Site icon Thomas J. Daley

Section 22.04 Omission Liability | Gonzalez v. State (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Gonzalez v. State, 02-25-00437-CR, November 12, 2026.

On appeal from 297th District Court, Tarrant County, Texas

Synopsis

Legally sufficient evidence supported Gonzalez’s conviction under Texas Penal Code Section 22.04 for injury to a child by omission causing serious bodily injury. Gonzalez’s legal custody of A.N., her prolonged and readily observable malnutrition and injuries, his failure to obtain medical care, and his inconsistent explanations permitted a rational jury to find beyond a reasonable doubt that he failed to protect her and provide necessary care.

Relevance to Family Law

Although Gonzalez is a criminal case, its treatment of omission liability is directly relevant to custody disputes, suits affecting the parent-child relationship, termination proceedings, protective-order matters, and divorces involving allegations of abuse or neglect. A conservator or caregiver cannot avoid legal consequences merely by denying that he personally inflicted an injury. Evidence that an adult with custody or control of a child knew of obvious injuries, malnutrition, medical distress, or abuse and nevertheless failed to intervene may support criminal liability under Section 22.04 and materially affect findings concerning family violence, endangerment, conservatorship, possession, access, and the need for emergency relief.

For family-law litigators, the case underscores the importance of developing evidence about the responsible adult’s opportunity to observe the child, legal or assumed caregiving duties, access to food and medical care, explanations for the child’s condition, and efforts—or lack of efforts—to obtain assistance. In a divorce or SAPCR, those same facts may bear on Texas Family Code Sections 153.002 and 153.004, emergency temporary orders, supervised possession, geographic and communication restrictions, and termination grounds based on endangerment. Property issues may also arise when community funds were used to conceal abuse, defend related criminal conduct, or dissipate assets during parallel family-law and criminal proceedings, although Gonzalez itself does not decide a property-division issue.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

A.N. was removed from her biological parents when she was slightly older than two and began living with her paternal aunt and Martin Gonzalez, who were in a dating relationship. The aunt and Gonzalez later obtained legal custody of A.N. Thus, this was not a case in which the accused was merely present in the same residence: Gonzalez occupied a legally recognized custodial role and had responsibility for the child’s care and protection.

When A.N. was approximately four and a half years old, first responders were called to Gonzalez’s apartment because she was in cardiac arrest. She was unresponsive and appeared to have been placed on her back in a room. Her blood-glucose level was 23, compared with a normal level of approximately 100. First responders described her as severely malnourished, emaciated, and “like a mummy.” Although she was more than four years old, she weighed less than 30 pounds and appeared much younger.

A.N.’s ribs and other bones were visible beneath her skin. Her body displayed bruising in different colors, patterned scarring, pronounced horseshoe-shaped marks, facial injuries, and a swollen eye. First responders could not resuscitate her, and she was later pronounced dead at the hospital. A child-abuse physician advised investigators that A.N.’s body showed signs of abuse and malnutrition.

Gonzalez gave investigators a series of explanations for A.N.’s condition. He attributed her low weight to genetics and a high metabolism. He claimed that she injured herself, threw herself onto a bed frame, fell frequently, or fell down stairs. He also stated that the horseshoe-shaped marks had existed for months and had concerned him, but he acknowledged that he did not take A.N. to a physician.

Gonzalez told detectives that he found A.N. unresponsive at approximately 1:30 p.m., even though neither he nor the aunt had seen her alive since approximately 3:00 a.m. the preceding day. Investigators found that account concerning because A.N. slept in an open office area of the one-bedroom apartment, and the adults had been present. Neighbors reportedly did not know that a child lived in the apartment.

The State ultimately tried Gonzalez for aggravated assault of a family or household member with a deadly weapon causing serious bodily injury and injury to a child by omission causing serious bodily injury. The omission count encompassed failures to provide adequate nutrition and to seek timely or adequate medical care. The jury convicted Gonzalez and assessed sentences of 50 years on the aggravated-assault count and 45 years on the injury-to-a-child count, to run concurrently.

Issues Decided

  1. Whether the evidence was legally sufficient to prove injury to a child by omission causing serious bodily injury under Texas Penal Code Section 22.04, including whether Gonzalez’s omissions caused A.N.’s serious bodily injury.

  2. To the extent Gonzalez’s briefing challenged both convictions, whether the evidence was legally sufficient to sustain the aggravated-assault conviction.

  3. Whether imposing punishment for both aggravated assault of a family or household member and injury to a child by omission violated the constitutional prohibition against multiple punishments for the same offense.

Rules Applied

Texas Penal Code Section 22.04 criminalizes intentionally, knowingly, recklessly, or with criminal negligence causing serious bodily injury to a child by act or omission. When the State relies on an omission, Section 22.04 requires a basis for imposing responsibility on the accused, such as a statutory duty to act or the accused’s assumption of care, custody, or control of the child. See Tex. Penal Code §§ 6.01(c), 22.04.

The applicable degree of the offense depends on the charged culpable mental state and the resulting injury. Under Section 22.04(e), an offense involving serious bodily injury is a first-degree felony when committed intentionally or knowingly.

For evidentiary sufficiency, an appellate court views all evidence in the light most favorable to the verdict and asks whether any rational factfinder could have found every essential element beyond a reasonable doubt. Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 319 (1979); Baltimore v. State, 689 S.W.3d 331, 341–42 (Tex. Crim. App. 2024).

The reviewing court measures the evidence against a hypothetically correct jury charge—one that accurately states the law, is authorized by the indictment, does not unnecessarily increase the State’s burden or restrict its theories, and adequately describes the charged offense. Lang v. State, 664 S.W.3d 155, 168–69 (Tex. Crim. App. 2022).

The jury determines witness credibility, resolves conflicts in the evidence, and draws reasonable inferences from proven facts. An appellate court does not reweigh the evidence or substitute its credibility determinations for those of the jury. Circumstantial evidence is as probative as direct evidence, and sufficiency is evaluated from the cumulative force of all admitted evidence. David v. State, 663 S.W.3d 673, 678 (Tex. Crim. App. 2022); Edward v. State, 635 S.W.3d 649, 655–56 (Tex. Crim. App. 2021).

The court also applied Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 38.9’s direction that briefing rules be construed liberally. Although Gonzalez inaccurately described the number and nature of the injury-to-a-child counts, the court construed his brief as challenging the convictions actually rendered.

Application

The omission theory did not rest on Gonzalez’s mere proximity to A.N. He and the aunt had obtained legal custody, establishing a duty to provide care and protection. The jury could therefore assess whether Gonzalez failed to fulfill that duty by withholding adequate nutrition, failing to secure timely medical treatment, or failing to protect A.N. from the conditions producing her injuries.

The child’s condition supplied powerful circumstantial evidence that the neglect was prolonged and observable. A.N. was dramatically underweight, emaciated, visibly bruised, scarred, and injured. Her bones were visible, her eye was swollen shut, and her body displayed patterned marks in various stages of discoloration. These were not hidden symptoms or a sudden condition that a caregiver might reasonably have missed.

Gonzalez’s own statements further supported the verdict. He acknowledged that the horseshoe-shaped marks had existed for months and that they concerned him, yet he did not obtain medical care. He offered changing explanations for those marks, attributing them at different times to a bed frame, self-injury, and a fall down stairs. The jury was entitled to reject those explanations and treat their inconsistency as circumstantial evidence of knowledge and culpability.

The timeline also supported an inference of omission. Gonzalez claimed that he found A.N. unresponsive in the early afternoon, but that neither caregiver had seen her alive since the early morning of the preceding day, despite the child sleeping in an open area of a small apartment. Viewed with the child’s severe malnutrition and extensive injuries, the evidence permitted the jury to find that Gonzalez failed to monitor, protect, feed, and obtain necessary treatment for a child entrusted to his care.

The appellate court did not isolate each fact or require direct evidence of every component of Gonzalez’s mental state. Instead, it considered the cumulative force of the child’s condition, the duration and visibility of her injuries, Gonzalez’s custodial responsibility, his admitted failure to seek care, and his inconsistent explanations. Applying the deferential Jackson standard, the court concluded that the inferences drawn by the jury were rational.

The court likewise rejected Gonzalez’s multiple-punishments argument. As charged and submitted, the aggravated-assault conviction addressed affirmative assaultive conduct, while the Section 22.04 conviction addressed distinct omissions involving nutrition, medical care, and protection. The concurrent sentences did not eliminate the need for double-jeopardy review, but the court concluded that the two convictions did not constitute impermissible multiple punishments for the same offense.

Holding

The Second Court of Appeals held that the evidence was legally sufficient to support Gonzalez’s conviction for injury to a child by omission causing serious bodily injury. A rational jury could find beyond a reasonable doubt that Gonzalez had a duty to care for A.N. and that his failure to protect her, provide adequate nutrition, and obtain timely or adequate medical care caused serious bodily injury.

The court also upheld the aggravated-assault conviction. Viewing the record in the light most favorable to the verdict and deferring to the jury’s credibility determinations and reasonable inferences, the court found the evidence sufficient to sustain the conviction.

Finally, the court held that Gonzalez’s double-jeopardy rights were not violated by convictions and punishments for both aggravated assault and injury to a child by omission. The court affirmed the trial court’s judgment.

Practical Application

Custody and conservatorship disputes. When a parent or proposed conservator claims not to have personally injured a child, counsel should examine whether the adult observed signs of abuse, failed to seek treatment, left the child with a dangerous caregiver, withheld nutrition, or otherwise failed to exercise a protective duty. Inaction may be as consequential as affirmative misconduct when determining best interest, conservatorship, and possession.

Emergency temporary orders. Severe weight loss, unexplained bruising, delayed medical treatment, changing explanations, or efforts to isolate a child may support an application for emergency relief. Counsel should present the evidence as a chronology showing what the caregiver knew, when the caregiver knew it, what options were available, and what the caregiver failed to do.

Family-violence findings. A family-law court may need to consider both affirmative abuse and a caregiver’s failure to protect the child from another household member. The analysis should not stop with identifying the person who allegedly inflicted the injury. The litigation record should address every adult who exercised care, custody, or control.

Termination and endangerment cases. The same facts relevant to Section 22.04 omission liability may be material to endangerment grounds under Texas Family Code Section 161.001. The criminal burden of proof is higher, but family-law counsel should independently develop the civil record rather than assume that an indictment, arrest, or conviction alone resolves the statutory termination elements.

Parallel criminal and family proceedings. Counsel must coordinate discovery and testimony with the client’s criminal counsel. Depositions, affidavits, inventories, discovery responses, and temporary-orders testimony can create admissions affecting a prosecution. Conversely, body-camera recordings, medical records, forensic photographs, and recorded interviews from a criminal investigation may become critical evidence in the SAPCR.

Appellate briefing. Accurately identify the judgment, count, statutory subsection, culpable mental state, and indictment allegations. The court liberally construed Gonzalez’s inaccurate description of his convictions, but practitioners should not depend on Rule 38.9 to cure avoidable errors. Sufficiency analysis must be tied to the elements of a hypothetically correct jury charge authorized by the actual charging instrument.

Checklists

Develop an Omission-Based Child-Safety Record

Prepare for Emergency Custody Relief

Manage Parallel Criminal and Family-Law Proceedings

Preserve a Sufficiency Challenge for Appeal

Avoid the Errors That Undermined Gonzalez’s Position

Citation

Gonzalez v. State, No. 02-25-00437-CR, slip op. (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Nov. 12, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion

~~287324e5-aadd-48dc-915f-b795daf1e8e6~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version