Loading Now

Family Code § 4.102 Excludes Post-Divorce Income | Holland v. Holland (2026)

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Holland v. Holland, 14-26-00045-CV, November 17, 2026.

On appeal from 245th District Court, Harris County, Texas

Synopsis

Texas Family Code §§ 4.102, 4.104, and 4.105 govern agreements partitioning or exchanging community property, not a spouse’s promise to pay half of income earned after divorce. Because the promised payments concerned post-divorce income rather than existing or future-acquired community property, the Fourteenth Court held that Donna Holland could not invoke those provisions to establish enforceability.

Relevance to Family Law

Holland draws an important classification line for marital-property litigation. Labeling an instrument a “postnuptial agreement” does not necessarily bring every promise in that instrument within Chapter 4 of the Family Code. A provision allocating community property may be governed by §§ 4.102–.105, while a promise concerning post-divorce income or contractual alimony may instead be governed by general contract law.

That distinction affects pleading, discovery, trial strategy, and appellate briefing. Counsel seeking to enforce a promise based on post-divorce earnings should not rely exclusively on the Family Code’s partition-and-exchange provisions. Conversely, counsel resisting enforcement should examine whether the provision actually partitions community property, creates contractual support obligations, or attempts to transfer income that will arise only after the marital estate ceases to exist.

The opinion also reinforces two recurring appellate concerns in family cases. First, a challenge involving federal retirement benefits must identify the particular deficiency in the decree and the governing federal provisions; a global citation to an extensive regulatory scheme will not suffice. Second, complaints about a trial judge’s questioning ordinarily require a timely objection unless the record demonstrates the rare level of incurable judicial bias that makes fair judgment impossible.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

Donna and Larry Holland married in December 2017 and separated approximately two years later. During the marriage, they signed and notarized a short postnuptial agreement without apparent assistance from counsel. The agreement stated that, in the event of divorce, Larry would pay Donna 50% of his income until either party died. It also stated that Donna would retain 100% of her businesses and that Larry and his heirs would make no claims against them.

At the bench trial, Donna sought enforcement of the agreement. Larry responded that he was not in the proper mental state when he signed it because he was experiencing depression and post-traumatic stress disorder and feared losing everything. During Donna’s testimony, the trial judge asked whether she had told Larry that she would not remain with him unless he signed the agreement. The judge also asked questions concerning Donna’s work history and the parties’ separation. Donna’s attorney did not object and was permitted to conduct additional examination addressing the court’s concerns.

The divorce decree denied enforcement of the postnuptial agreement as invalid and unconscionable. The court nevertheless awarded Donna portions of Larry’s 401(k) and United States Postal Service retirement benefits.

Donna later sought a judgment nunc pro tunc, asserting that the decree lacked language necessary to implement the award of federal retirement benefits. The trial court entered a nunc pro tunc judgment, but Donna maintained on appeal that the revised decree remained deficient.

Issues Decided

The Fourteenth Court of Appeals decided three issues:

  1. Whether the divorce decree, as corrected by the judgment nunc pro tunc, omitted language necessary for Donna to obtain the awarded USPS retirement benefits.

  2. Whether Family Code §§ 4.102, 4.104, and 4.105 governed the provision requiring Larry to pay Donna 50% of his post-divorce income until either party’s death.

  3. Whether the trial judge reversibly erred by questioning Donna about the execution of the postnuptial agreement and other matters relevant to the bench trial.

Rules Applied

  • Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 38.1(i): An appellant’s brief must provide a clear and concise argument supported by appropriate citations to authority and the record. An appellate court is not required to search a voluminous regulatory framework or construct an appellant’s argument.

  • Texas Family Code § 3.002: Community property consists of property, other than separate property, acquired by either spouse during marriage.

  • Texas Family Code § 4.102: Spouses may partition or exchange existing or future-acquired community property. Property transferred under such an agreement becomes the receiving spouse’s separate property, and the agreement may address future earnings and income arising from transferred property.

  • Texas Family Code § 4.104: A partition or exchange agreement under § 4.102 must be written and signed by both parties and is enforceable without consideration.

  • Texas Family Code § 4.105: A partition or exchange agreement may be challenged on the statutory grounds of involuntariness or unconscionability accompanied by the specified disclosure deficiencies. Unconscionability is decided by the court as a matter of law, and the section provides the exclusive remedies and defenses for agreements within its scope.

  • General contract law: The court relied by analogy on decisions holding that agreements to pay contractual alimony or spousal maintenance may be governed by ordinary contract principles rather than the Family Code’s marital-property provisions. See McCartney v. McCartney, 720 S.W.3d 789, 804–05 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2025, no pet.); McCollough v. McCollough, 212 S.W.3d 638, 645–48 (Tex. App.—Austin 2006, no pet.).

  • Preservation of judicial-conduct complaints: A party ordinarily must make a timely objection to a trial judge’s questioning. The narrow exception for incurable judicial bias applies only when the judge displays deep-seated favoritism or antagonism that would make fair judgment impossible.

Application

Donna argued that the agreement’s execution as a signed, notarized postnuptial instrument brought it within Family Code §§ 4.102, 4.104, and 4.105. The court rejected that premise by focusing on the subject of the disputed provision rather than the document’s label or formalities.

The operative provision did not divide property owned by the marital estate. Nor did it transfer an existing community-property interest and then characterize income generated by that transferred property. Instead, it required Larry to pay Donna one-half of income he would earn after the marriage ended. Because income acquired after divorce is not acquired “during marriage,” it is not community property under § 3.002. The promise therefore did not constitute a partition or exchange of community property governed by §§ 4.102–.105.

That conclusion did not necessarily mean a promise concerning post-divorce income could never be contractual. The court cited decisions treating contractual alimony and maintenance obligations under general contract law. Donna, however, presented no appellate argument based on contract law or another source of law. The court therefore rejected the statutory theory she actually briefed rather than developing an alternative enforcement theory for her.

Donna’s federal-retirement complaint failed for a separate briefing reason. She cited Title 5, Part 838 of the Code of Federal Regulations as a whole but did not identify a particular regulation, explain exactly what the nunc pro tunc decree lacked, or propose the language necessary to make the award implementable. The court declined to compare the decree against the extensive federal regulatory scheme without a developed argument.

Finally, the trial judge’s questioning did not support reversal. Donna did not make a contemporaneous objection, and the record did not satisfy the narrow exception for incurable bias. The questions were brief, related to facts the judge was required to decide, and followed by an opportunity for Donna’s counsel to clarify the testimony.

Holding

The court held that Donna inadequately briefed her challenge to the provisions awarding USPS retirement benefits. A global citation to the federal regulations, without identifying the missing decree language or explaining why the order was not implementable, did not satisfy Rule 38.1(i).

The court held that Family Code §§ 4.102, 4.104, and 4.105 did not govern Larry’s promise to pay Donna 50% of his post-divorce income. Those statutes apply to agreements partitioning or exchanging community property, while Larry’s earnings after divorce would not be community property. Because Donna did not advance a general-contract or other alternative theory, her challenge to the denial of enforcement failed.

The court also held that Donna did not preserve her complaint concerning the trial judge’s questioning. The limited questioning did not demonstrate deep-seated favoritism or antagonism sufficient to establish incurable judicial bias. The Fourteenth Court affirmed the divorce decree.

Practical Application

Practitioners should classify each provision of a marital agreement independently. A single document may contain a valid partition of existing community property, an agreement regarding future-acquired community property, a waiver of claims, and a contractual promise to provide post-divorce support. Those provisions may be governed by different substantive rules and may require different enforcement theories.

When drafting an agreement tied to future income, counsel should specify whether the obligation is intended as contractual alimony, a property-equalization payment, consideration for another contractual promise, or an allocation of income generated by transferred property. The agreement should define “income,” identify payment dates and accounting obligations, address taxes and withholding, provide access to supporting records, and establish remedies for nonpayment. A provision requiring payment until death should also address retirement, disability, unemployment, remarriage, modification, security, and the effect of the obligor’s estate plan.

In litigation, counsel should plead alternative theories when the characterization of the agreement is disputed. A party seeking enforcement may need claims for breach of contract, declaratory relief, specific performance, damages, or attorney’s fees in addition to any Family Code theory. A party resisting enforcement should preserve challenges to formation, voluntariness, capacity, ambiguity, public policy, and available remedies under the law that actually governs the provision.

For federal retirement awards, the decree should be tested against the specific federal plan requirements before rendition. An appellate complaint must identify the exact defect, the controlling regulation, the relevant record location, and the corrective language requested. Broad references to Part 838 or another regulatory scheme risk waiver through inadequate briefing.

Counsel should also object promptly if judicial questioning appears improper. In a bench trial, a judge may ask questions to clarify the evidence. Waiting to complain on appeal generally forfeits the issue unless the conduct demonstrates the rare degree of incurable bias recognized by Texas law.

Checklists

Classify the Marital Agreement

  • Identify the property or obligation addressed by each provision.
  • Determine whether the property exists at the time of execution.
  • Determine whether future-acquired property will arise during or after marriage.
  • Distinguish post-divorce earnings from income generated by property transferred under a partition agreement.
  • Separate property-division provisions from contractual-support obligations.
  • Avoid assuming that the title “postnuptial agreement” determines the governing law.
  • Analyze whether §§ 4.102–.105 apply to the specific provision in dispute rather than to the document as a whole.

Draft a Post-Divorce Income Obligation

  • State whether the obligation is contractual alimony, contractual maintenance, a property-equalization payment, or another contractual obligation.
  • Define “income” and identify included and excluded sources.
  • Specify whether the calculation is based on gross income, net income, taxable income, or another measure.
  • Establish payment dates, payment methods, and reporting procedures.
  • Require production of tax returns, pay statements, and other verification documents.
  • Address bonuses, commissions, deferred compensation, retirement distributions, and self-employment income.
  • Address unemployment, disability, retirement, remarriage, and death.
  • Specify whether the obligation is modifiable and under what conditions.
  • Include default, notice, cure, interest, security, and enforcement provisions.
  • Address attorney’s fees and available contractual remedies.
  • Include severability and governing-law provisions.
  • Obtain informed written consent and document financial disclosure.

Plead and Prove Enforcement

  • Plead the Family Code only if the provision actually partitions or exchanges community property.
  • Plead breach of contract and declaratory relief when the obligation concerns post-divorce payments.
  • Plead alternative theories when characterization is uncertain.
  • Identify the contractual promise, performance, breach, and resulting damages.
  • Address consideration if the governing contract doctrine requires it.
  • Develop evidence concerning voluntariness, capacity, disclosure, and circumstances of execution.
  • Preserve arguments concerning severability if only one provision is disputed.
  • Request findings of fact and conclusions of law after a bench trial.
  • Brief every potentially viable basis for enforcement on appeal.
  • Do not rely on the appellate court to formulate an unbriefed contract theory.

Prepare a Federal Retirement Award

  • Identify the federal retirement system and the correct administering agency.
  • Determine which provisions of 5 C.F.R. Part 838 govern the particular benefit.
  • Confirm that the decree contains all required identifying and benefit-calculation information.
  • Distinguish retirement benefits from survivor-annuity benefits.
  • Specify the former spouse’s share with an administrable formula.
  • Address commencement, termination, refunds, and cost-of-living adjustments where applicable.
  • Have the proposed order reviewed for federal compliance before rendition.
  • Identify any deficiency with a citation to the specific regulation.
  • Provide the trial court with proposed corrective language.
  • On appeal, explain precisely why the order cannot be implemented as written.

Preserve Complaints About Judicial Questioning

  • Make a timely and specific objection when the questioning becomes improper.
  • State whether the objection concerns advocacy, bias, relevance, or another ground.
  • Request an opportunity to clarify the witness’s testimony.
  • Seek a ruling on the objection.
  • Request appropriate relief if the questioning causes prejudice.
  • Ensure that the reporter’s record captures the challenged conduct.
  • Do not rely on the incurable-bias exception unless the conduct demonstrates deep-seated favoritism or antagonism making fair judgment impossible.

Citation

Holland v. Holland, No. 14-26-00045-CV (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Nov. 17, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion in Holland v. Holland.

~~e321dbcb-7f4c-424d-9fe7-51749df8830d~~

Share this content:

Tom Daley is a board-certified family law attorney with extensive experience practicing across the United States, primarily in Texas. He represents clients in all aspects of family law, including negotiation, settlement, litigation, trial, and appeals.