Site icon Thomas J. Daley

Subsection E Endangerment Through Cocaine Use | In re R.A.P. (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

In the Interest of R.A.P., a Child, 13-26-00523-CV, November 19, 2026.

On appeal from 444th District Court of Cameron County, Texas

Synopsis

The Thirteenth Court of Appeals held that Father’s repeated cocaine use, missed drug tests, criminal conduct, and continuing instability legally and factually supported termination under Texas Family Code § 161.001(b)(1)(E). The same evidence, together with the child’s stability and strong bond in an adoptive foster home, supported the finding under § 161.001(b)(2) that termination was in the child’s best interest.

Relevance to Family Law

Although In re R.A.P. is a termination case, its evidentiary lessons extend to custody litigation in divorce and other suits affecting the parent-child relationship. A sustained pattern of illegal drug use, missed testing, criminal conduct, interrupted visitation, and unstable housing can establish more than isolated poor judgment; it can demonstrate an ongoing course of conduct affecting a parent’s ability to provide a safe and stable environment. In conservatorship and possession disputes, the same evidence may support temporary restrictions, supervised possession, sobriety conditions, geographic or exchange safeguards, and modification of an existing order.

The case also underscores that litigators should connect parental misconduct to present and future parenting capacity rather than rely on labels or status alone. In particular, incarceration, deportation, or immigration status should not be treated as an independent proxy for endangerment. The probative evidence is the parent’s conduct, the resulting instability, the absence of a verifiable residence or workable care plan, the interruption of the parent-child relationship, and the parent’s inability or unwillingness to address the conditions affecting the child.

The decision has less direct application to property division, but related evidence can affect litigation strategy in a divorce involving conservatorship. Drug use, criminal proceedings, and unexplained instability may influence requests for temporary orders, exclusive use of a residence, control of vehicles, interim payment obligations, and preservation of funds needed for testing, treatment, or supervised visitation.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Rex was removed at birth after Mother, Father, and the child tested positive for cocaine. Mother also had received no prenatal care. Father sought placement, but the trial court required him to produce a clean hair-follicle test before the child could be placed with him.

Father did not satisfy that condition. A September 2024 hair-follicle test was positive for cocaine and related metabolites. An October urinalysis was positive for cocaine, Father failed to appear for a required November test, and a December urinalysis was again positive. He missed another test later that month. In January 2025, Father once more tested positive for cocaine and cocaine metabolites.

The trial court ordered Father to participate in supervised visitation, counseling, random drug testing, a psychosocial evaluation, and a substance-abuse assessment. It also required him to pay child support and provide a safe home. Father completed the psychosocial evaluation and substance-abuse assessment but did not complete the remaining services. Before his incarceration, he also missed eleven of twenty-one offered visits, according to the Department, and last visited Rex in February 2025.

Father was arrested in February 2025 for driving while intoxicated and reckless driving. After incarceration and immigration detention, he was deported to Mexico. The caseworker attempted to locate Father and arrange services, testing, and visitation, but Father would not disclose his address or even the city in which he lived. He instead told the caseworker to place visitation “on pause.” Because he did not provide an address, the Department could not evaluate his proposed home.

Father later reentered the United States and was arrested again. At trial, he remained in federal detention and acknowledged that he likely would be deported again. His proposed plan was to take Rex to Mexico while Father prepared to return to the United States, even though he recognized another return could lead to another arrest and additional incarceration.

Father disputed portions of the Department’s evidence. He denied using illegal drugs after Rex’s birth, denied missing as many visits as the caseworker reported, and proposed that Rex live either with him at his brother’s home in Mexico or with the paternal grandmother. The Department had not been able to evaluate Father’s proposed residence. It also found the paternal grandmother unsuitable because of her limited resources, health needs, home conditions, lack of a relationship with Rex, and prior Department history.

Rex had lived with the same foster family since the day after his birth. The evidence showed that the foster family provided a stable, nurturing environment, met the child’s developmental and therapeutic needs, and intended to adopt him. Rex was strongly bonded to the family, which was the only family unit he had known.

Issues Decided

Rules Applied

Texas Family Code § 161.001(b) requires clear and convincing evidence of both a statutory predicate ground and that termination is in the child’s best interest. Clear and convincing evidence is the degree of proof that produces in the factfinder’s mind a firm belief or conviction as to the truth of the allegations.

Under § 161.001(b)(1)(E), termination may be based on proof that a parent engaged in conduct, or knowingly placed the child with persons who engaged in conduct, that endangered the child’s physical or emotional well-being. The inquiry focuses on the parent’s conduct and ordinarily requires examination of a voluntary, deliberate, and conscious course of conduct rather than a single act or omission.

Endangerment does not require proof that the child suffered an actual injury. Illegal drug use can expose a child to instability and uncertainty and can support an endangerment finding, particularly when the use is repeated, persists during the Department’s case, or is accompanied by missed tests, criminal behavior, incarceration, and an inability to maintain a safe home.

In reviewing legal sufficiency in a parental-termination case, an appellate court considers the evidence in the light most favorable to the finding and asks whether a reasonable factfinder could form a firm belief or conviction that the finding was true. In reviewing factual sufficiency, the court considers the entire record, including disputed evidence, and determines whether contrary evidence is so significant that the factfinder could not reasonably have formed the required firm belief or conviction.

The best-interest determination under § 161.001(b)(2) is child-centered and may include the child’s needs, present and future danger, the parenting abilities of the individuals seeking custody, available programs, plans for the child, the stability of the proposed placements, and any excuses for the parent’s conduct. The same evidence may support both a statutory predicate ground and the best-interest finding. See In re C.H., 89 S.W.3d 17, 26–28 (Tex. 2002). Although parental rights are constitutionally significant, the child’s physical and emotional interests cannot be sacrificed merely to preserve the parent-child relationship. See Holick v. Smith, 685 S.W.2d 18, 20–21 (Tex. 1985).

Application

The court viewed Father’s cocaine use as a pattern rather than an isolated lapse. Rex tested positive at birth, Father’s hair-follicle test was positive shortly afterward, and subsequent urine and hair testing continued to show cocaine and related metabolites. Father also failed to appear for multiple requested tests. This evidence allowed the factfinder to reject Father’s assertion that he had remained drug-free since the child’s birth.

The drug evidence did not stand alone. Father failed to complete significant portions of his court-ordered services, missed numerous visits, and had not seen Rex for more than a year by the time of trial. His arrest for DWI and reckless driving resulted in incarceration, immigration detention, and deportation. He later reentered the country and was detained again, leaving his future location and availability uncertain.

After his deportation, Father would not provide the Department with his address or location. That refusal prevented a home study and obstructed efforts to arrange testing, services, and visitation. His proposed plan likewise lacked stability: he wanted Rex to live at his brother’s home in Mexico while he prepared to return to the United States, despite acknowledging that another return could produce another arrest and period of incarceration.

The court’s analysis did not rest merely on Father’s immigration circumstances. The material evidence concerned his repeated illegal drug use, criminal choices, recurring detention, refusal to disclose a residence, lack of a verified home, incomplete services, minimal recent contact with the child, and absence of a workable long-term parenting plan. Taken together, those facts constituted a continuing course of conduct from which the trial court could form a firm conviction that Father endangered Rex’s physical or emotional well-being.

The best-interest evidence reinforced that conclusion. Rex had lived with the foster family for essentially his entire life. He was bonded to the family, integrated into its extended-family network, meeting developmental milestones, attending daycare, and receiving appropriate occupational therapy. The foster family offered continuity and intended to adopt him. In contrast, Father had no verified residence, had not demonstrated sustained sobriety, remained detained, and could not articulate a stable plan for Rex’s care.

Father offered explanations and disputed the Department’s account of his missed visits and continued cocaine use. The trial court, however, was entitled to resolve credibility conflicts and weigh Father’s denials against objective testing, missed tests, Department records, and his own testimony concerning his criminal and residential instability.

Holding

The court held that the evidence was legally and factually sufficient to support termination under Texas Family Code § 161.001(b)(1)(E). Father’s repeated cocaine use, missed tests, criminal conduct, incomplete services, disrupted visitation, and inability to establish a safe and stable home permitted a reasonable factfinder to form a firm belief or conviction that he engaged in a course of conduct endangering the child.

The court also held that legally and factually sufficient evidence supported the best-interest finding under § 161.001(b)(2). Rex’s secure bond with his foster family, the stability and permanence available through adoption, and Father’s unresolved substance-abuse and housing instability supported the trial court’s determination that termination served the child’s best interest.

Finally, the court affirmed the appointment of the Department as permanent managing conservator. Once the predicate and best-interest findings supporting termination were sustained, the record provided no basis to disturb the related conservatorship ruling.

Practical Application

Build a chronology, not a collection of incidents. Subsection (E) asks whether the evidence demonstrates an endangering course of conduct. A chronology tying together test results, missed tests, arrests, periods of incarceration, missed visits, service-plan compliance, housing changes, and communications with the Department will ordinarily be more persuasive than presenting each event in isolation.

Use objective testing to confront credibility disputes. Father denied post-birth drug use, but the Department presented repeated positive results and missed tests. Obtain the underlying laboratory reports, chain-of-custody records, testing protocols, metabolite information, and witness testimony necessary to authenticate and explain the results. Anticipate challenges involving passive exposure, prescription medication, contamination, testing windows, and laboratory thresholds.

Do not rely on a missed drug test without developing context. Establish that the parent received notice, understood the testing obligation, had a reasonable opportunity to comply, and failed to provide a credible explanation. Multiple missed tests are more probative when considered alongside positive results and other evidence of avoidance.

Separate immigration status from parental conduct. In custody or termination litigation involving an undocumented, detained, or deported parent, focus on evidence relevant to parenting: the availability of a verified residence, ability to participate in services, consistency of contact, proposed caregivers, transportation arrangements, and the feasibility of the parent’s plan. Nationality, deportation, or residence outside the United States should not substitute for proof of endangerment or best interest.

Investigate proposed foreign placements early. If a parent proposes placement outside Texas or outside the United States, immediately seek a complete address, household composition, ownership or lease records, criminal-history information, photographs, references, school and medical plans, and available governmental or consular assistance. A vague plan presented at trial is unlikely to overcome a developed record of instability.

Treat visitation history as substantive evidence. Document each offered visit, confirmation, cancellation, no-show, late arrival, and observed interaction. If a parent requests shorter visits or pauses contact, preserve the communication and explore the stated reason. In a nontermination SAPCR, the same evidence may affect the structure, duration, and supervision of possession.

Develop best interest independently. Proof of a predicate ground does not eliminate the need for a child-specific best-interest record. Present evidence regarding attachment, developmental progress, therapy, medical care, routines, sibling and extended-family relationships, placement stability, and the permanency plan.

For the parent’s counsel, replace promises with verifiable proof. A parent facing an endangerment allegation should disclose a residence, submit to testing, obtain independent testing when appropriate, complete treatment, preserve service records, maintain contact, and present a concrete care plan. General assurances of sobriety or future stability rarely overcome repeated objective evidence to the contrary.

Checklists

Building a Subsection (E) Endangerment Record

Proving Best Interest

Defending a Parent Accused of Drug-Related Endangerment

Evaluating a Proposed Out-of-State or International Placement

Preparing for a Conservatorship or Possession Dispute

Citation

In re R.A.P., No. 13-26-00523-CV, slip op. (Tex. App.—Corpus Christi–Edinburg Nov. 19, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion

~~d693ba49-d727-495b-9df5-6aea0b5a1ee4~~

Share this content:

Exit mobile version