Loading Now

CROSSOVER: No Jurat, No Reinstatement: Defective Rule 165a Verification Ends the Appeal

New Texas Court of Appeals Opinion - Analyzed for Family Law Attorneys

Scott v. Nederland Tank Wash Inc., 09-26-00172-CV, November 19, 2026.

On appeal from 58th District Court, Jefferson County, Texas

Synopsis

A motion to reinstate following dismissal for want of prosecution is not verified under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 165a(3) when counsel’s supporting statement is neither sworn before an authorized officer nor signed under penalty of perjury. Because the defective motion did not extend plenary power or the appellate timetable, the Ninth Court of Appeals dismissed the subsequently filed appeal for want of jurisdiction.

Relevance to Family Law

Dismissals for want of prosecution frequently arise in divorce, SAPCR, modification, enforcement, and post-divorce property proceedings when a case remains inactive, deadlines are missed, or counsel does not appear at a dismissal docket. If a family law case is dismissed, a timely motion to reinstate must be properly verified—not merely labeled “verified”—to extend the trial court’s plenary power and the deadline for filing a notice of appeal. A defective verification can therefore prevent both reinstatement after the ordinary plenary-power period and appellate review of the dismissal, regardless of the potential merits of the underlying family law claims.

Case Summary

Fact Summary

The trial court dismissed the plaintiffs’ case for want of prosecution on January 20, 2026. On February 18, 2026, within 30 days of the dismissal order, the plaintiffs filed a motion to reinstate.

The motion included a document titled “VERIFICATION,” signed by trial counsel. It recited that counsel had appeared before an “undersigned authority,” had been duly sworn, had read the motion, and had personal knowledge that its factual statements were true and correct. But no notary or other authorized officer signed the document, and it bore no notarial seal or jurat. The verification and motion also omitted the phrase “under penalty of perjury.”

The plaintiffs later filed their notice of appeal on April 22, 2026. That notice was timely only if the motion to reinstate qualified as a verified motion under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 165a(3) and thereby extended the appellate timetable.

An appellee challenged the appellate court’s jurisdiction and moved to dismiss. The appellants responded that the signed verification constituted a sworn affidavit despite the inadvertently omitted jurat. They also argued that the appellee had waived the defect by failing to object in the trial court, which allegedly deprived them of an opportunity to cure it.

Issues Decided

  • Whether a statement labeled as a “verification” satisfies Rule 165a(3) when it is signed by counsel but lacks a notary’s attestation, jurat, and seal.

  • Whether the statement can qualify as an unsworn declaration under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 132.001 when it is not signed under penalty of perjury.

  • Whether the opposing party waives the verification defect by failing to object in the trial court.

  • Whether the defective motion to reinstate extended the trial court’s plenary power or the appellate deadline.

  • Whether the court of appeals had jurisdiction over a notice of appeal filed after the ordinary appellate deadline and the corresponding 15-day extension period.

Rules Applied

  • Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 165a(3): A motion to reinstate following a dismissal for want of prosecution must be verified by the movant or the movant’s attorney. A timely verified motion extends the trial court’s plenary power.

  • Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 132.001: A compliant unsworn declaration may be used in place of a written sworn verification. The declaration must be subscribed as true under penalty of perjury and otherwise comply with the statute.

  • Texas Government Code section 312.011(1): An affidavit is a written statement of facts signed by the declarant, sworn before an officer authorized to administer oaths, and officially certified by that officer.

  • Texas Government Code sections 406.013 and 406.016: These provisions govern a notary’s seal and performance of notarial acts.

  • In re K.M.L., 443 S.W.3d 101, 109 (Tex. 2014): A verification is a formal declaration made before an authorized officer through which the declarant swears to the truth of the document’s statements. Verification ordinarily requires an oath, affirmation, or equivalent statutory declaration.

  • McConnell v. May, 800 S.W.2d 194, 194 (Tex. 1990): An unverified motion to reinstate does not extend the trial court’s plenary power beyond 30 days after the dismissal order is signed.

  • Novoa v. Viramontes, 553 S.W.3d 45, 51 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2018, no pet.): An unverified motion to reinstate, like a verified motion filed outside the 30-day period, is insufficient to extend plenary power.

  • Mansions in the Forest, L.P. v. Montgomery County, 365 S.W.3d 314, 316–17 (Tex. 2012): An omitted jurat may constitute a formal defect in summary-judgment evidence that must be raised in the trial court. The Ninth Court distinguished that evidentiary context from a verification necessary to establish appellate jurisdiction.

  • Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure 26.1 and 26.3: These rules establish the ordinary notice-of-appeal deadline and the limited 15-day period in which an appellate court may grant an extension.

Application

The court began with the face of the purported verification. Although the document stated that counsel had appeared before an authority and had been duly sworn, no notary or other authorized officer certified that an oath had actually been administered. The document therefore did not qualify as an affidavit under the Government Code. Calling the document a “verification,” and including language typically found in an affidavit, could not substitute for the required official attestation.

The alternative statutory route was also unavailable. Section 132.001 permits an unsworn declaration to replace a sworn verification, but the declarant must sign the statement under penalty of perjury. Neither the motion nor counsel’s verification contained that language. The document consequently was neither an affidavit nor a compliant unsworn declaration.

The court rejected the appellants’ waiver argument. In Mansions in the Forest, the omitted jurat concerned summary-judgment evidence, and the opposing party’s failure to object in the trial court implicated ordinary error-preservation rules. Here, verification was not merely an evidentiary formality. A timely verified motion to reinstate was necessary to extend the trial court’s plenary power and the appellate timetable. The jurisdictional consequence distinguished this case from a curable defect in summary-judgment proof.

Because the February 18 motion was unverified, it did not extend plenary power beyond 30 days after the January 20 dismissal order. It likewise did not extend the notice-of-appeal deadline. The April 22 notice of appeal was filed after both the ordinary deadline and the 15-day extension period permitted by Rule 26.3. The court therefore lacked appellate jurisdiction.

Holding

The court held that counsel’s signed statement did not satisfy Rule 165a(3). Without an authorized officer’s attestation, the document was not a sworn affidavit or verification.

The court further held that the document did not qualify as an unsworn declaration under section 132.001 because it was not signed under penalty of perjury.

The court held that the defect was not rendered immaterial by the appellee’s failure to object in the trial court. Unlike a formal defect in summary-judgment evidence, the absence of a valid Rule 165a verification determined whether the motion extended plenary power and the appellate timetable.

Finally, the court held that the unverified motion did not extend the deadline for filing a notice of appeal. Because the notice was untimely even under Rule 26.3’s 15-day extension period, the court dismissed the appeal for want of jurisdiction.

Practical Application

Family law practitioners should treat verification of a Rule 165a motion as a jurisdictional deadline issue, not as a clerical formality that can be corrected whenever opposing counsel raises it. The safest practice is to file the motion early and use either a completed notarial jurat or a fully compliant section 132.001 declaration.

In a divorce or SAPCR dismissed at a dismissal docket, counsel should immediately determine the date the written dismissal order was signed. The 30-day period for a verified motion to reinstate runs from the signing date, and a defective filing may leave no opportunity to cure after that period expires.

The verification should also be executed by a person with an adequate factual basis for the motion. Rule 165a permits verification by the movant or the movant’s attorney, but formal compliance with the oath requirement does not establish the substantive grounds for reinstatement. The motion still must address whether the failure that led to dismissal was intentional or the result of conscious indifference, rather than accident, mistake, or another reasonable explanation.

Counsel should independently calendar the appellate deadlines from the dismissal order. Do not assume that a document titled “Verified Motion to Reinstate” extends the deadline. Before relying on the extended timetable, confirm that the filed version—not merely the draft—contains either a signed jurat completed by an authorized officer or a compliant declaration expressly made under penalty of perjury.

The decision is particularly important when a dismissed case concerns conservatorship, possession, child support, enforcement, or property rights. Even if another proceeding could eventually be filed, limitations, finality, accrued support, property claims, standing, or changed circumstances may make loss of the existing case consequential. Preservation of reinstatement and appellate remedies should therefore be handled as a same-day priority.

Checklists

Responding to a Dismissal for Want of Prosecution

  • Obtain and review the signed dismissal order immediately.
  • Confirm the date the order was signed, rather than relying on the hearing date or the date notice was received.
  • Calendar the 30-day deadline for filing a verified motion to reinstate.
  • Calendar the ordinary notice-of-appeal deadline independently.
  • Calendar the final day of the 15-day extension period under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 26.3.
  • Determine whether Rule 306a may apply if notice of the dismissal was delayed, and preserve that issue through the required sworn procedure.
  • Request a prompt hearing on the motion to reinstate.
  • Continue monitoring both trial-court and appellate deadlines while the motion remains pending.

Verifying the Motion to Reinstate

  • Decide whether the motion will be verified by the client or by counsel.
  • Confirm that the declarant has personal knowledge or an adequate factual basis for the statements being verified.
  • If using an affidavit, have the declarant appear before a notary or other officer authorized to administer oaths.
  • Confirm that the officer signs the jurat and applies any required seal.
  • If using an unsworn declaration, comply with Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 132.001.
  • Include an express statement that the declaration is made “under penalty of perjury.”
  • Confirm that all identifying and execution information required by section 132.001 is included.
  • Review the final signed document before filing.
  • Download the file-stamped version and verify that the jurat, seal, signature, and declaration language appear in the filed copy.

Drafting the Reinstatement Grounds

  • Identify the event that resulted in dismissal.
  • Explain why the failure was not intentional or the result of conscious indifference.
  • State the accident, mistake, scheduling issue, notice problem, or other reasonable explanation with specificity.
  • Support material facts with the verified motion and any appropriate evidence.
  • Address the case’s prosecution history and any activity demonstrating diligence.
  • Request reinstatement and any necessary amendment to the docket-control order.
  • Obtain a reporter’s record of the reinstatement hearing when appellate review may be necessary.

Protecting Appellate Jurisdiction

  • Do not assume that a motion extends the appellate timetable merely because it was timely filed.
  • Confirm that the motion is one of the instruments recognized by Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 26.1.
  • Confirm that a Rule 165a motion to reinstate is validly verified.
  • File a protective notice of appeal if there is any uncertainty about the motion’s validity or the applicable deadline.
  • If the ordinary deadline has passed, evaluate immediately whether a notice of appeal and extension motion can still be filed within Rule 26.3’s 15-day period.
  • Remember that an appellate court cannot enlarge the notice-of-appeal deadline beyond the authority supplied by the appellate rules.
  • Preserve proof concerning the date notice of the dismissal was received if Rule 306a may be implicated.

Family Law File-Control Review

  • Check inactive divorce, SAPCR, modification, enforcement, and post-divorce property cases for dismissal notices.
  • Assign responsibility for monitoring dismissal dockets and electronic-service notices.
  • Confirm that lead counsel, supporting counsel, and staff share the same deadline calculations.
  • Maintain approved affidavit and section 132.001 declaration forms.
  • Require a second-person review of all jurisdiction-sensitive filings.
  • Audit the file after submission to ensure the complete, executed document was accepted by the clerk.

Citation

Scott v. Nederland Tank Wash Inc., No. 09-26-00172-CV, slip op. (Tex. App.—Beaumont Nov. 19, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).

Full Opinion

Read the full opinion from the Ninth Court of Appeals.

Family Law Crossover

The crossover rule is straightforward: after a dismissal for want of prosecution, only a timely and properly verified Rule 165a motion to reinstate extends the trial court’s plenary power and the appellate timetable. Verification requires either an oath administered and certified by an authorized officer or a section 132.001 unsworn declaration signed under penalty of perjury. A signature, a “verification” label, or affidavit-style language without one of those formal mechanisms is insufficient.

In family law practice, the issue may arise when a divorce, custody case, modification, enforcement action, or post-divorce property proceeding is dismissed after inactivity or a missed setting. Counsel may file a motion to reinstate within 30 days and assume that the motion preserves jurisdiction. Under Scott, however, timeliness alone is not enough. If the verification is defective, the motion does not extend plenary power, and a notice of appeal filed under the assumed extended timetable may be untimely.

The procedural lesson is to separate three inquiries: whether the motion was timely filed, whether it was validly verified, and whether it substantively establishes grounds for reinstatement. Each must be satisfied. Because verification can determine both the trial court’s continuing authority and the court of appeals’ jurisdiction, the executed and file-stamped motion should be reviewed with the same care as a notice of appeal.

~~f1e2893a-5ce7-48f0-9ef9-63eb4ff9493a~~

Share this content:

Tom Daley is a board-certified family law attorney with extensive experience practicing across the United States, primarily in Texas. He represents clients in all aspects of family law, including negotiation, settlement, litigation, trial, and appeals.