Section 161.001(D)–(E) Endangerment | In re K.C.C. & P.G.C. (2026)
In the Interest of K.C.C. and P.G.C., Children, 04-26-00491-CV, November 20, 2026.
On appeal from County Court at Law, Val Verde County, Texas
Synopsis
The Fourth Court of Appeals held that legally and factually sufficient evidence supported termination under Texas Family Code § 161.001(b)(1)(D) and (E) when Mother remained connected to Father despite his violence, minimized the abuse, and failed to protect two infants from repeated and serious injuries. Mother’s completion of court-ordered services did not negate the historical evidence of endangerment or establish that she could safely protect the children going forward.
Relevance to Family Law
Although this is a termination case, its reasoning has direct implications for divorce, conservatorship, possession, protective-order, and modification litigation. A parent need not personally inflict an injury to face severe consequences; knowingly permitting a child to remain around an abusive parent or partner can support endangerment findings and materially affect conservatorship, geographic restrictions, supervised possession, and access conditions. The opinion also illustrates why financial dependence, reconciliation, service-plan completion, and verbal assurances of separation may carry limited weight when the record shows continued contact, minimization, delayed protective action, or inconsistent explanations.
In divorce and SAPCR cases involving family violence, practitioners should treat a parent’s protective capacity as an independent issue. The question is not limited to whether that parent committed violence. It includes whether the parent recognized the danger, acted promptly, maintained separation, complied with safety restrictions, and demonstrated the ability to protect the children outside a supervised setting.
Case Summary
Fact Summary
The Department first became involved in November 2023, when seven-week-old K.C.C. was taken to the hospital with bruising on her face and body. Mother reported hearing muffled screaming while Father was caring for the infant. Father initially prevented Mother from holding the child and later admitted that he had bruised her. Although Mother left with K.C.C. and sought medical care, she characterized Father’s conduct as accidental and stated that she had not seen him intentionally hurt the child.
Imaging revealed healing “bucket-handle” fractures near both knees. The medical evidence indicated that the fractures resulted from pulling or twisting forces inconsistent with routine infant care. A child-abuse specialist considered the fractures, patterned bruising, and Father’s reported admissions substantial evidence of physical abuse. The physician also questioned Mother’s willingness and ability to protect the child.
Mother entered a women’s shelter but continued communicating with Father and eventually resumed living with him. After another unexplained bruise was discovered, K.C.C. was placed with a family friend. Both parents subsequently completed services, obtained housing, and participated in visitation. The Department returned K.C.C. in June 2024 and closed the initial case the following month.
While pregnant with P.G.C., however, Mother experienced additional violence from Father. Her later protective-order affidavit described shoving, punching, kicking, biting, and thrown objects. In one incident, Father struck Mother in the abdomen while she was eight months pregnant. Mother nevertheless continued to believe that Father had changed and identified him as her principal source of financial support.
P.G.C. was born in September 2024. Within weeks, the infant experienced vomiting and an unusual increase in head circumference. Mother testified that she wanted to take the child to the hospital, but Father warned that CPS would become involved and remove the children. Although Mother later claimed she asked the pediatrician to investigate possible abuse, the medical records reflected that she denied the possibility of abuse.
Further testing disclosed severe injuries, including posterior rib fractures in different stages of healing, bilateral skull fractures, intracranial bleeding, and subconjunctival hemorrhages. The medical experts found no disease or accidental explanation accounting for the constellation of injuries. The differing stages of healing supported the conclusion that P.G.C. had sustained separate traumatic events.
Mother offered or endorsed several alternative explanations, including a dog jumping on the child, a difficult delivery, birth-related hemorrhaging, and hydrocephalus. The medical evidence refuted those theories. Mother eventually acknowledged that Father caused the skull fractures but continued to dispute his responsibility for other injuries.
Father voluntarily relinquished his parental rights. Mother completed the services required by the Department, consistently visited the children, and did not test positive for drugs. Nevertheless, the Department and other professionals remained concerned about her protective capacity, parenting ability, continued ties to Father, and incomplete recognition of the danger he presented.
The trial court directed the Department to assist Mother in obtaining a protective order. Mother delayed applying because she did not want Father arrested or otherwise placed in trouble. She ultimately obtained an agreed ten-year protective order, but evidence continued to suggest contact or association with Father. Mother offered explanations for observations of her vehicle at Father’s workplace, Father’s vehicle at her apartment, and her presence at Father’s residence.
Questions surrounding Mother’s later pregnancy also affected her credibility. Her account of when she became pregnant and the identity of the father did not align with earlier statements suggesting that she might have been pregnant months before the alleged encounter. Her therapist testified that Mother loved the children and would not intentionally injure them, but remained concerned about Mother’s ability to protect them from another person.
Issues Decided
-
Whether legally sufficient evidence supported termination under Texas Family Code § 161.001(b)(1)(D) based on Mother’s knowing placement of, or allowance of, the children in endangering conditions or surroundings.
-
Whether legally sufficient evidence supported termination under § 161.001(b)(1)(E) based on Mother’s conduct, including omissions and continued association with Father, that endangered the children’s physical or emotional well-being.
-
Whether the evidence was factually sufficient to support the subsection (D) and (E) findings under the clear-and-convincing-evidence standard.
-
Whether sufficient evidence supported the trial court’s finding that termination was in each child’s best interest.
Rules Applied
Texas Family Code § 161.001(b) authorizes termination when the Department proves by clear and convincing evidence at least one statutory predicate ground and that termination is in the child’s best interest. Clear and convincing evidence is evidence that produces in the factfinder a firm belief or conviction regarding the truth of the allegations.
Subsection (D) concerns the child’s conditions or surroundings. It applies when a parent knowingly places or knowingly allows a child to remain in conditions or surroundings that endanger the child’s physical or emotional well-being. The analysis focuses on the child’s environment, including the conduct of parents or other persons in the home when that conduct creates a dangerous environment.
Subsection (E) focuses on parental conduct. It applies when a parent engages in conduct, or knowingly places a child with persons who engage in conduct, that endangers the child’s physical or emotional well-being. Unlike a single environmental condition, subsection (E) generally examines a voluntary, deliberate, and conscious course of conduct. The relevant conduct may include omissions and failures to protect; the parent need not personally inflict the injury.
“Endanger” means exposing a child to loss or injury or jeopardizing the child’s physical or emotional health. The Department is not required to prove that the parent intended to injure the child or that the parent’s conduct caused a particular injury.
In reviewing legal sufficiency, an appellate court considers the evidence in the light most favorable to the finding and asks whether a reasonable factfinder could have formed a firm belief or conviction. Factual-sufficiency review considers the entire record, including disputed or contrary evidence, to determine whether that evidence is so significant that the factfinder could not reasonably have formed the required firm belief or conviction.
Because findings under subsections (D) and (E) may have collateral consequences in later termination proceedings, appellate courts must review challenged findings under those provisions even when another predicate ground might otherwise sustain termination. Best interest is evaluated separately under § 161.001(b)(2), with consideration of the child’s needs, present and future danger, parental abilities, available programs, stability, plans for the child, and the parent’s acts, omissions, and explanations.
Application
The court viewed the case as involving more than an isolated failure to appreciate danger. K.C.C. suffered bruising and serious fractures while in Father’s care. Mother initially took protective action, but then minimized the incident, maintained contact with Father, left the shelter under circumstances involving that contact, and resumed living with him. Those events placed Mother on direct notice that Father presented a substantial danger to an infant.
The risk did not end after the first Department case closed. Father continued committing violence against Mother, including striking her abdomen during pregnancy. Mother nevertheless remained dependent on him and continued the relationship. When P.G.C. later developed alarming symptoms, Father discouraged hospital treatment because he feared CPS involvement. Mother did not immediately override that objection and obtain emergency care.
The severity and pattern of P.G.C.’s injuries were especially significant. Rib fractures of different ages indicated multiple traumatic events, while the skull fractures and intracranial bleeding were inconsistent with routine care or the accidental explanations offered. Mother’s changing theories, her minimization of Father’s responsibility, and the medical records contradicting her account permitted the trial court to question her credibility and insight.
For subsection (D), the evidence supported a finding that Mother knowingly allowed the children to remain in an environment made dangerous by Father’s violence. Her knowledge was established not merely by general allegations of domestic conflict, but by K.C.C.’s prior injuries, Father’s admissions, medical findings of abuse, professional warnings, and Father’s later violence toward Mother.
For subsection (E), the trial court could consider Mother’s continuing course of conduct: returning to Father, minimizing the abuse, failing to respond decisively to warning signs, delaying protective measures, maintaining disputed ties to Father, and offering explanations inconsistent with the medical evidence. Although Mother did not personally inflict the children’s injuries, her omissions and decisions supported a finding that she knowingly exposed them to danger.
Mother’s completion of services was favorable evidence, but it was not dispositive. The factfinder could distinguish technical completion from actual behavioral change. Participation in counseling, parenting classes, and domestic-violence programming did not erase the prior endangerment or compel a finding that Mother had developed the insight and protective capacity necessary to prevent future harm.
The same evidence informed the best-interest determination. The children were extremely young and vulnerable, had sustained repeated serious injuries, and required stable caregivers capable of recognizing and responding to danger. Evidence that they were bonded with their caregivers, coupled with ongoing concerns regarding Mother’s parenting ability, credibility, and association with Father, allowed the trial court to find that termination served their best interests.
Holding
The Fourth Court held that the evidence was legally and factually sufficient to support termination under § 161.001(b)(1)(D). A reasonable factfinder could form a firm belief that Mother knowingly allowed the children to remain in an environment endangered by Father’s violence and repeated abuse.
The court also held that legally and factually sufficient evidence supported termination under § 161.001(b)(1)(E). Mother’s continued relationship with Father, minimization of the abuse, delayed protective action, inconsistent explanations, and repeated failures to protect constituted evidence of an endangering course of conduct.
Mother’s completion of services did not require a contrary result. The trial court was entitled to assess whether those services produced meaningful change and to weigh Mother’s conduct, credibility, and continuing ties to Father more heavily than formal compliance.
The court further upheld the best-interest finding and affirmed the termination order.
Practical Application
For litigators, K.C.C. and P.G.C. reinforces that protective capacity should be developed as a separate evidentiary theme. In a custody case involving an abusive partner, it is not enough to ask whether the non-offending parent committed an assault. Discovery and trial preparation should address what that parent knew, when the parent knew it, what protective action followed, and whether the parent later resumed or concealed the relationship.
Service completion must also be tested for substance. Obtain counseling records when discoverable, service-provider testimony, protective-order materials, visitation observations, communications with the alleged abuser, and evidence of post-service conduct. A certificate of completion may establish attendance, but it does not conclusively establish insight, behavioral change, or an ability to protect.
In divorce proceedings, financial dependence should be anticipated and addressed through temporary support, exclusive use of a residence, interim attorney’s fees, temporary injunctions, protective orders, and appropriate possession restrictions. Financial dependence may explain why a client remained in a relationship, but it does not neutralize evidence that children were knowingly exposed to serious danger.
For conservatorship and possession disputes, counsel should consider requesting narrowly tailored safety provisions, including supervised possession, neutral exchanges, restrictions on a dangerous third party’s presence, alcohol or drug conditions when applicable, and injunctions against permitting contact between the children and a specified person. Any proposed restriction should be supported by evidence and drafted so that compliance can be objectively determined.
Credibility is particularly important in endangerment litigation. Medical records, text messages, location evidence, pregnancy timelines, protective-order affidavits, and prior sworn statements can convert discrepancies into a broader argument that the parent continues to minimize or conceal the dangerous relationship. Counsel defending the parent should identify and reconcile those discrepancies before trial rather than allowing them to emerge for the first time on cross-examination.
Checklists
Develop the Endangerment Record
- Identify each injury, the date discovered, and the child’s known caregivers during the relevant period.
- Obtain complete hospital, pediatric, radiology, and child-abuse evaluation records.
- Separate evidence concerning dangerous conditions under subsection (D) from evidence of parental conduct under subsection (E).
- Establish when the parent first received notice of abuse or a substantial risk of abuse.
- Document prior Department warnings, safety plans, removals, and service referrals.
- Determine whether injuries occurred in different stages of healing.
- Retain appropriate medical experts to address accidental and nonaccidental explanations.
- Preserve photographs, imaging, body diagrams, and recorded statements.
Prove or Contest Protective Capacity
- Determine whether the parent promptly sought medical care.
- Identify any delay caused by fear of CPS involvement or pressure from the alleged abuser.
- Examine whether the parent minimized, denied, or recharacterized known violence.
- Investigate continued contact through vehicles, residences, employment locations, financial records, telephone records, and social media.
- Compare trial testimony with medical histories, affidavits, police reports, and Department records.
- Determine whether the parent enforced no-contact directives and protective-order provisions.
- Develop evidence showing whether the parent can recognize danger without professional supervision.
- Address the parent’s plan for protecting the children after the litigation ends.
Evaluate Service-Plan Compliance
- Obtain more than certificates of completion.
- Identify the objectives of each service and whether the provider believed those objectives were met.
- Ask whether the parent accepted responsibility and demonstrated insight.
- Compare conduct before, during, and after services.
- Determine whether the parent implemented safety strategies outside supervised visits.
- Examine whether the parent remained emotionally or financially dependent on the dangerous partner.
- Prepare to explain why completion either did or did not reduce future risk.
- Distinguish attendance, participation, completion, and behavioral change.
Prepare the Non-Offending Parent’s Defense
- Acknowledge established injuries rather than advancing unsupported medical theories.
- Develop a reliable timeline of knowledge, separation, treatment, and protective action.
- Explain apparent inconsistencies before opposing counsel uses them as impeachment.
- Present corroboration of separation, including housing, finances, communications, and transportation arrangements.
- Demonstrate prompt enforcement of protective-order violations.
- Offer a specific childcare and safety plan that does not depend on the alleged abuser.
- Present testimony from treatment providers regarding insight and measurable progress.
- Show sustained protective conduct over time, not merely compliance immediately before trial.
Draft Temporary and Final Orders
- Specify whether possession must be supervised and identify an appropriate supervisor.
- Prohibit the dangerous person from being present during possession or access.
- Define permitted and prohibited communications.
- Establish neutral or protected exchange locations.
- Address possession of the residence, temporary support, and transportation to reduce dependence.
- Include objective conditions for any step-up possession schedule.
- Provide a method for documenting compliance and alleged violations.
- Ensure restrictions are supported by findings and tailored to the demonstrated risk.
Citation
In re K.C.C. & P.G.C., No. 04-26-00491-CV (Tex. App.—San Antonio Nov. 20, 2026, no pet. h.) (mem. op.).
Full Opinion
~~4f6bb501-8fdf-44a7-9018-055118851f18~~
Share this content:
