already removed.
Holding
The Fourteenth Court of Appeals held that the mother’s timely, though unverified, motion sufficiently alleged that the children had resided in Montgomery County for more than six months. Those allegations triggered the mandatory-transfer procedure under §§ 155.201(b) and 155.204.
The court further held that the father’s affidavit was not a qualifying controverting affidavit. A statement that the affiant does not know where the children live does not deny the movant’s residence allegation and does not establish competing facts concerning the children’s residence.
Because no sufficient controverting affidavit was filed, the trial court had a ministerial duty to transfer the proceeding to Montgomery County without conducting a hearing. Its refusal to do so was an abuse of discretion.
The court also held that the mother lacked an adequate appellate remedy. It conditionally granted mandamus and directed the trial court to vacate its oral order denying transfer and enter a written order transferring the case to Montgomery County.
Practical Application
For the party seeking transfer, Medyanik confirms that precision in pleading may be more important than presenting evidence at the outset. The motion should expressly allege that each child has resided in the proposed transferee county for at least six months and should identify the statutory basis for transfer. Although verification is not required, attaching a declaration or supporting records may still be prudent when counsel anticipates a proper controverting affidavit and an evidentiary hearing.
For the party opposing transfer, filing a document titled “controverting affidavit” is not enough. The affidavit must deny the specific residence ground asserted in the motion or state admissible facts demonstrating why that ground does not exist. Lack of knowledge, inconvenience, the opponent’s alleged nondisclosure, or a preference for the original county will not preserve a contested venue hearing.
Counsel defending venue should conduct an immediate factual investigation rather than rely on a client’s uncertainty. Potential sources include school enrollment records, medical records, lease documents, utility records, property records, possession calendars, communications identifying the children’s home, and testimony from persons with personal knowledge. Any affidavit must also be timely; factual merit cannot ordinarily cure a missed statutory deadline.
At the hearing stage, counsel for the movant should object if the court attempts to receive evidence despite the absence of a timely and legally sufficient controverting affidavit. Medyanik indicates that the statutory consequence is transfer without a hearing. The relator preserved that position by raising the objection with sufficient clarity at the beginning of the hearing.
The decision also reinforces the need to calendar both sides of the statutory process. The opponent’s deadline is the first Monday after the twentieth day following service of the transfer motion. If no qualifying affidavit is filed, § 155.204(c) imposes a separate deadline for transfer: no later than the twenty-first day after the final date for filing the controverting affidavit.
If a trial court refuses mandatory transfer, counsel should evaluate mandamus promptly. An interlocutory appeal is unavailable, and waiting until final judgment would force the parties and children through potentially unnecessary litigation in the wrong county.
Checklists
Moving for Mandatory Transfer
-
Confirm that the pending matter is a modification suit or motion to enforce within Family Code § 155.201(b).
-
Identify the court holding continuing, exclusive jurisdiction.
-
Confirm that the child has resided in the proposed transferee county for at least six months.
-
File the transfer motion within the deadline prescribed by § 155.204(b).
-
Expressly allege the child’s county of residence and the duration of residence.
-
Identify the proper transferee court or county.
-
Cite §§ 155.201(b) and 155.204(c)–(d).
-
Preserve proof of service and calculate the deadline for a controverting affidavit.
-
Although not required, consider attaching residence evidence in anticipation of a contested hearing.
-
If no qualifying controverting affidavit is timely filed, request transfer without a hearing.
Preparing a Controverting Affidavit
-
Calendar the first Monday after the twentieth day following service of the transfer motion.
-
Review the exact residence allegations made by the movant.
-
Obtain facts from a witness with personal knowledge.
-
Expressly deny that the child resided in the proposed transferee county for the required six-month period, if supportable.
-
State the facts supporting the denial, including dates, locations, school enrollment, possession arrangements, or temporary absences.
-
Address each child separately if their residence histories differ.
-
Avoid relying solely on inconvenience, the responding parent’s residence, or the nature of the requested relief.
-
Do not use “I do not know” as a substitute for denying the statutory ground.
-
Ensure the affidavit or unsworn declaration complies with applicable formal requirements.
-
File and serve the affidavit before the statutory deadline.
Responding to a Deficient Affidavit
-
Determine whether the affidavit actually denies the alleged transfer ground.
-
Distinguish a factual denial from lack of knowledge, argument, or personal preference.
-
Object that the residence allegation remains effectively uncontroverted.
-
Cite § 155.204(c) and request transfer without an evidentiary hearing.
-
Object before testimony begins if the trial court attempts to hold a hearing.
-
Explain that hearing evidence cannot cure the absence of a timely qualifying affidavit.
-
Obtain a clear ruling and ensure the objection is reflected in the reporter’s record.
-
Request a written transfer order identifying the proper county and court.
Preserving Mandamus Relief
-
Secure a record of the transfer motion, proof of service, response, and purported controverting affidavit.
-
Include the relevant pleadings and the order establishing continuing, exclusive jurisdiction.
-
Obtain a reporter’s record of any transfer hearing.
-
Document the trial court’s oral or written ruling.
-
Demonstrate that the transfer motion was timely.
-
Show why the opposing affidavit failed to deny the statutory transfer ground.
-
Cite the unavailability of interlocutory appeal under § 155.204(h).
-
Explain why trial in the wrong county is not an adequate appellate remedy.
-
Seek mandamus promptly after the court refuses mandatory transfer.
Citation
In re Medyanik, No. 14-26-00906-CV (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Nov. 19, 2026, orig. proceeding).
Full Opinion
Read the full opinion in In re Medyanik.
~~4a0b0fe4-f4ed-4049-80f0-cf902eed2599~~
Share this content:

