Site icon Thomas J. Daley

Section 9.010 Money Judgment Cannot Exceed Decree-Based Damages | Murungi v. Kawinzi (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Murungi v. Kawinzi, 14-25-01011-CV, November 17, 2026.

On appeal from 308th District Court, Harris County, Texas

Synopsis

Texas Family Code § 9.010(a) authorizes a money judgment only for damages caused by a party’s failure to comply with a divorce decree; it does not permit a court to redistribute the marital estate. When the decree awarded each spouse 50% of the net proceeds from a residence, the enforcement judgment could provide the former spouse with her full 50% share—but no more.

Relevance to Family Law

Murungi is an important limitation on post-divorce property enforcement. Although a trial court has broad tools to enforce an existing property division, Texas Family Code § 9.007(a) prohibits it from amending, modifying, altering, or changing that division. Litigators seeking a money judgment under § 9.010(a) must therefore tie the requested amount to decree-based damages and demonstrate that the award restores the client to the economic position the decree required.

The decision also reinforces the distinction between enforcing a decree and collaterally attacking it. Complaints about the original property division, valuation findings, travel restrictions, and child-support provisions cannot ordinarily be raised for the first time in an appeal from a later enforcement or disbursement order. Counsel must identify whether a complaint concerns the final decree itself or the trial court’s subsequent implementation of that decree—and preserve and appeal it accordingly.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

The May 31, 2024 final divorce decree required the parties’ former marital residence to be sold through a receiver. After payment of the costs of sale, receiver fees and the first mortgage, the resulting net sale proceeds were to be divided equally between Charles Kimiathi Murungi and Sarah Kawinzi.

Before entry of the decree, Murungi had obtained a $150,000 second mortgage, referred to as the Discover Loan. The decree assigned that debt to Murungi as his separate liability and required him to satisfy it personally. If he failed to pay the loan before closing, the decree authorized the receiver to reallocate the sale proceeds to effectuate the requirement that Murungi bear 100% of the outstanding balance.

Murungi did not satisfy the Discover Loan before the receiver sold the residence. The sale generated $259,490.31 in net proceeds as that term was defined by the decree. Because the second mortgage remained outstanding, however, $148,114.40 had to be paid from the sale funds to clear title. Only $111,375.91 remained in the receiver’s trust account.

The trial court awarded Kawinzi all $111,375.91 remaining in the account and entered an additional money judgment in her favor for $92,426.44. The combined award was $203,802.35.

Murungi appealed the disbursement order and also attempted to challenge several matters resolved by the unappealed final decree, including the overall property division, property classification and valuation, travel restrictions, and child-support provisions.

Issues Decided

Rules Applied

Texas Family Code § 9.007(a) prohibits a court from amending, modifying, altering, or changing the division of property established by a final divorce decree. An enforcement order may implement or clarify the decree, but it may not substantively redistribute the property division.

Texas Family Code § 9.010(a) provides that when a party fails to comply with a divorce decree and delivery of the awarded property is no longer an adequate remedy, the trial court may render a money judgment for the damages caused by the noncompliance. The recoverable judgment is compensatory: it must correspond to the loss resulting from the failure to comply.

The court also relied on Hagen v. Hagen, 282 S.W.3d 899, 902 (Tex. 2009), for the principle that an attempt to obtain an enforcement order altering or modifying a divorce decree’s property division constitutes an impermissible collateral attack.

Application

The court began with the final decree’s controlling allocation: Murungi and Kawinzi were each entitled to one-half of the residence’s net sale proceeds. Under the decree’s definition, the net proceeds were $259,490.31. Each spouse’s decree-based entitlement was therefore $129,745.16.

Murungi’s failure to satisfy the Discover Loan reduced the cash remaining in the receiver’s account to $111,375.91. Because the decree made Murungi solely responsible for that loan, the trial court had authority under § 9.010(a) to enter a money judgment compensating Kawinzi for the loss caused by his noncompliance. The court agreed that an add-back analysis could be appropriate when one co-owner’s separate obligation is paid from a shared asset pool.

The problem was not the trial court’s authority to compensate Kawinzi; it was the amount awarded. Giving Kawinzi the entire $111,375.91 in the receiver’s account plus a $92,426.44 judgment produced a total recovery of $203,802.35. That amount substantially exceeded the $129,745.16 she would have received if Murungi had complied with the decree.

Section 9.010(a) did not authorize that excess recovery. A money judgment could cure the shortfall caused by Murungi’s default, but it could not provide Kawinzi with more than the decree awarded. The excess constituted a windfall and impermissibly deviated from the decree’s 50/50 division.

To place Kawinzi in the position required by the decree, she needed $18,369.25 in addition to the $111,375.91 held by the receiver. Those amounts totaled $129,745.16—her one-half share of the net sale proceeds.

As to Murungi’s other appellate complaints, the court concluded that he could not use the later disbursement appeal to challenge provisions of the final decree. Because the decree had not been timely appealed, his attacks on the original property division, valuation determinations, travel restrictions, and child-support provisions were impermissible collateral challenges.

Holding

A money judgment under Texas Family Code § 9.010(a) may compensate a former spouse for damages caused by the other party’s failure to comply with a divorce decree. It may not, however, provide a recovery exceeding the property interest awarded by the decree because that would alter the property division in violation of § 9.007(a).

Kawinzi was entitled to receive a total of $129,745.16, representing her 50% share of the decree-defined net sale proceeds. After receiving the $111,375.91 remaining in the receiver’s account, she was entitled to an additional money judgment of only $18,369.25—not $92,426.44.

Murungi’s challenges to matters resolved in the final divorce decree were dismissed for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals modified the enforcement judgment by reducing Kawinzi’s additional money award from $92,426.44 to $18,369.25 and affirmed the judgment as modified.

Practical Application

For the party seeking enforcement, Murungi requires a disciplined damages model. Counsel should identify the precise property interest awarded by the decree, calculate what the client actually received, and request only the difference attributable to the opposing party’s noncompliance. Evidence of misconduct may establish liability or support other remedies, but it does not enlarge the property award contained in the decree.

For the responding party, the case provides a focused objection to an excessive enforcement request. The relevant question is not merely whether the party violated the decree. The court must also determine whether the requested money judgment compensates for the resulting loss or instead creates a recovery greater than the decree permits.

The same analysis can arise in several post-divorce settings:

Although Murungi primarily concerns property enforcement, its procedural lesson extends to other family-law orders. Counsel should not assume that a later enforcement proceeding permits a collateral challenge to custody, possession, travel, or support provisions that became final in an earlier order. The substantive statutes governing modification and enforcement differ, but finality and preservation remain critical.

Checklists

Drafting the Divorce Decree

Preparing a Section 9.010 Money-Judgment Request

Challenging an Excessive Enforcement Award

Auditing a Receiver’s Accounting

Preserving Appellate Complaints

Citation

Murungi v. Kawinzi, No. 14-25-01011-CV (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Nov. 17, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion in Murungi v. Kawinzi.

~~3d2558bf-9833-4775-b72d-08cbbb229819~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version