CROSSOVER: Develop the Jurisdictional Record First: Springtown Supports Targeted Discovery Before a Fact-Dependent Jurisdiction Ruling
City of Springtown v. Hogue, 02-26-00423-CV, November 12, 2026.
On appeal from 415th District Court, Parker County, Texas
Synopsis
When disputed facts determine subject-matter jurisdiction, a trial court may deny a plea to the jurisdiction and permit narrowly targeted jurisdictional discovery before making a final jurisdictional determination. Because the City sought dismissal before discovery had developed the facts governing the Texas Tort Claims Act’s emergency exception, the Second Court of Appeals affirmed the denial and remanded for jurisdictional discovery.
Relevance to Family Law
Although Springtown arises under the Texas Tort Claims Act rather than the Family Code, its procedural lesson crosses directly into family litigation: develop the jurisdictional record before asking the court to resolve a fact-dependent jurisdictional challenge. That principle can matter in interstate custody proceedings under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act, interstate support cases under the Uniform Interstate Family Support Act, and other family-law disputes in which jurisdiction turns on contested facts such as a child’s home state, the location and duration of a child’s residence, continuing exclusive jurisdiction, the parties’ contacts with Texas, or the availability of another forum. The opinion supports a focused request for discovery when the existing record is insufficient, but it does not authorize merits-wide discovery or permit the parties to confer subject-matter jurisdiction by agreement.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
Robert Hogue alleged that a City of Springtown police officer, Sergeant Weldon Proctor, drove a police cruiser into the rear of Hogue’s vehicle while Hogue was stopped at an intersection. Hogue sued the City for negligence and invoked the Texas Tort Claims Act’s waiver of governmental immunity for claims arising from a governmental employee’s negligent operation or use of a motor vehicle.
Less than three months after suit was filed—and before depositions or an exchange of jurisdictional discovery—the City filed a plea to the jurisdiction. The City relied on a peace officer’s crash report and an eight-sentence statement from Proctor. According to those materials, the City had received a report of a possible intoxicated driver, and Proctor was looking in his side mirror for that vehicle when he collided with Hogue.
The City argued that these facts established the TTCA’s emergency exception under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 101.055(2). If applicable, that exception would prevent the motor-vehicle waiver from operating and preserve the City’s governmental immunity.
Hogue responded that the City’s own materials left material jurisdictional questions unresolved. Among other matters, he disputed whether an unconfirmed be-on-the-lookout notification constituted an emergency response and whether the officer’s decision to divert his attention from stopped traffic demonstrated conscious indifference or reckless disregard for the safety of others.
More importantly for the appellate court’s analysis, Hogue explained that jurisdictional discovery had barely begun. He requested 90 days of narrowly targeted discovery and identified the evidence he sought: body-camera and dashboard-camera recordings, Proctor’s deposition, dispatch records, emergency-response policies, vehicle speed and braking data, and information concerning the report of the possible intoxicated driver. Hogue also represented that the City had produced dashboard-camera footage shortly before the plea hearing and that the video showed the officer’s emergency lights and siren were not activated.
After a non-evidentiary hearing, the trial court denied the City’s plea without specifying the basis for its ruling. The City brought an interlocutory appeal.
Issues Decided
-
Whether the trial court was required to grant the City’s plea based on the evidentiary record presented before jurisdictional discovery had occurred.
-
Whether a trial court has discretion to defer a fact-dependent jurisdictional determination until the parties have had a reasonable opportunity to conduct targeted jurisdictional discovery.
-
Whether the trial court’s unexplained written order denying the plea could be affirmed on the ground that further factual development was necessary.
Rules Applied
The Texas Tort Claims Act waives governmental immunity for certain claims arising from a governmental employee’s negligent operation or use of a motor-driven vehicle while acting within the scope of employment. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 101.021(1).
The waiver does not apply to a claim arising from an employee’s response to an emergency call or reaction to an emergency situation if the employee acted in compliance with applicable laws and ordinances or, in the absence of such laws and ordinances, did not act with conscious indifference or reckless disregard for the safety of others. Id. § 101.055(2).
A governmental entity may challenge the existence of jurisdictional facts through a plea to the jurisdiction supported by evidence. Depending on its substance, the plea may operate like a traditional motion for summary judgment, a no-evidence motion, or a hybrid of the two. City of Austin v. Powell, 704 S.W.3d 437, 447–48 (Tex. 2024); Texas Department of Parks & Wildlife v. Miranda, 133 S.W.3d 217, 227 (Tex. 2004).
When immunity depends on specific factual prerequisites, discovery may be necessary to determine whether those prerequisites exist. A trial court therefore has discretion to decide whether to resolve jurisdiction at a preliminary hearing or await fuller development of the record. 4 Families of Hobby, LLC v. City of Houston, 730 S.W.3d 641, 644–45 & n.4 (Tex. 2026); Miranda, 133 S.W.3d at 227.
A trial court should allow a reasonable opportunity for discovery targeted to the jurisdictional facts when that discovery is necessary to illuminate the jurisdictional question. Hearts Bluff Game Ranch, Inc. v. State, 381 S.W.3d 468, 491 (Tex. 2012).
Finally, an appellate court determines the basis and scope of a trial court’s ruling from the written order, not from informal oral comments made during a hearing. Because the written order did not state a specific basis for denying the plea, the appellate court considered whether the ruling could be sustained as an exercise of discretion to await further factual development.
Application
The City’s plea did not present a purely legal question that could be resolved from the pleadings alone. It challenged the existence of facts controlling the emergency exception: whether Proctor was responding to an emergency and whether his conduct reflected conscious indifference or reckless disregard for public safety.
Those questions depended on evidence that had not yet been developed. The City filed its plea less than 75 days after suit was initiated, before depositions had occurred and before the parties had exchanged jurisdictional discovery. Its evidentiary submission consisted principally of a crash report and a brief officer statement. At the same time, those materials raised further questions about the nature of the dispatch, the officer’s response status, the use or nonuse of emergency equipment, the officer’s speed and braking, and why his attention was directed away from stopped traffic.
Hogue did more than make a generalized request for additional discovery. He identified discrete sources of evidence tied to the statutory emergency exception, including dispatch information, video recordings, the officer’s deposition, applicable City policies, and vehicle data. That showing gave the trial court a concrete basis to conclude that the jurisdictional determination should await a more complete record.
Relying particularly on 4 Families of Hobby, the appellate court held that the trial court could deny the plea as an exercise of its discretion to await further development of the jurisdictional facts. The City itself implicitly recognized the potential value of discovery by requesting jurisdictional discovery as alternative appellate relief.
Because the written order did not specify a different ground for the ruling, the appellate court could sustain it on the permissible ground that targeted jurisdictional discovery was needed. The court therefore did not finally adjudicate whether the emergency exception applied. It preserved that issue for determination after discovery.
Holding
The Second Court of Appeals held that a trial court may deny a plea to the jurisdiction when disputed, undeveloped facts control whether the Texas Tort Claims Act’s emergency exception applies. The trial court was not required to make a final immunity determination on the preliminary record presented by the City.
The court further held that the trial court acted within its discretion by awaiting jurisdictional discovery. Because Hogue identified specific discovery bearing on whether the officer was responding to an emergency and whether he acted with conscious indifference or reckless disregard, further factual development was appropriate.
The court affirmed the order denying the City’s plea and remanded the case for jurisdictional discovery. The affirmance was procedural rather than a final determination that the TTCA waived the City’s immunity.
Practical Application
For family-law litigators, Springtown supplies a useful framework when a jurisdictional challenge depends on evidence outside the pleadings.
In a UCCJEA dispute, for example, the parties may disagree over where the child lived during the six months preceding commencement of the proceeding, whether an absence from a state was temporary, whether another state retains continuing exclusive jurisdiction, or whether Texas may exercise temporary emergency jurisdiction. Counsel seeking discovery should connect each request to a specific statutory jurisdictional fact. Relevant evidence may include school and medical records, travel records, leases, utility records, childcare records, communications concerning the child’s location, and testimony about the duration and purpose of an absence.
In a UIFSA proceeding, targeted discovery may address the respondent’s Texas contacts, the parties’ residences, the child’s residence, prior support proceedings, consent to jurisdiction, or the tribunal possessing continuing exclusive jurisdiction. The request should distinguish facts bearing on adjudicative authority from the underlying merits of support.
The opinion is also relevant when governmental immunity arises within a family-law setting—for example, when claims are asserted against a governmental unit or governmental employee in litigation related to services, records, property, or alleged tortious conduct. If immunity turns on disputed facts, the party opposing a plea should identify the exact statutory waiver, the factual prerequisites to that waiver, and the limited discovery needed to test the governmental entity’s evidence.
The strategic point is not simply to ask for “more discovery.” Counsel should identify the disputed jurisdictional propositions, explain why the current record does not resolve them, list the evidence likely to illuminate those propositions, and propose a reasonable schedule. A request framed in that manner is more likely to be viewed as jurisdictional discovery contemplated by Springtown, 4 Families of Hobby, and Miranda.
Conversely, a party presenting an early jurisdictional challenge should anticipate whether the supporting evidence leaves material factual gaps. If the question is genuinely fact-dependent, counsel should consider proposing phased discovery and a prompt renewed hearing rather than insisting on a final determination from an incomplete record.
Checklists
Requesting Jurisdictional Discovery
- Identify the statute or doctrine governing the jurisdictional question.
- Separate jurisdictional facts from facts relevant only to the merits.
- Specify each material jurisdictional fact that remains disputed.
- Explain why the existing pleadings and evidence do not resolve that fact.
- Identify particular documents, recordings, data, or testimony likely to supply the answer.
- Tailor written discovery and deposition topics to the jurisdictional issue.
- Propose a defined discovery period rather than an open-ended delay.
- Request a scheduling order setting discovery deadlines and a renewed jurisdictional hearing.
- Preserve the request in a written response, motion, or verified request when appropriate.
- Obtain an express written ruling or ensure the written order preserves further jurisdictional consideration.
Building a UCCJEA Record
- Prepare a precise chronology of the child’s physical location.
- Determine the date the Texas proceeding commenced.
- Calculate the relevant six-month home-state period.
- Identify every absence and develop evidence concerning whether it was temporary.
- Obtain school, daycare, medical, counseling, and extracurricular records.
- Collect leases, utility records, travel records, and other residence evidence.
- Identify prior custody proceedings and obtain certified copies of relevant orders.
- Determine whether another state has made an initial child-custody determination.
- Address continuing exclusive jurisdiction before relying on modification jurisdiction.
- Request interstate judicial communication when required or strategically appropriate.
- Make a record of any communication between courts as required by the UCCJEA.
- Distinguish temporary emergency jurisdiction from authority to enter a final custody determination.
Building a UIFSA Record
- Identify all prior support orders and the issuing tribunals.
- Obtain certified copies of existing orders and registration materials.
- Determine the present residence of each party and the child.
- Identify the statutory basis asserted for personal jurisdiction.
- Develop evidence concerning Texas contacts relevant to UIFSA’s long-arm provisions.
- Determine which tribunal has continuing exclusive jurisdiction.
- Examine whether the parties filed written consents affecting jurisdiction.
- Separate jurisdiction to establish support from jurisdiction to modify an existing order.
- Confirm compliance with registration, notice, and contest deadlines.
- Request discovery limited to the disputed jurisdictional predicates.
Presenting an Early Jurisdictional Challenge
- Determine whether the challenge concerns pleadings, jurisdictional facts, or both.
- Identify whether the jurisdictional facts overlap with the merits.
- Support factual assertions with competent, admissible evidence.
- Anticipate the discovery necessary to test declarations, affidavits, or business records.
- Disclose and preserve recordings, electronic data, dispatch records, and comparable evidence.
- Address known contrary evidence in the plea rather than leaving unexplained gaps.
- Consider proposing phased jurisdictional discovery.
- Request a prompt renewed hearing after completion of limited discovery.
- Draft the proposed order to clarify whether the ruling is final or permits further factual development.
- Preserve objections to discovery that extends beyond the jurisdictional question.
Preserving the Appellate Record
- File the request for jurisdictional discovery in writing.
- Identify the specific evidence sought and its expected relevance.
- Include proposed deadlines or a requested continuance period.
- Ensure that exhibits are formally admitted or otherwise included in the appellate record.
- Obtain a reporter’s record of the jurisdictional hearing when available.
- Secure a written order accurately reflecting the trial court’s ruling.
- Do not rely on oral comments to establish the basis of the ruling.
- If discovery is denied, make a record showing how the missing evidence bears on jurisdiction.
- If the plea is denied pending discovery, seek clarification about renewal and scheduling.
- Distinguish a provisional denial from a final merits determination on jurisdiction.
Citation
City of Springtown v. Hogue, No. 02-26-00423-CV, ___ S.W.3d ___ (Tex. App.—Fort Worth Nov. 12, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
Family Law Crossover
The procedural mechanism recognized in Springtown is a discretionary deferral of a fact-dependent jurisdictional ruling so the parties can conduct reasonable, targeted discovery. A trial court confronted with an evidence-based jurisdictional challenge need not decide disputed jurisdictional facts on an undeveloped record merely because the challenge has been presented through a plea to the jurisdiction. The court may deny the plea without finally resolving jurisdiction, permit discovery directed to the controlling jurisdictional facts, and revisit the issue after the record has been developed.
In Texas family litigation, that procedure may arise when UCCJEA jurisdiction turns on disputed evidence concerning home-state residence, temporary absences, continuing exclusive jurisdiction, or temporary emergency jurisdiction. It may similarly arise under UIFSA when adjudicative authority depends on residence, prior orders, consent, or statutory contacts with Texas. The discovery must remain proportional and tied to the jurisdictional issue; Springtown does not convert a jurisdictional dispute into unrestricted merits discovery or alter statutory directives requiring expedited handling.
Practitioners should therefore frame the requested procedure expressly: identify the fact-dependent jurisdictional issue, explain why the present record is insufficient, specify the limited discovery needed, propose a short completion period, and request a renewed jurisdictional setting. That approach gives the trial court a principled basis to develop the record without prematurely resolving disputed facts that control its authority to act.
~~42e7d3ec-8b40-480b-b43e-c49cbc2118bb~~
Share this content:
