Anders Counsel Must Remain Through Petition for Review | In re D.A.R. (2026)
In the Interest of D.A.R., a Child, 12-26-00265-CV, November 18, 2026.
On appeal from County Court at Law of Cherokee County, Texas
Synopsis
Court-appointed counsel in a parental-rights termination appeal may not withdraw merely because counsel filed an Anders brief and the court of appeals concluded that the appeal was frivolous. The statutory right to counsel continues through proceedings in the Texas Supreme Court, and counsel must timely file an Anders-compliant petition for review if the parent, after consultation, seeks further review.
Relevance to Family Law
The decision directly affects termination cases and other child-protection proceedings in which an indigent parent is entitled to appointed counsel. It establishes that appellate representation does not end when the intermediate court affirms the termination order—even after an Anders submission—and requires counsel to preserve the parent’s ability to seek Texas Supreme Court review.
The holding generally does not create a right to appointed appellate counsel in an ordinary private divorce, conservatorship, possession, child-support, or marital-property dispute. It nevertheless offers a broader practice lesson for all family-law appeals: counsel should define the scope and duration of appellate representation carefully, calendar every post-opinion deadline, consult promptly with the client about further review, and avoid assuming that affirmance automatically terminates counsel’s professional or court-imposed obligations.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
The Department of Family and Protective Services filed an amended petition seeking protection of D.A.R., appointment as conservator, and termination of the parental rights of D.R.R. and M.R. The Department was appointed temporary managing conservator, while the parents received limited access to and possession of the child.
At the final hearing, the evidence showed that D.R.R. repeatedly failed to submit to required drug testing. He also had a history of methamphetamine use, tested positive multiple times while the case was pending, and did not successfully complete substance-abuse counseling. The trial court terminated his parental rights. The mother did not participate in the appeal.
D.R.R.’s appointed appellate counsel filed a brief under Anders v. California and Gainous v. State, representing that the appeal presented no nonfrivolous grounds. D.R.R. filed a pro se response. Counsel also moved for leave to withdraw, and the Twelfth Court of Appeals carried that motion with the merits.
The court agreed with counsel that the appeal was wholly frivolous and affirmed the termination judgment. It nevertheless denied counsel’s motion to withdraw because appointed counsel’s obligations continued through any proceedings in the Texas Supreme Court.
Issues Decided
-
Whether the termination judgment should be affirmed after appointed counsel filed an Anders brief and the parent filed a pro se response.
-
Whether appointed appellate counsel could withdraw once the court of appeals determined that the termination appeal was wholly frivolous.
-
Whether appointed counsel’s continuing obligations include consulting with the parent and, if the parent desires further review, filing an Anders-compliant petition for review in the Texas Supreme Court.
Rules Applied
-
Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738 (1967). Appointed counsel who concludes that an appeal is frivolous must follow the Anders procedure rather than simply abandoning the appeal or presenting arguments counsel considers meritless.
-
Gainous v. State, 436 S.W.2d 137 (Tex. Crim. App. 1969). Texas recognizes the Anders procedure for appointed appellate counsel who determines that no arguable grounds for appeal exist.
-
In re P.M., 520 S.W.3d 24, 27 (Tex. 2016). In a suit seeking termination of parental rights, the right to counsel extends to all proceedings in the Texas Supreme Court, including the filing of a petition for review. When the parent seeks review after an Anders disposition, appointed counsel must file a petition satisfying Anders standards.
-
A.C. v. Texas Department of Family & Protective Services, No. 03-16-00543-CV, 2016 WL 5874880, at *1 n.2 (Tex. App.—Austin Oct. 5, 2016, no pet.) (mem. op.). The Twelfth Court cited this decision as additional support for counsel’s continuing obligations following an Anders appeal.
-
Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 43.2. The court applied the rule governing the types of judgments available to a court of appeals and affirmed the trial court’s judgment.
Application
Appointed counsel reviewed the record and concluded that no nonfrivolous appellate issue existed. Counsel therefore filed an Anders brief and requested permission to withdraw. D.R.R. exercised his opportunity to respond pro se, but the court ultimately agreed with counsel’s assessment that the appeal was wholly frivolous and affirmed the termination judgment.
That conclusion did not resolve the separate question of whether counsel’s appointment had ended. Applying In re P.M., the court distinguished between determining that the appeal lacked merit and determining that counsel had completed the representation. Although no reversible issue justified relief in the court of appeals, D.R.R. retained the right to consult with appointed counsel about pursuing review in the Texas Supreme Court.
Because proceedings in the Texas Supreme Court fall within the protected period of representation, permitting withdrawal immediately after the court of appeals’ decision would leave the parent unrepresented during the petition-for-review stage. The court therefore denied the motion to withdraw. If D.R.R. elects to seek review after consulting with counsel, counsel must timely file a petition for review that complies with Anders standards.
Holding
The court affirmed the judgment terminating D.R.R.’s parental rights. After considering counsel’s Anders submission and D.R.R.’s pro se response, the court agreed that the appeal was wholly frivolous.
The court denied appointed counsel’s motion to withdraw. Under In re P.M., the right to appointed counsel in a parental-rights termination case continues through all proceedings in the Texas Supreme Court, including preparation and filing of a petition for review.
The court further held that, if D.R.R. desires Texas Supreme Court review after consulting with counsel, appointed counsel must timely file a petition for review satisfying the standards applicable to an Anders brief. The intermediate court’s affirmance does not itself discharge counsel’s appointment.
Practical Application
Treat an Anders affirmance as a transition, not the end of the appointment. Appointed counsel should not close the file when the court of appeals issues its opinion. Counsel must review the opinion and judgment, communicate with the client, explain the available avenues for further review, and calendar all applicable deadlines.
Consult promptly and document the client’s decision. Termination appeals move on accelerated schedules, and delay can forfeit review. Counsel should promptly provide the parent with the opinion and judgment, explain the function and limited scope of a petition for review, and obtain a documented decision about whether the parent wants to proceed.
Prepare an Anders-compliant petition when review is requested. Counsel is not required to manufacture an arguable issue. But if the parent wants Texas Supreme Court review, counsel must timely file a petition that candidly addresses the record and controlling law while satisfying the procedural requirements identified in In re P.M.
Do not rely on a withdrawal motion filed with the Anders brief. A court of appeals may deny the request even while accepting counsel’s assessment that the case is frivolous. Counsel should continue monitoring the case unless and until the appointment is formally discharged by the proper court.
Preserve the merits record from the beginning of the termination case. Although the principal published lesson concerns appellate counsel’s continuing duties, the underlying facts illustrate recurring termination risks. Missed drug tests, repeated positive tests, and incomplete substance-abuse services can become central evidence supporting termination. Trial counsel should challenge inaccurate evidence, preserve objections, document legitimate explanations for noncompliance, and present evidence of completed services and changed conditions.
Distinguish appointed termination appeals from private family-law appeals. In an ordinary divorce, custody, support, or property appeal, the attorney-client agreement and applicable procedural orders ordinarily define the duration of representation. Even there, prudent appellate counsel should address rehearing, en banc reconsideration, mandamus relief, and petition-for-review responsibilities expressly rather than assuming representation ends upon issuance of the court of appeals’ opinion.
Checklists
After Receiving an Anders Decision
- Review the court of appeals’ opinion and judgment immediately.
- Confirm whether the court granted or denied the motion to withdraw.
- Do not close the file solely because the judgment was affirmed.
- Calculate the deadlines for rehearing, en banc reconsideration, and petition for review.
- Determine whether the appeal is governed by accelerated appellate deadlines.
- Send the client the opinion and judgment through a verifiable delivery method.
- Preserve the appellate record, exhibits, correspondence, and deadline calculations.
- Continue monitoring notices and orders from the court of appeals and Texas Supreme Court.
Client Consultation About Further Review
- Explain that the court of appeals affirmed the termination judgment.
- Explain the court’s conclusion that the appeal was wholly frivolous.
- Discuss the purpose and limitations of a petition for review.
- Advise the client of the applicable filing deadline.
- Determine whether the client wants to seek Texas Supreme Court review.
- Document the consultation and the client’s instructions.
- Use appropriate procedures if the client cannot be located or will not respond.
- Avoid treating silence as an automatic discharge from the appointment.
Preparing an Anders-Compliant Petition for Review
- Confirm that the client has requested further review.
- Reexamine the complete appellate record and the court of appeals’ opinion.
- Verify the preservation status of any potential issue.
- Address the governing termination standards and controlling precedent.
- Identify anything in the record that could arguably support review.
- Explain candidly why potential issues do or do not present reversible error.
- Comply with the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure governing petitions for review.
- File the petition within the applicable deadline.
- Serve the petition and provide the client with a copy.
- Continue representation until counsel is formally discharged.
Preserving a Termination Case for Appeal
- Obtain rulings on all objections and requested relief.
- Preserve challenges to the legal and factual sufficiency of the evidence.
- Verify that the termination grounds and best-interest findings appear in the final order.
- Develop the record regarding drug testing, including missed tests and disputed results.
- Document completion of services, counseling, treatment, and parenting requirements.
- Present evidence explaining alleged noncompliance where a legitimate explanation exists.
- Preserve constitutional and statutory complaints at the earliest appropriate stage.
- Request findings, records, and reporter’s records necessary for accelerated appellate review.
- File the notice of appeal and related indigency materials promptly.
- Maintain current contact information for the parent throughout the appeal.
Defining the Scope of Representation in Other Family-Law Appeals
- State in the engagement agreement whether representation includes rehearing or en banc review.
- Address whether the engagement includes a petition for review in the Texas Supreme Court.
- Explain any separate fee arrangement for post-judgment appellate proceedings.
- Calendar all deadlines even if further representation has not yet been confirmed.
- Provide written notice before terminating or limiting the engagement.
- Obtain any required court approval before withdrawing.
- Protect the client’s interests while a withdrawal request remains pending.
- Transfer the record and file promptly if successor counsel appears.
Citation
In re D.A.R., No. 12-26-00265-CV, slip op. at 3 (Tex. App.—Tyler Nov. 18, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
~~a60d66bc-1320-4b75-9bdd-eb91090f962e~~
Share this content:
